With the 21st-century period piece, cinema writes… | Little White Lies

Incoming

With the 21st-cen­tu­ry peri­od piece, cin­e­ma writes the his­to­ry books

21 Jan 2023

Words by Charles Bramesco

A woman in a black dress and jacket standing in a supermarket aisle, examining a product on the shelf.
A woman in a black dress and jacket standing in a supermarket aisle, examining a product on the shelf.
Films like Uncut Gems, Hus­tlers, and Lady Bird help us make sense of a mod­ern past.

The Wash­ing­ton Post’s Philip L. Gra­ham has been wide­ly cred­it­ed with declar­ing jour­nal­ism the first rough draft of his­to­ry,” though as first drafts go, it’s espe­cial­ly rough. If for no oth­er rea­son than posterity’s sake, the human species com­pul­sive­ly doc­u­ments each day from the blink­ered van­tage of real time, col­lec­tions of events and data syn­the­sized into instant reac­tions on the inter­net and pages of op-ed sec­tions. The goal is to make sense of a hec­tic present, but that ini­tial wave of chron­i­clers is hand­i­capped by imme­di­a­cy, the facts yet to cool into a nar­ra­tive vis­i­ble in full.

As a form of col­lec­tive pub­lic mem­o­ry, his­to­ry begins in earnest with the movies, which chan­nel polit­i­cal and social real­i­ties with the ben­e­fit of per­spec­tive into what crit­ic J. Hober­man termed the dream-life.” Now near­ly a quar­ter of the way into our young cen­tu­ry, a suf­fi­cient amount of time has passed for a lucid notion of this moment to take shape through the cin­e­ma, in par­tic­u­lar those films that empha­size their own dis­tance from the most recent chap­ter of the past. While every work of art is a rel­ic of the cul­tur­al con­di­tions under which it was made, some attempt to dra­ma­tize and ana­lyze the steps we’ve tak­en to get here.

Along these lines, I’ve been think­ing about the 21st-cen­tu­ry peri­od piece, for our pur­pos­es any movie pro­duced after the year 2000 and set in an ear­li­er part of the post-Y2K era. (Those with exten­sive flash­backs tak­ing place in 1999 or ear­li­er are dis­qual­i­fied, as are those with­out dis­cernible mark­ers or men­tions of set­ting.) Con­sid­ered as a canon, they illus­trate both the sig­nif­i­cance of chronol­o­gy-defin­ing events and the indi­vid­ual ram­i­fi­ca­tions they hold for the peo­ple involved — those fig­ures stand­ing astride major devel­op­ments and those just try­ing not to get crushed under­foot by the onward march of progress all around them.

Film­mak­ers have tak­en an inter­est in the Great Man” the­o­ry of his­to­ry ever since Charles Fos­ter Kane dropped his snow­globe, though as in that sear­ing por­trait of a thin­ly veiled William Ran­dolph Hearst, the con­cept is reversed as the flaws in our most influ­en­tial titans of indus­try and gov­ern­ment expand to nation­al and even glob­al pro­por­tions. The Social Net­works take on Face­book co-founder Mark Zucker­berg (how­ev­er inac­cu­rate, cast­ing the man we all now know as a par­tic­u­lar­ly advanced automa­ton in a light of emo­tion­al pro­fun­di­ty) diag­noses the whole of Sil­i­con Val­ley as the bit­ter revenge of the nerds, the advent of Big Tech reori­ent­ing pop­u­lar­i­ty at the cost of real-world iso­la­tion. In Maya, the fic­tion­al­ized intel­li­gence spe­cial­ist track­ing down Osama bin Laden in Zero Dark Thir­ty, the Unit­ed States’ war on ter­ror takes human form as she cross­es some cru­cial eth­i­cal lines in pur­suit of clo­sure, vengeance, or just a pos­i­tive report she can take back to her supe­ri­or. (The Hurt Lock­er, the oth­er half of Kathryn Bigelows GWOT Dip­tych, cat­a­logues the trau­mas that the Amer­i­can occu­pa­tion of the Mid­dle East inflicts on the sol­diers in the action.)

The coor­di­nat­ed attacks of 11 Sep­tem­ber loomed large over Hol­ly­wood in the fol­low­ing years, and not just when Amer­i­can Air­lines Flight 11 plowed into Robert Pat­tin­son to bring 2010’s romance Remem­ber Me to a stun­ning­ly mis­cal­cu­lat­ed twist end­ing. For teen girls Lady Bird of Lady Bird and Lisa of Ken­neth Lon­er­gans Mar­garet, the geopo­lit­i­cal hav­oc rag­ing in the back­ground of their lives throws their ado­les­cent solip­sism into sharp­er relief, the for­mer tun­ing it out where­as the lat­ter goes knee-jerk jin­go, both reac­tions more in response to the per­son­al quag­mires in their own lives.

More com­mon­ly, the fiery death scream­ing through the sky served as a reminder of life’s pre­cious­ness, John Cameron Mitchells pan­sex­u­al fan­ta­sia Short­bus thumb­ing its nose (and oth­er parts) at the fleet­ing nature of our mor­tal­i­ty with an orgy-jam­boree cel­e­brat­ing vital­i­ty. Brady Cor­bets ambi­tious Vox Lux con­spic­u­ous­ly announces its his­tor­i­cal bent ear­ly on with men­tions of Reaganomics and the pop-musi­cian dias­po­ra out of Swe­den, with its pri­ma­ry focus placed on the spec­ta­cles of vio­lence set­ting the terms of a chaot­ic new world; a Columbine-like inci­dent and the destruc­tion of the World Trade Cen­ter brack­et the first half in 2001, then a mass shoot­ing on a Euro­pean beach casts a pall over the 10s in the second.

