Suspiria – first look review | Little White Lies

Festivals

Sus­piria – first look review

01 Sep 2018

Words by Adam Woodward

A woman with long, auburn hair and green eyes wearing a grey top.
A woman with long, auburn hair and green eyes wearing a grey top.
Dako­ta John­son dances to an unfa­mil­iar beat in Luca Guadagnino’s sur­pris­ing­ly naff hor­ror remake.

It’s all a mess, isn’t it,” offers Dako­ta John­son towards the end of Sus­piria. Well, quite. This is Luca Guadagnino’s bizarre reimag­in­ing of Dario Argento’s cult Euro-shock­er from 1977. The word cult’ is key, because while the film was some­thing of an unex­pect­ed com­mer­cial hit in the US – fol­low­ing sig­nif­i­cant edits made to secure the desired R‑rating – it wasn’t until 1988 that the full, uncut ver­sion was made avail­able to a wider audi­ence on VHS. So how has Guadagni­no trans­lat­ed this clas­sic low-bud­get gial­li – with its omi­nous sound design, expres­sion­ist visu­als and crude­ly over­dubbed dia­logue – into a big tick­et stu­dio offering?

For starters, he’s added an hour to the run­time, arrang­ing the sto­ry into six acts and an epi­logue. Which is not to say his film packs a big­ger phan­tas­magoric punch. Because although Guadagni­no grad­u­al­ly dials up the freaky dur­ing the film’s slow­burn first hour, it plays out more like a drunk­en stum­ble in the dark than a dread-filled danse macabre. And what a dingy, ugly film it is. The Ital­ian direc­tor pre­vi­ous­ly teamed up with Thai DoP Say­omb­hu Mukdeep­rom to intox­i­cat­ing effect in 2017’s Call Me by Your Name, but this time around the cin­e­matog­ra­phy is murky and flat, Guadagni­no favour­ing low-con­trast light­ing and a mut­ed palette over eye-pop­ping pri­ma­ry colours. The set design, too, is drab and inel­e­gant, dimin­ish­ing the char­ac­ter and aes­thet­ic impact of the Art Deco interiors.

The set­ting is Berlin cir­ca 1977. Susie Ban­nion (John­son), a shy but prodi­gious dancer hail­ing from Ohio, has just joined the world-renowned Markos Dance Acad­e­my, run by the aus­tere and mys­te­ri­ous Madame Blanc (Til­da Swin­ton). Hav­ing already made a big impres­sion in her audi­tion, Susie’s tal­ent instant­ly shines through and she quick­ly becomes an object of fas­ci­na­tion among the all-female staff and stu­dents. But then strange things start hap­pen­ing, and there’s a creep­ing sense that the girls are some­how trapped inside this grand old build­ing – bound not only by its walls but by the con­crete struc­ture that divides the city, and which stands just a few metres away from the academy’s front steps. Or per­haps they’re being drawn to some­thing, gripped by an imper­ceiv­able, all-pow­er­ful force.

A woman in a purple dress stands in a dimly lit, abstract interior with geometric patterns on the floor.

There are signs every­where you look in this film. Some are lit­er­al, like a cross-stitched pic­ture spelling out the poet­ic verse A moth­er is she who can take the place of oth­ers, but whose place no one else can take,’ and a cry of defi­ance writ­ten in graf­fi­ti, Frei­heit Für Alle’. Oth­ers are sym­bol­ic, like the unmis­tak­able yon­ic shapes that appear spo­rad­i­cal­ly through­out (seri­ous­ly, there is So. Much. Vagi­na. in this movie). As the main sto­ry­line unfolds, seem­ing­ly impor­tant infor­ma­tion about var­i­ous char­ac­ters is par­celled out, such as Susie’s Amish upbring­ing (as if that auto­mat­i­cal­ly makes her weird or untrust­wor­thy), with­out actu­al­ly telling us any­thing about them. The script repeat­ed­ly empha­sis­es themes of rebirth, reli­gion and every­day human rit­u­als but doesn’t have a great deal to say about any of it.

Guadagni­no also draws our atten­tion to the sociopo­lit­i­cal tur­moil Ger­many was expe­ri­enc­ing in the late 1970s, inter­mit­tent­ly cut­ting to break­ing news reports on the kid­nap­ping and even­tu­al mur­der of the indus­tri­al leader Hanns Mar­tin Schley­er at the hands of the Baad­er-Mein­hof Gang. It’s hard to fig­ure out what exact­ly Guadagni­no and screen­writer David Kaj­ganich are try­ing to achieve by insert­ing fac­tu­al sub­plots into a super­nat­ur­al hor­ror cen­tred around a clan­des­tine coven. If mak­ing allu­sions to the Holo­caust is their way of ele­vat­ing pro­ceed­ings, it doesn’t work. At best, it’s a crass attempt at pathos.

Sus­piria is even more both­er­some on a tech­ni­cal lev­el. The cam­era move­ment see­saws between glacial push-ins and wob­bly crash zooms, cre­at­ing a jar­ring visu­al tone. Rapid-cut mon­tages com­pris­ing ran­dom night­mar­ish images – a toi­let clogged with hair, a woman’s face drenched in blood, an earth­worm writhing on a bath­room coun­ter­top – amount to very lit­tle beyond imply­ing a character’s dis­turbed psy­che. Instances of sub-David Cro­nen­berg body hor­ror are agree­ably grue­some but feel styl­is­ti­cal­ly at odds with the rest of the film. The dance chore­og­ra­phy is more sil­ly than unset­tling. The already infa­mous scene of bone-snap­ping muti­la­tion that sup­pos­ed­ly prompt­ed walk­outs at an ear­ly footage pre­view bor­ders on tor­ture porn, though it’s great to see Guadagni­no util­is­ing old-school prac­ti­cal effects. And Goblin’s icon­ic score from the orig­i­nal is replaced by Radiohead’s Thom Yorke war­bling incomprehensibly.

Swin­ton makes her sec­ond appear­ance in the film (she doesn’t nec­es­sar­i­ly stop there) as an elder­ly male psy­chi­a­trist named Dr Jozef Klem­per­er, who lost his wife in the War and is now search­ing for a miss­ing girl named Patri­cia (Chloë Grace Moretz in a small, thank­less role), a for­mer client and Markos stu­dent. Odd­ly enough the role of Klem­per­er is offi­cial­ly cred­it­ed to one Lutz Ebers­dorf, an appar­ent­ly real-life octo­ge­nar­i­an first-time actor who even has his own IMDb page. Why both­er going to all that trou­ble when the truth is as plain as the pros­thet­ic nose on Swinton’s face?

At one point Klem­per­er reads a pas­sage from Patricia’s diary that con­tains a direct ref­er­ence to Argento’s Three Moth­ers’ tril­o­gy: Mater Tene­brarum, Mater Lachry­marum, Mater Sus­piri­o­rum.” These are the names of the ancient evil spir­its Patri­cia believes are behind the ghast­ly goings on at the acad­e­my, and she hand­i­ly pro­vides an expla­na­tion for what each one rep­re­sents. Dark­ness, Tears and Sighs.” Sus­piria is cer­tain­ly a dark film, and it may well cause you to sigh or even bring you to tears. Just not for the rea­sons you were prob­a­bly expecting.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.