Lean on Pete

Review by Ed Gibbs

Directed by

Andrew Haigh

Starring

Charlie Plummer Steve Zahn Travis Fimmel

Anticipation.

Horsing aside, casting Boardwalk Empire’s Charlie Plummer and Steve Buscemi together on the big screen sounds neat and kooky.

Enjoyment.

A standout performance from Plummer makes this thoughtful drama swing.

In Retrospect.

Less a gallop, more a gentle canter through one teen’s travails, and all the better for it.

Charlie Plummer proves his acting chops in this equine drama from writer/director Andrew Haigh.

Pretty soon, Charlie Plummer’s image will be ubiquitous. The Boardwalk Empire regular, recently seen in Ridley Scott’s All the Money in the World (as John Paul Getty III), has a wise-beyond-his-years quality about him that grounds his nuanced performances. Before hysteria ensues, Plummer comfortably leads Andrew Haigh’s follow-up to 2015’s silver-dollar/grey-pound success, 45 Years.

In Lean on Pete, Plummer plays the troubled Charley, a 15-year-old trying to watch over an alcoholic roguish father (his mother has, we later learn, long since got up and left) in Portland, Oregon. Wandering the streets in search of work, Charley meets the gruff Del (Steve Buscemi), a small-time horse trainer who takes the teen under his wing. All goes well until Charley learns that his favourite horse, Lean on Pete, is to be slaughtered, having outgrown his racing use.

Dismayed by Del’s pragmatic attitude to the animal, Charley proceeds to take off across America with his boss’ truck and trailer, in search of his last surviving relative, an aunt he barely knowns. Along the way he meets a series of down-on-their luck types, some of whom appear willing to help, only to then rob him. The horse, meanwhile, grows weary of being cooped up in a trailer in the hot desert, lending its fate an air of inevitability.

Plummer’s performance, which is never less than assured, helps glue together the more disparate elements and characters of the film. The actor is a fixture in almost every frame – and when he does wander off on foot into the desert, Magnus Nordenhof Jonck’s handsome photography opens up the young lad’s world. Confiding in his trusted horse as he walks (he cannot ride, we learn later), the extent of Charley’s difficult upbringing becomes all-too clear. It is another authentic marker showing us just how easily someone Charley’s age can (and does) slip through the cracks and onto the mean streets of society.

Charley’s journey is akin to a bumpy ramble, with some pit stops more successful than others (he narrowly escapes being arrested and is almost taken away by family services on more than one occasion). But generally, most folk seem to warm to the lad and take him in.

Based on the 2010 novel by Richmond Fontaine frontman and author Willy Vlautin, Haigh’s film isn’t as harsh as it could have been – although there are plenty of unlikeable characters, and the whiff of sex and drugs is never far away. And while it may lack the bite of a work like Kelly Reichardt’s Certain Women (which feels similar in tone), we do get a clear sense of Charley’s predicament, which seems increasingly desperate. When the finale does eventually arrive, it’s with more a sense of relief than a clear resolution.

Lean on Pete may feel a tad too subtle for some, but it’s beautifully crafted – and there’s no disputing Plummer’s acting chops, and that undeniable star quality.

Published 3 May 2018

Tags: Andrew Haigh Charlie Plummer

Anticipation.

Horsing aside, casting Boardwalk Empire’s Charlie Plummer and Steve Buscemi together on the big screen sounds neat and kooky.

Enjoyment.

A standout performance from Plummer makes this thoughtful drama swing.

In Retrospect.

Less a gallop, more a gentle canter through one teen’s travails, and all the better for it.

Read More

Willy Vlautin on the art of working class storytelling

By Ian Gilchrist

The American novelist and former Richmond Fontaine frontman discusses the latest adaptation of his work, Lean on Pete.

45 Years

By Sophie Monks Kaufman

Charlotte Rampling and Tom Courtenay are on top form in Andrew Haigh’s devastating relationship drama.

review LWLies Recommends

Andrew Haigh: ‘I try to make my characters as complex and messy as possible’

By Sophie Monks Kaufman

The director of Weekend and 45 Years talks to LWLies about how he creates authentic, lived-in characters.

What are you looking for?

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design