Manderlay | Little White Lies

Man­der­lay

02 Mar 2006 / Released: 03 Mar 2006

Several individuals gathered at night, some in military uniform, others in casual attire, focused on a figure in the centre.
Several individuals gathered at night, some in military uniform, others in casual attire, focused on a figure in the centre.
3

Anticipation.

An emotional mauling, anyone?

4

Enjoyment.

The strengths easily out-weigh the weaknesses.

5

In Retrospect.

It’s a hard nut to crack, but the questions Manderlay raises are endlessly stimulating.

Lars von Trier’s lat­est is an exer­cise in claus­tro­pho­bic film­mak­ing, rife with sym­bol­ism and an unstop­pable momentum.

If there is any town the world would be a lit­tle bet­ter with­out, this is it,” said Grace of her stay in the 1930s town­ship of Dogville. With Man­der­lay, she has had the strange mis­for­tune of stum­bling across anoth­er such place – a Deep South plan­ta­tion where slav­ery is still in prac­tice 70 years after its offi­cial abolition.

How can such bar­bar­ic inhu­man­i­ty be allowed to reign free in a coun­try which holds per­son­al free­dom above all else? Grace unwit­ting­ly makes it her moral oblig­a­tion to reg­u­late this abuse of pow­er and give the democ­ra­cy-starved slaves the free­dom they deserve. What could pos­si­bly go wrong?

Filmed in the bold but bare the­atri­cal aes­thet­ic coined by Berthold Brecht, Man­der­lay is (after Dogville) the sec­ond part of a pro­posed Amer­i­ca’ tril­o­gy from Lars von Tri­er. Assum­ing the role of Grace from Nicole Kid­man is (rel­a­tive) new­com­er Bryce Dal­las-Howard. She doesn’t bring the same vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty and elec­tric pres­ence to the char­ac­ter as Kid­man, but she does demon­strate a vital­i­ty and ide­al­ism which accom­pa­nies the specifics of this par­tic­u­lar role rather well.

It will come as no sur­prise that Man­der­lay is a film that active­ly seeks to rile its view­er. Very lit­tle room is left for ambi­gu­i­ty in a nar­ra­tive so cal­cu­lat­ed that every line, prop and nuance is bound by a pre­med­i­tat­ed cause and effect con­coct­ed by von Tri­er himself.

This is claus­tro­pho­bic film­mak­ing, rife with sym­bol­ism and an unstop­pable momen­tum. It gives pur­pose to the spar­tan set design, puri­fy­ing the film’s mes­sage and forc­ing a reac­tion from the audi­ence. Emo­tion­al rape or mea­sured sto­ry­telling? The jury is still out.

Of the many idio­syn­crasies that Man­der­lay choos­es to run with, per­haps the most dubi­ous is the sug­ges­tion that the rela­tion­ship between mas­ter and slave was not, in fact, one of acri­mo­ny and deri­sion but benign acqui­es­cence – hell, even love. But there is an expla­na­tion: Man­der­lay is not a film about slavery.

It address­es the com­po­nent of slav­ery’ inher­ent in all forms of gov­ern­ment; the total­i­tar­i­an­ism imbued with­in so-called enlight­ened democ­ra­cies, and the false notion that there exists an ide­ol­o­gy which sur­mounts racial or class bar­ri­ers. Grace’s smug moral suprema­cy over the sup­posed sub­servience of the slaves also helps the film work as a metaphor for the cur­rent hos­til­i­ties in the Mid­dle East, going fur­ther to sug­gest what might become of the area when the US final­ly decides to pull out.

And that’s the rea­son why you should see this film. While some of the dia­logue may feel over-the­atri­cal and the final twist verges on the ludi­crous, Man­der­lay will, nev­er­the­less, leave you lying awake at night, pon­der­ing the intri­ca­cies of the ethics and morals put to tri­al. It’s a curt, dis­pas­sion­ate and manip­u­la­tive film, but it’s also bold in its assump­tions, emo­tion­al­ly stir­ring and often high­ly amusing.

With Man­der­lay, von Tri­er has cre­at­ed anoth­er ode to the clas­sic Hol­ly­wood film­mak­ing he so obvi­ous­ly reveres, and while his dex­ter­i­ty at fash­ion­ing mor­dant and high­ly provoca­tive films may have reached its apogee a few years ago, it’s still a tes­ta­ment to the fact that von Tri­er at half cock is bet­ter than 99 per cent of most direc­tors fir­ing on all cylinders.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.