Two women embracing in a dimly lit room, one wearing a purple dress and the other with dark hair.

As the rushed-to-mar­ket del­uge of COVID-relat­ed con­tent can attest, film­mak­ers are attract­ed to big hap­pen­ings, and the only oth­er cat­a­clysm that’s com­mand­ed as much ret­ro­spec­tive atten­tion as 911 is the finan­cial crash of 2008. Explained from a smug bird’s‑eye view in The Big Short and with boots-on-the-ground empa­thy in 99 Homes, the hous­ing cri­sis upend­ed the classed peck­ing order with the cru­el poet­ry of a Greek tragedy. See­ing rich peo­ple in pan­ic mode makes for sat­is­fy­ing dra­ma, the dri­ving engine of the scam­mer epic Hus­tlers, in which a squad of crafty strip­pers fleece the Wall Streeters com­ing in from a long day of fleec­ing hard­work­ing reg­u­lar folks. Their white-col­lar marks might as well make up the ensem­ble of Mar­gin Call, as a group of invest­ment bankers scram­ble to screw their clients out of their mon­ey before the firm goes bel­ly up.

Amer­i­ca is one big strip club,” says J. Lo in Hus­tlers, echo­ing Killing Them Softly’s part­ing sen­ti­ments of refu­ta­tion to the hol­low hope offered by Barack Obama’s elec­tion to the White House. The cyn­i­cism ram­pant in this time trans­lat­ed to shrewd self-inter­est where per­son­al account­ing was con­cerned, and no one kept a clos­er eye on her mon­ey than Chelsea, the high-end escort prowl­ing through down­town Manhattan’s finan­cial sec­tor in The Girl­friend Expe­ri­ence. As she pumps her var­i­ous johns for stock tips and oth­er advice that might give her a leg up as the econ­o­my goes into a tail­spin, direc­tor Steven Soder­bergh sug­gests that lean times have made us all just as ruth­less­ly bot­tom-line-mind­ed as she is. (2012’s Mag­ic Mike, anoth­er Soder­bergh film about the inter­sec­tion between sex work and cap­i­tal in the post-melt­down par­a­digm, shares in a cash-strapped dread trad­ed for a rise-and-grind can-do atti­tude in the sequel.)

In the numer­ous ripped-from-the-head­lines pic­tures rehash­ing the play­back of note­wor­thy true crimes — whether in inves­tiga­tive pieces like Spot­light and She Said, or buzzy report­ed-arti­cle adap­ta­tions in line with The Bling Ring and Bad Edu­ca­tion — sup­ple­men­tary details hint at the pieces of zeit­geist that might endure as part of the last­ing pop-cul­tur­al pic­ture. A pass­ing men­tion of nude-post­ing Red­dit boards in Red Rock­et sit­u­ates the film on the eve of Don­ald Trump’s 2016 elec­tion to the pres­i­den­cy, just after DIY porn had begun its great democ­ra­ti­za­tion but before the advent of Only­Fans. Uncut Gems plays out in 2012 because that’s when a suf­fi­cient­ly dra­mat­ic NBA play­off game hap­pened to take place, but direc­tors Ben­ny and Josh Safdie cap­i­tal­ize on the lack of smart­phones or legal­ized sports bet­ting in New York that would have rad­i­cal­ly altered Howard Ratner’s life.

Still being in the thick of the pan­dem­ic, it’s dif­fi­cult to see the lock­downs and para­noia of the last three year with any sort of dis­tanced clar­i­ty, though COVID has giv­en a few sol­id punch lines to the time­ly Glass Onion. But most of the slapped-togeth­er quar­an­tine arti­facts (once upon a time, Anne Hath­away was in a film called Locked Down) prove the dan­gers of mak­ing haste, draw­ing rash con­clu­sions that already look out-of-date by the time the final cut make it to viewers.

The ear­li­est sto­ries on record were cre­ation myths, devised to explain nat­ur­al phe­nom­e­na too mas­sive to be con­trolled; today, we engage in a sec­u­lar equiv­a­lent of this rit­u­al, orga­niz­ing the messi­ness of exis­tence into sto­ries ren­der­ing it com­pre­hen­si­ble. This con­stant recon­tex­tu­al­iz­ing can be a source of com­fort, if one wants it to be. Fads fade and dis­as­ters beget new dis­as­ters, but the ten­den­cy toward self-scruti­ny has been the one con­stant through all of mod­ern life, each gen­er­a­tion equal­ly assured that it’s liv­ing through the end times. Sur­veyed as a whole, this body of work posits the heart­en­ing the­o­ry that as years tick by, the only guar­an­tee is that there will always be more of them.

Lit­tle White Lies is com­mit­ted to cham­pi­oning great movies and the tal­ent­ed peo­ple who make them.

By becom­ing a mem­ber you can sup­port our inde­pen­dent jour­nal­ism and receive exclu­sive essays, prints, month­ly film rec­om­men­da­tions and more.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.