All-female horror anthology XX is a worthy project poorly executed

Annie Clark makes her directorial debut in this convention-flipping collection of shorts.

Words

Elena Lazic

Horror cinema has often been the object of virulent feminist critique. This comes as no surprise since from the early days of the genre, predominantly male horror filmmakers have continuously portrayed women as victims, at the mercy of gothic vampires, giant gorillas, chainsaw-wielding psychopaths and more.

It’s tempting to conclude that horror movies are made by and for people who hate women and enjoy their suffering. Yet this is to simplify the complex pleasures of horror and to cast all female fans as masochists. Evolving rather in a highly allegorical register, the genre frequently uses onscreen violence and victimisation to satisfy a visceral curiosity about the body and explore the oppressive nature of social conventions regarding gender, sexuality and identity.

Despite a rich history of women in horror, anthology horror films have done few favours for female directors. Recent iteration the V/H/S franchise featured none across three instalments while the two ABCs of Death films showcase a combined total of five female filmmakers across 52 shorts. In a climate in which the likes of Ana Lily Amirpour, Julia Ducournau, the Soska Sisters and Karyn Kusama are flourishing, it certainly feels an uncomfortable status quo worth challenging. XX, the first ever all-female anthology horror film, explicitly sets out to do that.

Jovanka Vuckovic’s opening short ‘The Box’ is by far the best. After her son peers into a box held by a mysterious stranger, a wife and mother sees her perfect family swiftly succumb to a strange starving spell. The film’s slick production values and levels of dread are unfortunately not matched by the subsequent three shorts, with the next part, directed by musician Annie Clark, proving particularly poor.

Quite besides the hypocrisy of giving a popular musician a coveted spot in a film for women directors, the resulting short ‘The Birthday Party’ is amateurish in its execution. A darkly comic allegory about the pressure which suburban mothers struggle under, it fails to match the creepiness suggested by Clark’s jarringly dissonant soundtrack. Roxanne Benjamin’s ‘Don’t Fall’ aims for a more classical American slasher/monster movie aesthetic but proves inconsequential, while final short ‘Her Only Living Son’ is the most technically accomplished, but proves frustrating.

Directed by The Invitation’s Karyn Kusama, the short touches on maternal themes via body horror, with the mother of a young man growing increasingly afraid of who – or what – he may become. Despite an effective opening, the film ends on a note of symbolism too ambitious for the short format, bringing the anthology to an end on something of a bum note.

Framed by pretty banal animation, the film as a whole reflects a rather limited vision of womanhood, with three shorts focused solely on mothers. That XX proves patchy is a disappointment, particularly as it is a noble project. We can only hope that future instalments in a possible franchise (?) will do more justice to the thematic potential of horror as a genre for and about women and their place in the world.

XX is available on DVD from 8 May.

Published 26 Apr 2017

Tags: Ana Lily Amirpour Annie Clark Jovanka Vuckovic Julia Ducournau Karyn Kusama Roxanne Benjamin

Read More

How female directors are staking their claim in horror

By Katy Vans

Karyn Kusama and St Vincent’s Annie Clark are among those contributing to an all-female anthology film.

25 new films by female directors you need to see

By Eve Watling

2017 is shaping up to be an exceptional year for women behind the camera.

The original scream queens who gave giallo its feminist edge

By Emily Gosling

Iconic stars like Anita Strindberg and Edwige Fenech are the thread that ties this deviant subgenre together.

What are you looking for?

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, LWLies has been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design