Caitlin Quinlan

@csaquinlan

The Five Devils – first-look review

A family’s quiet mountain life is disrupted by the arrival of a relative in Lea Mysius’ beguiling second feature.

The past lives of parents are having a moment on screen. In both the arthouse world, with the likes of Céline Sciamma’s delicate Petite Maman, and the mainstream sphere, with Disney and Pixar’s delightful Turning Red, understanding who our guardians were before we existed seems to have become a favoured narrative. In Director’s Fortnight offering The Five Devils, director Lea Mysius follows suit, crafting an intriguing yet overstuffed tale of family mystery and fantasy.

The Soler family live a relatively quiet life in their isolated mountain village. Joanne, played by a brilliant Adèle Exarchopoulos, is a former gymnast who now works at a leisure centre. Her marriage to fireman Jimmy (Moustapha Mbengue) is strained and they have grown distant over the years; Joanne drifts through her days with little to relieve the numbness she seems to feel about her life. It’s ironic, then, that her attempt at self-care involves wild swimming in freezing cold water where her heart could stop if she were to stay longer than twenty minutes.

The film’s enigmatic genre turn revolves around their young daughter, Vicky (Sally Dramé), and her unnervingly good sense of smell. She stores scents in jars for future reference – notably her mother’s, which lingers on the grease she uses to keep warm in the water – and can sniff out even the subtlest of odours. The racist bullying Vicky faces at school leaves her lonely and solitary, seeking comfort in her parents alone.

But the arrival of Jimmy’s sister Julia (Swala Emati), who has been mysteriously absent for a decade, causes a rupture for Vicky. Her parents seem different, tenser at Julia’s arrival, and she will soon discover her own hidden connection to her aunt that may have set tragedy in motion well before she was even born.

Mysius’ film is so filled with complex ideas that it feels like the central narrative strands could have been split into totally separate projects – one following the thorny romantic history between Joanna and Julia before the former married the latter’s brother, and another diving further into the puzzle of Vicky’s powers. The combination of the two here results in a muddled narrative that feels stilted in pacing, clunky in editing.

When Vicky discovers that a certain smell will plunge her into the past, where only Julia can see her, she begins to unravel the secrets that plague their family and the wider community. The notion that scents can be transportive, that scent-memory is incredibly powerful, has clear emotional resonance but there is a subtlety missing to weave these narratives together elegantly. From Vicky’s perspective in the past, the detail and sentiment needed to really develop Julia and Joanne’s bond, to give weight to Julia’s fears, and to give the film’s climax greater depth is really lacking.

Still, the filmmaker’s ambition and flair for the strange (as also seen in her bold debut feature Ava) is admirable and gives The Five Devils an eerily curious quality. There are moments of visual adventurousness, particularly during a kaleidoscopic karaoke scene, and the original music by Florencia Di Concilio creates a striking atmosphere and tone. Yet, overall, the clashing ideas leave this feeling a little too heavy-handed and uncontrolled to be totally immersive.

Little White Lies is committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them.

By becoming a member you can support our independent journalism and receive exclusive essays, prints, monthly film recommendations and more.

Published 23 May 2022

Tags: Adèle Exarchopoulos Cannes Lea Mysius The Five Devils

Suggested For You

Falcon Lake – first-look review

By Steph Green

First-time director Charlotte Le Bon draws out sweet performances from her young co-stars in this idyllic coming-of-ager.

Scarlet – first-look review

By Sophie Monks Kaufman

Pietro Marcello adapts Alexander Grin’s fairy tale about a poverty-stricken family with breathtaking results.

The Eight Mountains – first-look review

By Rafaela Sales Ross

Felix van Groeningen and Charlotte Vandermeersch's is a poignant study of the friendship between two young men across four decades.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design