Hannah Strong


Papillon – first look review

Charlie Hunnam and Rami Malek star in this serviceable but unnecessary remake of the classic prison camp drama.

One has to wonder if Hollywood studios have a yearly roulette wheel which they spin to decide which film of yesteryear they’re going to remake for a modern audience. This seems like the only logical reason they could have for choosing to remake Franklin J Schaffner’s 1973 film Papillon, as the production itself offers few insights into what it is that makes this retelling necessary.

In Michael Noer’s new imagining of Henri ‘Papillon’ Charrière’s memoir, Charlie Hunnam takes on the role made famous by Steve McQueen of a safecracker wrongly imprisoned for murder in 1930s Paris, and shipped off to French Guiana to serve hard time. Opposite him is Rami Malek as millionaire counterfeiter Louis Dega (Dustin Hoffman’s role back in 1973), and together the pair form an odd-couple alliance in order to survive the hellish penitentiary and plot an escape.

To his credit, Noer manages to shave 17 minutes off Schnaffner’s excessive 150-minute runtime, but 133 minutes of Papillon still feels like a bit of an ordeal. Pools of blood run into dirty water and heads roll from the guillotine as Noer really hammers home the message that life in the 1930s French penal system was pretty rough. The conditions are diabolical and the guards are sadistic, but Papi and Louis maintain their resolve to get free.

As the years go by their friendship grows stronger, and it’s in the chemistry of Hunnam and Malek that Papillon finds one of its strengths. It’s easy to invest in their relationship, and how their marriage of convenience soon become a genuine devotion to ensuring each others’ life. Hunnam in particular has come into his own as an actor in recent years (see also: The Lost City of Z), but performances alone are not enough to excuse an indulgent runtime and the fact there was no real need to retell this story in the first place.

Penal reform continues to be an issue across the world, but in constantly looking to the past rather than the present, cinema seems curiously reluctant to address this.

Published 23 Jun 2018

Tags: Charlie Hunnam Dustin Hoffman Franklin J Schaffner Michael Noer Steve MCQueen

Suggested For You

The Lost City of Z

By Matt Thrift

James Gray channels Joseph Conrad in this immaculately-crafted but lacklustre epic.


‘It changed the whole look of American film’ – Remembering Midnight Cowboy

By Hannah Strong

Adam Holender and Michael Childers reflect on the making of this iconic New York movie.

Puzzle – first look review

By Hannah Strong

Kelly Macdonald plays a technophobe with a penchant for solving puzzles in a drama whose pieces don’t quite fit together.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.