Starve Acre review – all texture and no teeth | Little White Lies

Starve Acre review – all tex­ture and no teeth

05 Sep 2024 / Released: 06 Sep 2024

A man with long brown hair lying on the rocky ground, looking pensive. Muted tones of grey, brown, and black dominate the image.
A man with long brown hair lying on the rocky ground, looking pensive. Muted tones of grey, brown, and black dominate the image.
4

Anticipation.

Apostasy was a promising debut from Daniel Kokotajlo.

4

Enjoyment.

Rich in detail and atmosphere, well-performed and creepy where it counts.

3

In Retrospect.

Despite the skill and restraint on display, it’s all texture and no teeth.

Matt Smith and Morfy­dd Clark play a cou­ple who move to an iso­lat­ed York­shire Dales estate in Daniel Kokotajlo’s folk horror.

Back in 2017, direc­tor Daniel Koko­ta­j­lo was dubbed one to watch’ after his strik­ing debut Apos­ta­sy, a brood­ing dra­ma set with­in Manchester’s Jehovah’s Wit­ness com­mu­ni­ty. But those who watched were left wait­ing. Now, he returns with Starve Acre, which leaves behind the streets of Old­ham for the broad vis­tas of the York­shire Dales. As well as cross­ing the Pen­nines, Koko­ta­j­lo has crossed genre bor­ders, too: where Apos­ta­sy found dread and cru­el­ty in sufo­cat­ing dog­ma, Starve Acre works in a much more overt folk hor­ror’ vein.

Adapt­ed from the 2019 nov­el by Andrew Michael Hur­ley, the film focus­es on a cou­ple, archae­ol­o­gist Richard (Matt Smith, tasked with tack­ling a York­shire accent) and stay-at-home mum Juli­ette (Morfy­dd Clark, thank­ful­ly not), who move from inner- city Leeds to Richard’s rur­al child­hood home in search of some clean coun­try­side air to alle­vi­ate their son’s asth­ma. How­ev­er, super­sti­tion clings to the fields like the morn­ing fog, and there’s word of a mytho­log­i­cal being, Dan­de­lion Jack, lying in wait. Soon, tragedy, loss and long-buried trau­ma come to call, and after their son sud­den­ly dies, Richard and Juli­ette become whipped up by a cen­turies-old prophe­cy regard­ing Jack’s return.

On page and on screen, folk hor­ror is in bloom. Whether it’s Men or Enys Men, In the Earth or The Feast, direc­tors are turn­ing to the land­scape to pro­vide a dis­tinc­tive (and dis­tinc­tive­ly British) flour­ish to their films, find­ing some­thing weird, pri­mae­val and unset­tling in the depths of ancient forests, or just under the sur­face of this green and pleas­ant land. Starve Acre is an unde­ni­ably impres­sive addi­tion to this mini-move­ment, but it’s per­haps one that works bet­ter as a slow-burn­ing aes­thet­ic exer­cise than as either a nerve-rat­tling hor­ror or an exca­va­tion of nation­al myth, his­to­ry, or identity.

Tech­ni­cal­ly, it’s a stun­ner. Its 1970s set­ting allows cos­tume design­er Emma Fry­er to go wild in the knitwear depart­ment, while pro­duc­tion design­er Francesca Mas­sar­i­ol and art direc­tors Kather­ine Black and Amelia Lester-Hinch­life cap­ture a Britain at its most grim and sti­fling. Koko­ta­j­lo works again with Apos­ta­sy cin­e­matog­ra­ph­er Adam Scarth to cast a fam­i­ly home as an emo­tion­al prison, always in shad­ow and half-dark­ness, as if all light has been ban­ished. The rare sun­light that does get in bleach­es the frame, cre­at­ing streaks of colour and halos around the image: appari­tions that feed into the film’s sense of a place haunt­ed and hound­ed by the past.

The film itself is in thrall to the past, too. There are par­al­lels with folk-hor­ror touch­stone The Wick­er Man, and the couple’s dia­bol­i­cal jour­ney and recur­rent run-ins with kind­ly neigh­bours-cum-cultists recalls Rosemary’s Baby. Like­wise, a glimpse of Don­ald Suther­land through the sta­t­ic of a TV set sug­gests an even deep­er link with Don’t Look Now, and its explo­ration of the over­lap between grief, obses­sion and the super­nat­ur­al. How­ev­er, apart from some splen­did effects work and a bravu­ra score from Matthew Her­bert, Kokotajlo’s film ulti­mate­ly comes up short. For all its com­po­sure and craft, Starve Acre sits in the shad­ow of what has come before.

Lit­tle White Lies is com­mit­ted to cham­pi­oning great movies and the tal­ent­ed peo­ple who make them.

By becom­ing a mem­ber you can sup­port our inde­pen­dent jour­nal­ism and receive exclu­sive essays, prints, week­ly film rec­om­men­da­tions and more.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.