Dylan Southern and Will Lovelace: ‘We picked up… | Little White Lies

Interviews

Dylan South­ern and Will Lovelace: We picked up enough detec­tive skills that we could work for Bellingcat’

09 Mar 2023

Words by Callie Petch

A person in a white jacket stands in front of two people sitting on a wooden bench, embracing each other.
A person in a white jacket stands in front of two people sitting on a wooden bench, embracing each other.
The music doc­u­men­tar­i­ans dis­cuss piec­ing togeth­er a his­to­ry of the LES scene which birthed LCD Soundsys­tem, The Strokes, and Yeah Yeah Yeahs.

In mid-2017, jour­nal­ist Lizzy Good­man wrote per­haps the ulti­mate tome of the ear­ly-00s indie rock renais­sance, Meet Me in the Bath­room. A rau­cous, ultra-com­pre­hen­sive explo­ration of the bands, clubs, and pro­mot­ers which made up New York at the turn of the century.

Five years on, Will Lovelace & Dylan South­ern, vet­er­ans of doc­u­men­tary films on Blur (No Dis­tance Left to Run) and LCD Soundsys­tem (Shut Up and Play the Hits), have adapt­ed that sto­ry for the big screen. The pair hopped on Skype to dis­cuss con­dens­ing a 600-page book into a 100-minute fea­ture, the chal­lenges in craft­ing an archive-based doc­u­men­tary, and grap­pling with rock’s propen­si­ty for mythology.

What brought you onto Meet Me in the Bathroom?

Dylan South­ern: A friend gave me the gal­ley for the book, and didn’t stop read­ing it for about five hours. I love the for­mat of oral his­to­ry, the Rashomon qual­i­ty where everyone’s talk­ing about the same event from dif­fer­ent angles with the truth some­where in the mid­dle. Yes, it’s a music sto­ry, but it takes place at such a spe­cif­ic time in such a spe­cif­ic place when every­thing was about to change – tech­no­log­i­cal­ly, polit­i­cal­ly, cul­tur­al­ly – and peo­ple didn’t nec­es­sar­i­ly know that.

We’ve made a cou­ple of music docs before that were pure music docs, and I liked the fact that this gave us a chance to make a time cap­sule. We knew we could nev­er go into the foren­sic detail of a 600-page book, but what we could do was give peo­ple the time and feel­ing of that place.

Why a film and not a TV series?

DS: We had pitched it as a four-part TV series, but it might’ve been the wrong time. Before there was prece­dent, peo­ple were going well, it’s quite expen­sive for a four-part TV series on a niche scene.” So, we start­ed think­ing that, if we picked the right parts of the book, we could instead cre­ate a sort of com­pan­ion piece.

What most drove the deci­sion to focus on The Strokes, Inter­pol, Yeah Yeah Yeahs, and LCD Soundsystem?

Will Lovelace: For us, the first part of the book, which we cov­er, was the most exciting.

DS: As we exam­ined the sto­ries of each artist, we looked at the ones whose nar­ra­tives chimed with the notion of com­ing-of-age; indi­vid­ual exam­ples which all took place in the same city around the same time. Karen O, a shy girl who moves to a big city and cre­ates this new iden­ti­ty that threat­ens to con­sume her; clas­sic com­ing-of-age. James Mur­phy, though he’s doing it ten-to-fif­teen years late, it’s still his moment com­ing-of-age. We want­ed to find some strong con­trast­ing arcs; Inter­pol and The Strokes have a tor­toise-and-hare sit­u­a­tion with their respec­tive ris­es. These four being the most pop­u­lar bands from that era may be a part of it, but they also allowed us to present the depth of things that were hap­pen­ing in the city.

You went into pro­duc­tion when COVID hit. How did the pan­dem­ic alter your ini­tial plans?

WL: We nev­er want­ed to make a movie with talk­ing heads. The inten­tion was to use most­ly archive aug­ment­ed by shoot­ing footage of con­tem­po­rary New York to show what those areas look like now. COVID stopped that. What it did help, in a weird way, was it had peo­ple like us, peo­ple with box­es of tapes and pho­tographs and inter­views, with more time on their hands to search archive out. It also gave us time. Weeks sat in front of our com­put­ers on the Inter­net, look­ing at old mes­sage boards, try­ing to read every inter­view that had hap­pened with every band fea­tured in the film.

DS: We picked up enough detec­tive skills that we could work for Belling­cat. We’d see a pho­to­graph and, in the cor­ner, there’d be a journalist’s mini­disc play­er. Let’s call up the pho­tog­ra­ph­er, see if they can get the journalist’s name, if they’ve still got their mini­discs and can send them over.”

The archive was com­ing in right until the eleventh hour. We didn’t even know footage of the first ever LCD show exist­ed until about two weeks before we had to lock the pic­ture. You’d get pan­ics that you wouldn’t be able to tell this part of the sto­ry like you planned, but then some­body would find a suit­case full of gold at the last minute. It was a very dif­fer­ent way of mak­ing a film to our pre­vi­ous ones.

Crowded dance floor with people raising their arms, disco ball illuminating the scene with colourful lights.

Some­thing I just realised when I was putting togeth­er my ques­tions, there were no jour­nal­ists in the nar­ra­tion parts. Was that a delib­er­ate decision?

WL: Def­i­nite­ly. We just want­ed it to be the sto­ry of these artists from these artists. You hear jour­nal­ists ask­ing ques­tions, but it wasn’t peo­ple com­ment­ing on the scene.

DS: One of the things we were real­ly inter­est­ed in was the notion of mythol­o­gy in music. Part of why we open on a Walt Whit­man poem mon­tag­ing these roman­ti­cised icons from New York was that they act as a bea­con call draw­ing artists to the city. Then the meat of the film shows the real­i­ty of that mythol­o­gy, these messy com­plex peo­ple strug­gling through. Book­end­ing with the poem reprise was a tongue-in-cheek way of ask­ing will these bands become the same as the ones we saw in the begin­ning? Or has the world changed so much in the inter­ven­ing years, par­tic­u­lar­ly in how we con­sume music, that it’s the last time a scene may emerge organ­i­cal­ly from a sin­gu­lar place?”

The film’s a time cap­sule of this scene, but it’s also a time cap­sule of New York City’s evo­lu­tion in the ear­ly-00s. How dif­fi­cult was it to bal­ance the sto­ry of, say, 911 with­out trivialising?

DS: It was tough. The aim was to show that these spe­cif­ic events impact­ed per­son­al­ly upon the lives of these musi­cians, oth­er­wise it would be insen­si­tive; it couldn’t just be there because it was there. So, when we got the footage of Paul [Banks] on the streets pick­ing up leaflets and going to give blood, or when we found the Kimya Daw­son per­for­mance short­ly after 9÷11… There’s some­thing so hon­est about them, it became nec­es­sary to include.

This scene was hap­pen­ing in New York at a time where the world’s eyes were locked there for anoth­er rea­son. We’re telling the sto­ry of these bands and we found it real­ly inter­est­ing to see what that his­tor­i­cal event meant to a spe­cif­ic artis­tic com­mu­ni­ty. The sto­ry that runs for three years, but we were at pains to make sure that trau­mat­ic events didn’t just hap­pen and then stop. We go to the anniver­sary of it, that park­ing lot show in Brook­lyn, and the rever­ber­a­tions of 911 are still there.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.