Words By

Adam Solomons


Tantura and Descendant reckon with troubling elements of Israeli and US history

Two of the best documentaries at Sundance probe the messy legacies of nations’ founding epochs.

Among a multitude of things it did wonderfully, perhaps the finest achievement of Get Back was to successfully correct the record of The Beatles’ most gruelling, infamous recording sessions. The most over-analysed group in the history of music, it turns out, still have plenty of wit, wisdom and lunacy behind the curtain. Maybe the ‘Get Back’ sessions weren’t as mean-spirited as we’re told. Maybe the music was better.

Two documentaries that screened at the Sundance Film Festival last week also seek to rewrite popular history in favour of the truth. Alon Schwarz’s Tantura reopens a disgraced ex-student’s personal archives to explore war crimes committed by Israeli Defence Forces during the late-1940s War of Independence – or Nakba (“catastrophe”), depending who you ask.

Margaret Brown’s Descendant – which picked up the festival’s U.S documentary special jury award – searches high and low for the wreckage of the Clotilde, the last known slave ship brought to American shores. Aboard the Clotilde were 110 West African captives, smuggled onto US soil in the dark more than 50 years after importing slaves became a crime punishable by death. Despite this law slavery was still legal and slave labourers remained highly lucrative. Both Descendant and Tantura find revelatory, frustrating clues in their quests for answers; they are also essential and compelling resources for anyone who wants to know how the resounding ethnic schisms of America and Israel – to put it mildly – have persisted.

The journalistic approach of Tantura is the more provocative: an indictment of all Israeli public life for its consistent negligence of Palestinian ethnic cleansing, it’s likely to divide an insecure nation. There are signs it already has. Descendant is a little more like the peaceful current of the Mobile River which flows past Africatown, Alabama, where the Clotilde arrived in 1859 or 1860. Director Margaret Brown sets out to give us an impartial, though not dispassionate, impression of a rugged racial inequality.

That makes Descendant a somewhat neater narrative. Many Black people in the Mobile suburb don’t much care about finding the boat: they know the route their ancestors took. Emmett Lewis, a direct descendant of Clotilde survivor and Africatown founder Cudjoe Lewis, says: “When they told all the stories, all I needed to hear was ‘We came up off the water.’ Maybe we’ll find it, maybe we won’t.” On the other hand, white excavators, politicians and business leaders see a financial opportunity in finding the Clotilde. Smithsonian Institute marine archaeologist Kamau Sadiki, who has made it his life’s work to understand the c. 40,000 journeys made by slave ships during the 246 years of American slavery, is caught somewhere in between. He tells an Africatown audience upon his arrival: “The Clotilde is a conduit to the past of a story and community, and a conduit to a very powerful future.”

What takes a little time to become clear is that digging up old wood and distributing the gains justly are two very different tasks. As it happens, the family of slave trader and Clotilde builder Timothy Meaher still owns more than 260 acres of land surrounding Africatown, worth tens of millions of dollars. Much of it houses factories and chemical plants. Lawsuits alleging local Black families have got cancer from the toxins produced nearby became a publicised opportunity for reparations of a kind. That didn’t happen.

A similar inert injustice has set in on the site of Tantura, an ancient Arab fishing village in northern Palestine which, since May 1948, has been Dor, northern Israel. The prosperous Haifa suburb shows no scars of the massacred prisoners and slain villagers who lived there. The bones of murdered Tanturans are thought to be buried underneath a beachside car park. Director Alon Schwarz speaks at length to Teddy Katz, a former University of Haifa student whose uncovering of Tantura evidence through interviews with dozens of IDF veterans blew open the history books in 2003 – before an ugly prosecution and a reluctant, regretted retraction. Katz’s story, of an idealist who hoped to tell a more faithful version of his nation’s messy past, is not too different to that of his namesake Theodore Herzl, the inventor of Zionism whose romantic vision of a tolerant New Jerusalem was bastardised by a generation of hateful militarists. It is the Palestinian exiles to neighbouring Arab states who were the victims of an ethnic cleansing still scarcely discussed in Israel in such terms. As one Haifa professor tells Schwarz: “These things do not glitter on the horizon of Israeli public life.” Ex-soldiers, now 90 or older, tell us what Tantura was like first-hand. All Israel should watch it.

Neither Descendant nor Tantura claim to offer easy answers to the troubling, twisty histories they explore. That much is left to people in power, who – handily – don’t seem equipped or interested in the challenges ahead. It may, therefore, be a few more Sundances before documentaries like Descendant and Tantura run out of new histories to uncover.

Published 29 Jan 2022

Tags: Sundance Film Festival

Suggested For You

Alice – first-look review

By Leila Latif

KeKe Palmer plays an enslaved woman who makes a shocking discovery in Krystin Ver Linden’s misjudged thriller.

The Underground Railroad is a revelatory telling of a complex tale

By Rogan Graham

Barry Jenkins’ adaptation of Colson Whitehead’s Pulitzer Prize-winner is a nuanced small-screen masterwork.

Barry Jenkins: ‘People of colour have been looking into the eyes of white people forever’

By David Jenkins

The Moonlight director sits down to pick apart his wonderful James Baldwin adaptation, If Beale Street Could Talk.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.