Hannah Strong


Hold the Dark – first look review

Jeremy Saulnier continues his excellent run with this haunting Alaskan mystery thriller starring Jeffrey Wright and Riley Keough.

Jeremy Saulnier makes films about the darker side of human nature. His previous features, Blue Ruin and Green Room, deal with a vagrant’s quest for revenge and a band caught up with a group of murderous Neo-Nazis respectively, so it stands to reason that his third feature should cover equally shocking ground: wolves with a taste for human flesh.

Hold the Dark is not really about the wolves, though. As the title suggests, it’s about the dark. Set in a distant and desperate part of Alaska, the film opens with Medora Sloane (Riley Keough) penning a letter to wolf expert Russell Core (Jeffrey Wright) pleading him to visit her and kill the wolves that have taken her young son, Bailey, before her husband Vernon (Alexander Skarsgård) returns from Iraq. It quickly becomes clear to Core that things are not all they seem for the Sloane family, and he becomes hopelessly embroiled in their affairs as the physical and metaphorical darkness closes in.

Written by regular Saulnier collaborator Macon Blair, Hold the Dark feels very different from the work which brought the director to the attention of genre fans. Although boasting the highest body count of any of his films so far, the violence here feels more engrained in the setting and characters – it’s a way of life in the desolate corner of the world where the story takes place.

It’s also the only language that Vernon Sloane seems to understand. Skarsgård gives a menacing performance, relying on hard stares and body language (his character isn’t much of a talker). Meanwhile, Wright is perfectly cast as a man thrust into something beyond his understanding, but determined to not give up or merely walk away. He’s drawn to the darkness and consumed by his fascination with it.

Those looking for the jaw-dropping ultraviolence may be left disappointed, as Hold the Dark is more an exploration of the human condition than a straight-up horror film. Yet when it does come, the violence is as heart-poundingly grisly as we’ve come to expect from Saulnier. He certainly knows how to shoot action, and how to show it in a way that feels realistic and devastating. This is a moody, twisted drama from the fringes of American society, once more examining the more depraved extent of human cruelty with haunting results.

Published 14 Sep 2018

Tags: Alexander Skarsgård Jeffrey Wright Jeremy saulnier Riley Keough Toronto Film Festival

Suggested For You

Blue Ruin

By Sophie Monks Kaufman

This hard-boiled, unironic revenge thriller is held together by a mesmerising lead performance from Macon Blair.


Jeremy Saulnier: ‘The motivations for the violence are all very practical’

By Anton Bitel

The Green Room director offers some sage advice on how to ride the wave of your first indie hit.

Green Room

By David Jenkins

There’s plenty to admire in Jeremy Saulnier’s follow up to Blue Ruin. But it’s not for the faint-hearted...


Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.