Poor Things – first-look review | Little White Lies

Festivals

Poor Things – first-look review

01 Sep 2023

Words by Hannah Strong

Young woman in a flowing orange skirt dancing in a formal ballroom setting, with other people visible in the background.
Young woman in a flowing orange skirt dancing in a formal ballroom setting, with other people visible in the background.
Yor­gos Lan­thi­mos reunites with his Emma Stone for a lav­ish and lewd romp through a steam­punk vision of Europe.

The bright but pover­ty-strick­en Max McCan­d­less (Ramy Youssef) wants noth­ing more than to become a doc­tor and make some­thing of him­self. In a strange, steam­punk vision of Vic­to­ri­an Lon­don, he stud­ies under the eccen­tric Doc­tor God­win Bax­ter (Willem Dafoe), a Scots­man with a scarred face and pecu­liar teach­ing meth­ods. When Bax­ter informs McCan­d­less he has a spe­cial project with which he needs some assis­tance, he jumps at the oppor­tu­ni­ty to earn some extra money.

That project is Bel­la Bax­ter (Emma Stone), Godwin’s ward, who is part daugh­ter, part exper­i­ment. A young woman fished from the Thames after a mys­te­ri­ous sui­cide attempt, God­win informs McCan­d­less he has trans­plant­ed the brain of her unborn baby into Bella’s body with an airy casu­al­ness. McCan­d­less can’t decide if he’s hor­ri­fied or intrigued: Bel­la is beau­ti­ful, mis­chie­vous, and devel­op­ing at an accel­er­at­ed rate. As her gross motor and lan­guage skills devel­op, she becomes curi­ous about the world beyond their Lon­don town­house and wish­es to see more of it. Bel­la, we quick­ly realise, is a woman who before all else, knows her own mind.

Reunit­ing with The Favourite screen­writer Tony McNa­ma­ra, Yor­gos Lan­thi­mos has found per­haps the per­fect voice to com­pli­ment his sur­re­al eye. Togeth­er they realise Alas­dair Gray’s cult 1992 nov­el of the same name, about a young woman’s (lit­er­al and fig­u­ra­tive) voy­age of self-dis­cov­ery. When God­win realis­es it would be futile to keep Bel­la locked away, he ini­tial­ly pro­pos­es she mar­ry McCan­d­less, but before this plan can come to fruition, Bel­la opts to run away with the dash­ing, devi­ous lawyer Dun­can Wed­der­burn (Mark Ruf­fa­lo) and sets sail on a steam­er ship to cen­tral Europe.

It’s a sto­ry that falls between Franken­stein and Pyg­malion, as Bel­la reck­ons with her own per­son­hood, and becomes increas­ing­ly aware of the peo­ple and pol­i­tics that sur­round her. She is delight­ed by the dis­cov­ery of pas­tel de nata in Lis­bon and dev­as­tat­ed to realise the extent of pover­ty in Alexan­dria. Most promi­nent, how­ev­er, is her voy­age of sex­u­al dis­cov­ery, as she realis­es the pos­si­bil­i­ties and price that come with her wom­an­hood. Wed­der­burn – the con­niv­ing rake played with panache by Ruf­fa­lo – can only hold on for dear life as Bel­la moves through their sur­round­ings like a dervish, thrilling­ly engaged with the world around her and unbound by soci­etal convention.

The part­ner­ship between Lan­thi­mos and Stone paid div­i­dends in The Favourite, and Poor Things is an evo­lu­tion of their clear under­stand­ing of one anoth­er. Stone’s tal­ent for phys­i­cal com­e­dy and abil­i­ty to deliv­er wordy, ludi­crous dia­logue with com­plete sin­cer­i­ty imbues Bel­la with an inno­cence that quick­ly evolves into res­olute­ness. This trans­for­ma­tion is reflect­ed by Hol­ly Waddington’s lav­ish cos­tume design, a feast of puff sleeves, ruf­fles and eye-catch­ing colours, that devel­op accord­ing to Bella’s grow­ing under­stand­ing of her­self and the world around her.

This is a sweet­er film than we have come to expect from Lan­thi­mos – a love sto­ry, not only about a strange sur­ro­gate father and his out­spo­ken cre­at­ed daugh­ter brought to life by moral­ly dubi­ous meth­ods, but between a woman and the world around her, as she chal­lenges the misog­y­nis­tic atti­tudes of the day and takes to task the idea that a woman should be sub­servient to a man in any fash­ion. It’s a tour de force per­for­mance from Stone, game­ly matched by Ruf­fa­lo, and com­pli­ment­ed by the dreamy, mad­cap world Lan­thi­mos and his tal­ent­ed col­lab­o­ra­tors have created.

You might like