New Year’s Day

Review by Emma Dibdin @emmdib

Directed by

Garry Marshall

Starring

Ashton Kutcher Jessica Biel Sarah Jessica Parker

Anticipation.

Based on Valentine’s Day alone, the auspices aren’t good. Based on the cast, they’re even worse.

Enjoyment.

The zipping from one plot strand to another only adds to the general irritation, and the third act is a real drag.

In Retrospect.

Nothing wrong with an unashamedly sentimental holiday flick, but this is awful.

Nails-on-a-chalkboard characters and manipulative heartstring-yanking leave you desperate for midnight to strike.

What better way to celebrate the dawn of a new year than by watching an encyclopedic selection of A-listers play some of the most irritating characters you’ll see onscreen for the next 365 days? From shrill (step up, Sarah Jessica Parker and Katherine Heigl) to plankish (Jon Bon Jovi, Josh Duhamel) to what-are-you-even-doing (Robert De Niro), there’s something here to set everybody’s teeth on edge.

In the mould of director Garry Marshall’s 2010 behemoth Valentine’s Day – or more generously Love Actually – New Year’s Eve follows a multitude of couples in the lead-up to the titular holiday, some married, some exes, some total strangers. Once you’ve recovered from SJP’s syrupy intro voiceover about “the magic of New Year’s”, you’ll spend the remaining running time locked into an internal struggle over which storyline you hate the most.

Take Heigl, playing against type as a manic, unlucky-in-love gal who’s sent into a whirlwind of high-pitched resentment when a rock star former flame (Bon Jovi) re-enters the picture. Or Sarah Jessica Parker’s uptight, frumpy single mother (really) who won’t let her daughter grow up, or Michelle Pfeiffer’s drippy worker bee (seriously) who just wants to experience life.

It’s not just that the stories are paper-thin, painfully unfunny and revolve chiefly around Those Crazy Women and how they all need a bloke to set them back on an even keel – it’s that they redefine predictability. Do you think Heigl and Bon Jovi might just make it up in time to kiss at midnight? Will De Niro get his dying wish to see the ball drop from his hospital rooftop?

On the plus side, Zac Efron pulls a Hugh Grant to surprisingly enjoyable effect, ditching his usual nice guy shtick for a sleazy wheeler-dealer type. There’s at least one genuine surprise to be had, too, in that the plot strand involving Ashton Kutcher is actually the film’s least awful, thanks to his pairing with the genuinely charming Lea Michele.

At a push, you might even enjoy De Niro’s barely-phoned-in turn, not least for the ironic sense that in watching him play a dying man, you’re witnessing the final death rattles of his career.

Published 8 Dec 2011

Anticipation.

Based on Valentine’s Day alone, the auspices aren’t good. Based on the cast, they’re even worse.

Enjoyment.

The zipping from one plot strand to another only adds to the general irritation, and the third act is a real drag.

In Retrospect.

Nothing wrong with an unashamedly sentimental holiday flick, but this is awful.

Related Reviews

Mother’s Day

By David Jenkins

Garry Marshall’s tin-eared greeting card movie extravaganza is so bad it’s almost quite good.

review

When Harry Met Sally… (1989)

By Glenn Heath Jr

Nora Ephron and Rob Reiner’s seminal rom-com remains as fresh and feisty as ever.

review LWLies Recommends

Valentine’s Day

By Nell Frizzell

Despite marketing itself as a Hollywood rom-com, this is in many ways a Bollywood comedy, set in LA.

review

What are you looking for?

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design

Sign up to our newsletter to hear more from team LWLies