Truth and Movies

Babyteeth

Review by Hannah Woodhead @goodjobliz

Directed by

Shannon Murphy

Starring

Ben Mendelsohn Eliza Scanlen Essie Davis

Anticipation.

Not another teen cancer movie...

Enjoyment.

Earns its emotional crescendo, and features a quartet of remarkable performances.

In Retrospect.

The best kind of surprise – a debut feature with bite.

A young cancer patient falls for a local hustler in this striking debut from Australian director Shannon Murphy.

Ever since Ali McGraw died in Love Story, there’s been a steady slew of films about terminally ill young women who experience a transformative romance before their inevitable demise. A Walk To Remember, Now is Good, Restless, Me and Earl and the Dying Girl – they may take different guises, but the results are always similar: sick girl meets boy, girl teaches boy valuable lesson about himself.

Of course, women existing as a tool to male betterment is nothing new in Hollywood, but even a twist on the formula, such as in teen weepy The Fault in Our Stars (the boy dies!) still manages to reduce the complexity of facing your own mortality when you’ve only just become aware of it to a romantic narrative.

What a breath of fresh air, then, Shannon Murphy’s debut feature is. It stars Eliza Scanlen as Milla Finlay, a 16-year-old cancer patient who (yep, you guessed it) develops an infatuation with a local ne’er-do-well after they meet on a train platform on her way home from school. Based on Rita Kalnejais’ play of the same name, it’s an effervescent coming-of-age story that manages to be honest, impish and completely devastating in a single breath.

Milla knows from the off that Moses (Toby Wallace) is bad news. He’s got a rat tail, face tattoos and a shirt unbuttoned to his naval. Intrigued, she invites him home for dinner, where her parents Anna and Henry (Essie Davis and Ben Mendelsohn) are bemused, but begrudgingly accepting of his presence. It helps, by her own admission, that Anna is high throughout the meal, while Henry – a therapist – really just wants to see his daughter happy, regardless of how inappropriate her blossoming relationship with Moses might be.

Through a series of chapters, we get to know Milla, witnessing her creativity during violin practice with an eccentric teacher and empathising with her struggling to fit in at school, given how wildly different her concerns are to those of the girls around her. Moses offers her respite, but also danger; a chance to experience life way beyond her comfort zone, be it breaking into his mother’s house or sneaking out to a late night party.

They don’t talk much, in contrast from other films, where teenagers speak with the rueful eloquence of much older souls – Milla and Moses are delightfully brash, awkward, and immature, as are Anna and Henry, who have prepared for every eventuality other than their daughter falling in love.

Taking visual cues from Terrance Malick’s Badlands and the teenage dreams of Sofia Coppola, Murphy presents a sun-drenched vision of Milla’s world, never condescending but instead inviting audiences into her mind. Every imperfection, every reckless decision, highlights the fragility and fleeting nature of teendom, made all the more poignant given that Milla is acutely aware of her diagnosis, and remains determined to live on her terms all the same.

While Wallace makes a delightfully objectionable love interest, the film belongs to Scanlen, Davis and Mendelsohn, a complex family unit with remarkable chemistry. A late scene, in which they visit the beach together and contemplate their situation, earns its emotional evocation, as nothing about Babyteeth feels manipulative or trite.

Films about teenagers – particularly teenage girls – so often feel too polished or self-conscious, but there’s a raw, kinetic energy about Babyteeth which helps it sidestep the pitfalls of the genre. A truly impressive debut from a filmmaker we will undoubtedly be seeing much more of, it’s perfect viewing for these hot, uncomfortable summer nights, but just make sure you’ve got your Kleenex at the ready.

Published 13 Aug 2020

Tags: Babyteeth Eliza Scanlen Shannon Murphy

Anticipation.

Not another teen cancer movie...

Enjoyment.

Earns its emotional crescendo, and features a quartet of remarkable performances.

In Retrospect.

The best kind of surprise – a debut feature with bite.

Suggested For You

What makes a great coming-of-age movie?

By Little White Lies

Keith Behrman, the writer/director of Giant Little Ones, discusses the intricacies of this time-honoured genre.

Shannon Murphy: ‘At film school they made me believe I couldn’t be an auteur’

By David Jenkins

The Australian director discusses her debut, Babyteeth, and why she’s perfectly happy making other people’s scripts.

Never Rarely Sometimes Always

By Hannah Woodhead

Eliza Hittman’s emotionally bruising, exceptionally tender abortion drama is not to be missed.

review LWLies Recommends

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design