Mufasa: The Lion King review – let down by weak… | Little White Lies

Mufasa: The Lion King review – let down by weak script and songs

17 Dec 2024 / Released: 20 Dec 2024

Two lion cubs in a grassy field, their golden fur and expressive faces visible against a blue sky.
Two lion cubs in a grassy field, their golden fur and expressive faces visible against a blue sky.
5

Anticipation.

We’ll always be front of the queue for a new Barry Jenkins movie.

3

Enjoyment.

It's a noble effort that lacks of originality and a human touch.

3

In Retrospect.

Jenkins tries hard to make this film about something more than plot and characters.

A rous­ing, noble mis­step from Bar­ry Jenk­ins, in which the paw-print of this great film­mak­er is too light to make out.

Every­thing the light touch­es” is an apt descrip­tor for the fea­tures, shorts and TV shows made by Bar­ry Jenk­ins in col­lab­o­ra­tion with his trusty cin­e­matog­ra­ph­er James Lax­ton dur­ing the first lit­tle por­tion of the 21st cen­tu­ry. In films such as Moon­light and If Beale Street Could Talk, and his extra­or­di­nary TV saga, The Under­ground Rail­road, he used his cam­era and lights to both empow­er char­ac­ters whose rep­re­sen­ta­tion on screen had long been dimin­ished, and to depict faces and bod­ies in ways that hadn’t been seen before. 

Jenk­ins is, with­out a doubt, one of if not the most impor­tant work­ing film­mak­ers in Amer­i­ca right now, and it is for that rea­son that we must approach his toe-dip into the world of dig­i­tal­ly-dri­ven main­stream fran­chise film­mak­ing, Mufasa: The Lion King, with empa­thy and rev­er­ence rather than cyn­i­cism or cau­tion. The fact is, with the films he now has under his belt, he should be able to do what­ev­er he god damn pleas­es, and we should sit-up and listen.

And yes, I under­stand that this wouldn’t need to be stat­ed so fer­vent­ly if I didn’t har­bour my own lit­tle scin­til­la of sus­pi­cion about the project. And that always occurs when a trust­ed, excit­ing auteur who appears to be carv­ing a niche or build­ing up a body of work takes a bit of a wild career U‑turn to ful­fil some per­son­al ambi­tion that may seem inscrutable to fol­low­ers. As crit­ics, we mere­ly have to work a lit­tle hard­er to draw per­ti­nent con­nect­ing lines between this and his pre­vi­ous work.

Way back in 2019, they couldn’t fill up the mon­ey sacks fast enough with the prof­its accrued from Jon Faverau’s live action”, beat-for-beat remake of 1994’s ani­mat­ed behe­moth, The Lion King. And so this pre­quel from Jenk­ins, visu­alised from a new script by Jeff Nathanson, seemed inevitable, and was like­ly weighed down with the lofty box office expec­ta­tions set by its predecessor.

Dis­ney tends to have prob­lems when it comes to their sequels; they sel­dom play like nec­es­sary con­tin­u­a­tions of the orig­i­nal, often closed sto­ries, and are more like vic­to­ry laps with extra lash­ings of that thing you already said you loved. Mufasa: The Lion King does suf­fer a lit­tle from that, ham­pered by the need for seam­less brand con­ti­nu­ity and con­triv­ing con­nec­tions to the things that made the first film so successful.

As the title sug­gests, this is the ori­gin sto­ry of Mufasa, the mighty, bari­tone-voiced father of Sim­ba, and how he came to be a vaunt­ed and wise king of the Pride Lands (pri­or to being slain by his treach­er­ous sib­ling”, Scar). It’s a sto­ry framed as a fire­side yarn intoned by wise old man­drill, Rafi­ki, and told to Simba’s own cub, Kiara, as she waits for her folks to return home dur­ing a vio­lent storm. Tim­on and Pum­ba are, of course, on hand for some misc caper­ing, as there’s no way you could real­ly leave these now-icon­ic com­ic reliefs on the bench.

Where the orig­i­nal The Lion King works as a ruth­less­ly effi­cient revenge saga dot­ted with killer tunes, Mufasa’s plea­sures are per­haps less direct, arriv­ing in the form of polit­i­cal alle­go­ry and light exis­ten­tial dis­course. The young king-in-wait­ing finds sud­den­ly him­self orphaned as he’s swept away from his par­ents in flash flood­wa­ters and is sud­den­ly forced to fight for his future among a new pride who spurn out­siders. Luck­i­ly he finds a fast friend in Taka, who saves him from drown­ing, and a cham­pi­on in the mater­nal Eshe (Thandi­we New­ton) who teach­es him the prac­ti­cal­i­ties of hunt­ing when he is forced to live with the more indus­tri­ous females.

Yet a group of fero­cious and dom­i­neer­ing white oppres­sors, led by Mads Mikkelsen’s Kiros, dri­ve them from their land and insti­gate a cross coun­try odyssey towards the dream­like idyll of Malele – a land­scape of per­fec­tion and plen­ty that exists just beyond the hori­zon. Jenk­ins’ film talks frankly about white colo­nial oppres­sion as not being mere­ly con­cerned with cul­tur­al and geo­graph­ic plun­der, but with the neu­ter­ing of blood­lines and erad­i­ca­tion of indige­nous pop­u­la­tions. It offers a sim­i­lar­ly roman­ti­cised and unspe­cif­ic vision of the African con­ti­nent (we only real­ly know it’s Africa due to the Afrobeat-inflect­ed musi­cal cues), but one that’s more fine­ly-attuned to its his­to­ry and the malign inter­ests of a pow­er­ful few.

Maybe this reads like we’re mak­ing excus­es, but it feels like the main issues with the film fall beyond Jenk­ins’ purview as a direc­tor: the under­whelm­ing, hook-free songs from Lin-Manuel Miran­da, which may be some of the weak­est to ever fea­ture in a Dis­ney pic­ture; a script which lays out many of its big dra­mat­ic reveals way too ear­ly; and just the inher­ent lack of expres­sive poten­tial in this form of live action” ani­ma­tion, in which we are remind­ed of the incon­ve­nient fact that ani­mals sim­ply don’t emote through facial expressions.

Aaron Pierre is one of the most excit­ing actors on the cur­rent block, and while he is def­i­nite­ly able to emu­late the hon­eyed boom of the late James Earl Jones (to whom the film is ded­i­cat­ed), his is a duti­ful rather than char­ac­ter­ful piece of voice work as the teenage Mufasa. And that’s per­haps a prob­lem with the film as a whole, where every­thing feels duti­ful­ly done and up to code, while no indi­vid­ual ele­ments real­ly shine through. It was an excit­ing prospect to see what some­one like Jenk­ins would do while up against the Hol­ly­wood machine, but it unfor­tu­nate­ly feels like the machine won this bout, if not by knock­out, then def­i­nite­ly on points.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.