Heart Eyes review – a gimmicky horror fauxmance | Little White Lies

Heart Eyes review – a gim­micky hor­ror fauxmance

12 Feb 2025 / Released: 14 Feb 2025

Words by Billie Walker

Directed by Josh Ruben

Starring Alex Walker, Latham Gaines, and Lauren O'Hara

A woman in a beige coat and a man in a dark suit stand in a dimly lit setting.
A woman in a beige coat and a man in a dark suit stand in a dimly lit setting.
3

Anticipation.

Hopeful for a bloody Valentine.

2

Enjoyment.

More sentimental mush than slasher.

1

In Retrospect.

Better luck next Valentine’s Day!

Two young­sters come a crop­per of a very par­tic­u­lar masked mani­ac in Josh Ruben’s dis­mal hor­ror-romance mash-up.

At the risk of sound­ing like a recent­ly can­celled mur­der­ous clown cre­ator, I’m tired of big stu­dio hor­ror movies hap­haz­ard­ly attempt­ing to wres­tle with trau­ma, grief or throw a pseu­do-fem­i­nist spin on every­thing. The promise of Heart Eyes, Josh Ruben’s Valen­tine slash­er where the ser­i­al killer is armed with an emo­ji-inspired mask and a big knife, sound­ed devoid of sen­ti­ment and there­fore per­fect. Unfor­tu­nate­ly Heart Eyes is so vac­u­ous and con­fused that it can’t even decide if it’s cyn­i­cal or sen­ti­men­tal about love itself.

At the cen­ter of this mis­guid­ed mix of roman­tic com­e­dy and slash­er movie is Ally (Olivia Holt), a guard­ed young woman in adver­tis­ing who believes her dash­ing cowork­er Jay (Mason Good­ing) is threat­en­ing her job. While Jay’s entire per­son­al­i­ty seems to be being help­ful and kind to the point of annoy­ance, Ally’s main traits revolve around stalk­ing her ex on Insta­gram and an eco-con­scious” atti­tude which man­i­fests in the form of her trusty met­al straw that nev­er leaves her side. Of course this pair are relent­less­ly thrust togeth­er till their unde­ni­able chem­istry” (a ques­tion I’ve been ask­ing since Not­ting Hill, is there chem­istry or are the actors just hot?) draws the atten­tion of the tit­u­lar killer tar­get­ing cou­ples. The pair con­tin­u­ous­ly scream that they’re not a cou­ple” at their approach­ing mur­der­er until the ene­mies-to-lovers trope has been beat­en to death with more force than most of the movie.

To intro­duce a new slash­er killer, audi­ences need some­thing more than a fun mask with glow­ing red heart eyes. We already have Jason and Michael Myers deliv­er­ing their stoney silence, Ghost­face has the sar­cas­tic wit and Art the Clown offers a sick mime humour. But Heart Eyes is as emp­ty as the hol­i­day he’s themed around, and no amount of heart-based weapon­ry makes up for watch­ing the same slow inten­tion­al walk of masked killers. It’s not even clear what Heart Eyes’ motive is beyond his desire to kill cou­ples – the film opens with him tar­get­ing an influ­encer cou­ple stag­ing their pro­pos­al for Insta­gram, imply­ing a hatred of fak­ery, but for the rest of the run­time Heart Eyes con­cen­trates their pur­suit on those with a gen­uine connection.

The killer – much like the film itself – can’t decide whether it’s cyn­i­cal or infat­u­at­ed by this Hall­mark hol­i­day, try­ing to make a dif­fer­en­ti­a­tion between the fak­ers and real love. Half the time attach­ment the­o­ry is a throw­away com­ment mak­ing online ther­a­py speak the butt of the joke, except of course when Ally and Jay are open­ing up to one anoth­er. Not only can the film not decide where it stands on true love” (a cook­ie cut­ter con­cept in itself) but Heart Eyes seems unsure of the bal­ance it wants to strike between romance and blood­shed. Between a Romy and Michele’s High School Reunion homage, a sick­en­ing­ly sweet meet-cute and even an unnec­es­sary fash­ion show, plus aes­thet­ic choic­es that make the whole film look like a Pret­ty Lit­tle Thing advert, Heart Eyes ends up feel­ing as fake as the optics-obsessed cou­ples it claims to hate.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.