BAFTA and the Academy are wrong to relegate technical awards

By denying the winners airtime, these major events are discrediting those at the very heart of the craft.


Beth Webb



Carlos Somonte

If you managed to sit through the weary jokes, human glitter balls and impossibly extra clariphone performances that made up the 2019 BAFTAs ceremony, you will have fleetingly enjoyed some of the most poignant and triumphant moments of the entire evening.

Tacked hastily onto the backend of the broadcast in a short series of edited highlights, production designers Fiona Crombie and Alice Felton dedicated their win for The Favourite to working mothers everywhere, while Best Short Film winner Jonathan Hodgson spoke out against Brexit in his acceptance speech. “We need Europe now more than ever,” was the quote that made the supercut, and was received with rapturous applause.

Perhaps the most baffling win to miss out on proper screen time – to a First Man-themed circus performance, no less – was the team behind Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, who paid homage to Stan Lee in a touching speech that was afforded just a few seconds during the broadcast.

“Animation is not a genre, it is a medium. And that medium is film,” writer-producer Phil Lord says in the extended cut, a simple but powerful statement that holds to account awards ceremonies and their continuous disregard for those at the heart of the very industry they claim to celebrate.

Then on Monday, Academy president John Bailey announced that cinematography, film editing, live-action short and makeup/hairstyling honours will be handed out during commercial breaks at this year’s Oscars.

The categories, which include nominations for British indie cinematographer Robbie Ryan for The Favourite and Border’s transformative troll makeup courtesy of Goran Lundstrom and Pamela Goldammer, will be live-streamed over the Academy’s site and social media but cut from the show itself, sparking instant criticism from key industry folk.

“No one single film has ever existed without CINEMAtography and without editing,” Alfonso Cuarón tweeted, a sentiment that feels particularly raw given that the Mexican filmmaker taught himself cinematography for Roma after his regular collaborator Emmanuel Lubezki was unable to join the project. He joins Ryan in the category this year.

Cuarón’s friend and fellow Oscar-winner Guillermo del Toro also called out the decision, accusing the body of discrediting the work of nominees by denying them airtime:

“Cinematography and Editing are at the very heart of our craft. They are not inherited from a theatrical tradition or a literary tradition: they are cinema itself,” he said.

Moon director Duncan Jones also weighed in: “For an awards do that is supposed to be by the industry, for the industry, the Academy sure doesn’t have a lot of respect for the crew who put in most of the work.”

Emailing the Academy’s membership, Bailey attempted to justify the cuts in the show by highlighting changes in content consumption: “Viewing patterns for the Academy Awards are changing quickly in our current multi-media world, and our show must also evolve to successfully continue promoting motion pictures to a worldwide audience.”

With the dust still swirling around numerous controversies tied to this year’s show, this is not just a blow to a large and long-standing sector of the industry, but a new rip in the surface of the academy, further highlighting their deeply questionable priorities.

The fire has been lit for progress, but it’s the people who receive the awards that truly deserve to see change, and not global content providers.

Published 12 Feb 2019

Tags: Academy Awards Alfonso Cuarón BAFTAs Guillermo del Toro Oscars

Suggested For You

Five things we learned from the 2019 Oscars nominations

By Charles Bramesco

Key takeaways from this year’s slate of Academy selections.

Alfonso Cuarón: Observe the Moments

By Adam Woodward

The Mexican writer/director describes coming home to make Roma, his most profoundly personal film to date.

Why the ideal Oscars host is… Nobody

By Victoria Luxford

With Kevin Hart out of the frame, the Academy would be wise to put the focus back on the films.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.