Kursk – first look review | Little White Lies

Festivals

Kursk – first look review

08 Sep 2018

Words by Elena Lazic

Couple in military uniform and formal dress smiling and raising a glass at a formal event.
Couple in military uniform and formal dress smiling and raising a glass at a formal event.
Direc­tor Thomas Vin­ter­berg and a for­mi­da­ble cast recre­ate the final hours of a real-life nuclear submarine.

Thomas Vinterberg’s lat­est film tells the true, trag­ic sto­ry of how the neglect, incom­pe­tence, greed, and pride of Russ­ian Navy offi­cials led to the deaths of dozens of men on the Kursk, a nuclear sub­ma­rine once deemed unsinkable.

Because actu­al peo­ple died in the events that they depict, films about real-life tragedies often strive to pay trib­ute to the vic­tims. To tell their sto­ry truth­ful­ly and to immor­talise it on screen is already one way of doing so, but even the best inten­tions are mud­dled when the dead are not sim­ply por­trayed as inno­cent vic­tims, but as saints and mar­tyrs. The urge to empha­sise the good­ness in the dead is under­stand­able, but it often gross­ly implies that cer­tain lives have more val­ue than others.

Vin­ter­berg lays into this uncom­fort­able impulse with­out restraint, often to tire­some effect. The film opens with a series of sequences show­cas­ing the unusu­al gen­eros­i­ty of Matthias Schoe­naerts’ Mikhail Kalekov, his idyl­lic home life with his preg­nant wife (Léa Sey­doux in a thank­less role) and son, and the cama­raderie between him and the men of his crew. When one of them strug­gles to pay for his wed­ding par­ty, all his friends spon­ta­neous­ly pawn their watch­es: they know that he would do the same for them.

These are all pos­i­tive and love­ly scene to wit­ness, but none of them seem gen­uine – the sen­ti­ments shown rather than felt. Vin­ter­berg appears to be aim­ing for pres­tige dra­ma but does not pull it off. The dia­logue is large­ly to blame, but it isn’t helped by the mad­den­ing cast­ing choic­es: to have all the char­ac­ters com­mu­ni­cate in Eng­lish makes some kind of sense, but it does not explain why almost every actor plays a char­ac­ter of a dif­fer­ent nation­al­i­ty than their own. The most baf­fling exam­ple is the cast­ing of Peter Simonis­chek (the tit­u­lar Toni Erd­mann) as a Russ­ian Navy official.

To make things worse, the sto­ry is stripped of the polit­i­cal res­o­nance and impli­ca­tions that the events did car­ry at the time. There are a few vague ref­er­ences to old Russ­ian ships and lack of funds, but Vladimir Putin – who had just began his pres­i­den­cy when the inci­dent occurred – is con­spic­u­ous­ly absent. This sim­pli­fi­ca­tion deprives the audi­ence of ways to con­nect with the film, but it also makes the tragedy appear episod­ic and ran­dom, as opposed to a mean­ing­ful moment in post Cold War relations.

Vin­ter­berg seems to care more about the visu­al look of the film than he does about the sto­ry itself. The unde­ni­ably beau­ti­ful cin­e­matog­ra­phy and care­ful­ly realised sets only empha­sise the glib­ness of script. But on a more fun­da­men­tal lev­el, this choice of aes­thet­ic vio­lent­ly jars with the film’s oth­er ambi­tions – along with a dra­mat­ic retelling of the bureau­crat­ic nego­ti­a­tions on land between Russ­ian and British author­i­ties, Kursk also strives to offer a vis­cer­al account of the men’s suf­fer­ing in the submarine.

The film’s shift from a nar­row aspect ratio to a much wider one when the sub­ma­rine gets to sea does put a more real­ist slant on pro­ceed­ings. But the clunky dia­logue, clichéd rela­tion­ships and char­ac­ter­i­sa­tion of every char­ac­ter under­mine all these efforts. Even as we wit­ness the extreme con­di­tions these men were put under – risk of explo­sion, freez­ing tem­per­a­tures and a lack of oxy­gen – Kursk ulti­mate­ly leaves us cold.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.