Why John Carpenter’s They Live feels more… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

Why John Carpenter’s They Live feels more rel­e­vant than ever

10 Sep 2017

Words by Bryan Hempel

Two people in Halloween costumes and masks, one in a grey jumper, the other in a green suit, stand in front of a piano.
Two people in Halloween costumes and masks, one in a grey jumper, the other in a green suit, stand in front of a piano.
This cult clas­sic tack­les issues which have become of increas­ing impor­tance since its release in 1988.

On 4 Novem­ber, 2018, John Carpenter’s They Live turns 30. This date also marks the two-year anniver­sary of the 2016 US pres­i­den­tial elec­tion, where a for­mer real­i­ty TV star was elect­ed. Carpenter’s film is a polit­i­cal and social thriller pos­ing as an alien inva­sion sci-fi. Aliens have invad­ed earth and employ cod­ed tele­vi­sion trans­mis­sions to assist them in their desire to con­trol the human population.

Accom­pa­ny­ing these mes­sages are what appear to be a pre­cur­sor to the mod­ern-day drones which now con­trol our skies. The true con­flict, not only with­in the film, but also sur­round­ing it, is the con­trol­ling influ­ence of tele­vi­sion and how this con­flicts with ideas of free will in the West.

One con­flict addressed in They Live is that of film ver­sus tele­vi­sion. Begin­ning in the late 1970s, the com­pe­ti­tion for view­er­ship suprema­cy actu­al­ly brought about a change with­in film­ing meth­ods, as most films would even­tu­al­ly be watched on a tele­vi­sion. Tele­vi­sion is bet­ter viewed with dif­fer­ent aspect ratios and view­ing qual­i­ties than film. Accord­ing to film his­to­ri­an Emi­lie Bick­er­ton, in order to retain home view­er­ship after a film had been shown in the­atres, films were pre­emp­tive­ly shot to accom­mo­date a tele­vi­sion view­ing experience.

A fur­ther issue was that tele­vi­sion had a greater sus­cep­ti­bil­i­ty to adver­tis­ing and the demands of tele­vi­sion exec­u­tives in a man­ner that cin­e­ma – espe­cial­ly inde­pen­dent cin­e­ma – did not. They Live is a cri­tique of both tele­vi­sion and adver­tis­ing, with Car­pen­ter ral­ly­ing against rat­ings hun­gry net­work exec­u­tives and the insid­i­ous, con­trol­ling influ­ence of adver­tis­ing. It’s a work that com­bines sci­ence fic­tion and hor­ror ele­ments in which Car­pen­ter makes a com­pelling state­ment relat­ing to the real world – that film can be a weapon which fights the social coer­cion of television.

Zombie-like man in suit holding microphone in front of large "OBEY" sign.

In They Live, we are nev­er explic­it­ly shown that humans can read or are direct­ly affect­ed by the trans­mis­sions. What we do see, how­ev­er, is that the aliens have posi­tioned them­selves as the upper class elite, and humans emu­late these hid­den alien over­lords. This is very sim­i­lar to how adver­tis­ing ide­al­ly works in the real world – indi­vid­u­als are exposed to prod­uct adver­tise­ments, as they them­selves respond to the adver­tis­ing oth­er peo­ple are influ­enced by and make the same or sim­i­lar deci­sions and purchases.

The genius of Carpenter’s film lies in how it shows the adver­tis­ing mod­el trick­le down from pow­er­ful aliens to ordi­nary humans, effec­tive­ly mark­ing it as an inci­sive com­ment of 1980s yup­py cul­ture. They Live has been her­ald­ed by both Lib­er­als and Con­ser­v­a­tives as the exem­pli­fi­ca­tion of 20th cen­tu­ry adver­tis­ing and social con­trol, just as Fritz Lang’s Metrop­o­lis was embraced by the Nazis as well as Allied coun­tries for its por­tray­al of the dan­gers of moder­ni­ty. The ques­tion of what it meant to be a human being in a time when you were expect­ed to be a cog in the machine was a rel­e­vant and impor­tant question.

Both Metrop­o­lis and They Live speak to the dif­fer­ent ways in which the major con­flicts of their respec­tive days chal­lenged pop­u­lar notions of iden­ti­ty. Dur­ing the 1980s, the issue that endan­gered free will was exter­nal manip­u­la­tion which came in the form of tele­vi­sion trans­mis­sions, and their pre­scrib­ing of lifestyles which were ben­e­fi­cial to the pow­er struc­ture. Giv­ing these issues a plat­form is what good film does; it makes impor­tant issues promi­nent in an approach­able manner.

Car­pen­ter tapped into the anx­i­eties of the 1980s in a total­ly unique man­ner; the com­bi­na­tion of wrestling the­atrics in the form of pro­tag­o­nist Row­dy” Rod­dy Piper’s one lin­ers and action scenes, com­bined with social com­men­tary sur­round­ing sur­veil­lance and brain­wash­ing con­tribute to the argu­ment that They Live is one of the most impor­tant and per­ti­nent social satires of the lat­er 20th cen­tu­ry. Now more than ever it is vital that we heed Carpenter’s warn­ings; to ques­tion whether the deci­sions we make are tru­ly our own, or if tele­vi­sion and adver­tis­ing are coerc­ing us.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.