Discover the indie horror comedy that made ‘mumblegore’ happen

The Duplass brothers’ Baghead, starring Greta Gerwig in one of her first screen roles, is a charming love letter to DIY filmmaking.


Anton Bitel


“Hollywood has us convinced that it takes 100 million dollars to make a quality piece of art, and that’s a piece of crap statement. I think you just saw that, right?”

So says Jett Garner (playing himself) at the beginning of Baghead, in a cocky Q&A on his no-budget feature We Are Naked that has just screened at the Los Angeles Underground Film Festival. Shot guerrilla-style in his home town on his parents’ mini DV cam using real light and extras who did not even know they were being filmed, the film is laughably bad, with awful sound quality and a ridiculous script – a perfect parody of the worst instincts of outsider filmmaking.

Yet while its monochrome presentation contrasts with the colour shots of the small audience watching it, even the camera filming them is obviously handheld, clumsily panning and zooming to mark Baghead itself as being not entirely unlike Garner’s film-within-a-film in terms of its homemade, DIY status. Mark and Jay Duplass’ film not only opens in a cinema, but repeatedly engages in metacinema, as a poioumenon that wittily tracks its own making.

In Jett’s audience are Chad (Steve Zissis), Matt (Ross Partridge), Michelle (Greta Gerwig) and Catherine (Elise Muller) – all struggling, wannabe actors who openly laugh at how terrible We Are Naked is, but are nonetheless inspired by Garner’s can-do attitude to take off together that very night to an isolated cabin in Big Bear owned by Chad’s uncle, where they plan to spend the weekend brainstorming a future project. Their idea is to create from scratch a script for a cheapo film in which all four of them will star, to kickstart their careers.

Asked what the film should be about, Chad declares, “Love, I want love to happen,” although it is clear that he is talking as much about his hoped-for relationship with Michelle as about film genres. Even after Michelle has pushed him into the friend zone with exemplary deftness (a typical class act from Gerwig), Chad continues to try to make them a couple at least in their screenplay, in the hope that somehow life will imitate art. Meanwhile, Matt and Catherine try to negotiate whether they want to rekindle the flame that they once had, and how exclusive their non-relationship is. The love that Chad wants in the film is also very much in the air.

After Michelle has a nightmare about a figure circling and stalking the cabin with a paper bag for a mask, the genre of the four friends’ screenplay – and of Baghead itself – takes a turn from romance to horror. Immediately spotting the appeal of the slasher genre for cash-poor filmmakers like themselves, Matt insists that their script accommodate a bag-headed killer – even as a similarly clad person appears in Michelle’s bedroom, and the four start wondering if their fiction might be coming to life, confounding the boundaries between their time together at the cabin and the film that they are writing.

If the Duplass brothers’ feature debut, The Puffy Chair, established their credentials in the mumblecore scene, then Baghead marked a shift to the even more rarefied subgenre of ‘mublegore’. For like Joe Swanberg’s later, similarly meta Silver Bullets, it is set in the same indie filmmaking world from which it has emerged, and brings to its character-driven dynamics of love and friendship the barest shades of horror – including a direct evocation of the escape on the back of a pickup truck with which Tobe Hooper’s The Texas Chain Saw Massacre famously ends.

The combination totally works, with the sense of external menace always comically grounded by Chad’s essential schlubbiness and Michelle’s kookiness. While in the end we are not entirely sure whether the quartet will ever finish making their Baghead, the Duplasses certainly finish theirs: a charming love letter to films made by friends for very little money.

Baghead is released on Blu-ray on 28 February via 101 Films.

Join our community of film lovers and receive monthly film recommendations, exclusive essays and more

Become a member

Published 1 Mar 2022

Tags: Baghead Greta Gerwig Jay Duplass Mark Duplass Mumblecore

Suggested For You

Watch: An interview with Greta Gerwig and the cast of Little Women

By Hannah Strong

We chat with the director and stars Saoirse Ronan, Florence Pugh and Timothée Chalamet.

Language Lessons – first-look review

By Callie Petch

Writer/director Natalie Morales crafts one of the pandemic era’s most moving and effective odes to long-distanced intimacy.

Greta Gerwig: ‘I’ve never felt successful at being someone who looks perfect’

By Sophie Monks Kaufman

The writer and star of Mistress America opens up about how she learned to love her flaws.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.