On a Magical Night – first look review | Little White Lies

Festivals

On a Mag­i­cal Night – first look review

20 May 2019

Words by Iana Murray

A group of people gathered in a room, some embracing, with warm lighting and colourful decor.
A group of people gathered in a room, some embracing, with warm lighting and colourful decor.
Christophe Hon­oré gives the roman­tic com­e­dy genre a shot in the arm in this por­trait of spousal strife.

A Parisian roman­tic com­e­dy about infi­deli­ty comes as reli­ably as the sun ris­ing at dawn. Last year alone saw films like Philippe Garrel’s Lover for a Day, and A Faith­ful Man from his son Louis. What can be said about the appar­ent­ly gru­elling hard­ship of stay­ing faith­ful that isn’t a rep­e­ti­tion of these tired rumi­na­tions? And yet, with On a Mag­i­cal Night, Hon­oré expands the lim­i­ta­tions of the genre with a fresh take that bor­ders on the fantastical.

The film’s French title, Cham­bre 212, is more illu­mi­nat­ing than its lousy Eng­lish inter­pre­ta­tion. Arti­cle 212 of the French civ­il code states, spous­es owe each oth­er respect, fideli­ty, sup­port and assis­tance,” fideli­ty being the key­word here. At a neat 90 min­utes, the film wastes no time in intro­duc­ing its adul­ter­er. Law lec­tur­er Maria (Chiara Mas­troian­ni) is hav­ing an affair with a stu­dent but gets caught in the act by her hus­band of 20 years Richard (Ben­jamin Bio­lay). The bright neon of a sign­post points to her next des­ti­na­tion, as she qui­et­ly slips out of her home and checks in at the hotel across the street.

Hon­oré is a direc­tor of two extremes, exem­pli­fied by his two Palme d’Or nom­i­na­tions. There’s the sin­cere and ground­ed Hon­oré of 2018’s Sor­ry Angel, and the whim­si­cal Hon­oré of 2007’s Jacques Demy-inspired musi­cal Love Songs. On a Mag­i­cal Night grav­i­tates towards the lat­ter with a the­atri­cal extrav­a­gance involv­ing spec­tral-like mov­ing doors, dra­mat­ic cam­era move­ments and bil­low­ing smoke.

On a Mag­i­cal Night resem­bles some­thing like a mar­i­tal Christ­mas Car­ol. Through­out the night, Maria is vis­it­ed by the ghosts of Richard past: her hus­band in his twen­ties (Vin­cent Lacoste, reunit­ing with Hon­oré after Sor­ry Angel), her dozen past affairs, and her will per­son­i­fied as singer Charles Aznavour.

The film gets par­tic­u­lar­ly caught up in the appari­tion of Richard’s piano teacher, who he repeat­ed­ly refers to as the love of his youth”. As these visions of the past migrate to com­fort Richard too, much of the film takes time to eval­u­ate what could’ve been if Maria didn’t come into the pic­ture. Would they have been hap­py? Would they have a child? But it’s an unnec­es­sary tan­gent. In what is some­how not the film’s most egre­gious trans­gres­sion, the fact that Richard was a child when they met goes unac­knowl­edged. The sight of an author­i­ty fig­ure caress­ing a child’s bare back is uncom­fort­ably treat­ed like a joke.

Roman­tic films live or die on the rela­tion­ship they depict, and there’s a poten­cy to the decay­ing mar­riage with its auto­bi­o­graph­i­cal con­no­ta­tions. (Mas­troian­ni and Bio­lay were mar­ried for three years before they divorced in 2005.) A sense of urgency is all the more vis­i­ble as they take their rela­tion­ship apart and put the pieces back together.

Love is always built on mem­o­ry,” Richard says. Mar­riage is a beast con­stant­ly in a state of evo­lu­tion. The per­son you fell in love with at 25 isn’t the same per­son at 45. Hon­oré ren­ders a famil­iar nar­ra­tive, but as its name sug­gests, On a Mag­i­cal Night is an enchant­i­ng jour­ney to be on.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.