Why The Prestige is the greatest trick… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

Why The Pres­tige is the great­est trick Christo­pher Nolan ever pulled

16 Oct 2016

Words by Daniel Seddon

Two smiling men in casual clothing, one pointing his finger at the other while they converse.
Two smiling men in casual clothing, one pointing his finger at the other while they converse.
Nev­er has on-screen mag­ic been so com­pelling as in the director’s now 10-year-old pas­sion project.

A whole decade ago cin­ema­go­ers were sub­ject to the illu­sion­ary spec­ta­cle of Christo­pher Nolan’s The Pres­tige. Lead by a venge­ful Hugh Jack­man and Chris­t­ian Bale, the Eng­lish-Amer­i­can director’s adap­ta­tion of Christo­pher Priest’s 1995 nov­el is one of the new millennium’s most extra­or­di­nary cin­e­mat­ic achieve­ments. As nar­rat­ed by Michael Caine’s engi­neer, Cut­ter, every mag­ic trick con­sists of three parts: the pledge, the turn and the pres­tige.” Nolan manip­u­lates these foun­da­tions into a non-lin­ear nar­ra­tive, mix­ing and match­ing between time­frames and per­spec­tives to fur­ther mys­ti­fy the events unfold­ing, rem­i­nis­cent of his ear­li­er Memen­to.

Set against a nat­u­ral­ly-lit 19th cen­tu­ry Lon­don, the film’s essence lies in the rela­tion­ship between Robert Ang­i­er (Jack­man) and Alfred Bor­den (Bale), two aspir­ing illu­sion­ists whose lives are for­ev­er entwined once a tragedy strikes. The cat-and-mouse mechan­ics that pro­ceed take us down a num­ber of strange avenues, com­pli­ment­ed by Wal­ly Pfister’s sleep­i­ly brood­ing cin­e­matog­ra­phy. It’s a mas­ter­ful­ly exe­cut­ed piece of work, espe­cial­ly dur­ing the Col­orado Springs scenes where Ang­i­er search­es for answers in the snow-kissed mountains.

Woman in floral dress sits on man's lap, man in waistcoat, dark-haired woman stands behind them.

On reflec­tion, 2006 was a pret­ty good year for genre cin­e­ma, with Pan’s Labyrinth, Chil­dren of Men and The Depart­ed all pos­i­tive­ly received. Neil Burger’s fan­ta­sy-romance The Illu­sion­ist went toe-to-toe with Nolan’s cre­ation that year too, flaunt­ing a sim­i­lar stage-trick­ery nar­ra­tive. In terms of invest­ment and mem­o­ra­bil­i­ty, Nolan sought after a cast which didn’t nec­es­sar­i­ly lend itself to peri­od-set­ting dynam­ics, this includ­ed the Thin White Duke him­self. Inter­est­ing­ly, David Bowie had already turned down the role of inven­tor Niko­la Tes­la before Nolan flew out to New York City – it was here that the direc­tor cement­ed their col­lab­o­ra­tion with a detailed face-to-face pitch. Expand­ing to more than just a cameo, the result­ing Bowie per­for­mance is one of thought­ful­ness, nuance and rich ethe­re­al­i­ty. It’s hard to imag­ine The Pres­tige with­out him.

This magician’s tale, sand­wiched between the first two instal­ments in Nolan’s Bat­man tril­o­gy but with all the hall­marks of a long-ges­tat­ing pas­sion project, is not only under­stat­ed but ground­ed in some­thing more grit­ty and real than his sub­se­quent work. Priest’s orig­i­nal nov­el proved the per­fect stomp­ing ground for a rapid­ly matur­ing film­mak­er – the in-depth focal points of self-sac­ri­fice, secre­cy, the dan­ger of mag­ic tricks and the uncan­ny are all facets that play to Nolan’s eye for dra­ma. Addi­tion­al­ly, Tes­la and Thomas Edison’s War of Cur­rents’ ignites on the fringes of this nar­ra­tive, sug­gest­ing a slight com­men­tary on yet anoth­er bit­ter rivalry.

Along with Dar­ren Aronofsky’s The Foun­tain, The Pres­tige is also sig­nif­i­cant for being the spear­head for Jackman’s for­ay into more seri­ous dra­ma. He and Bale are aston­ish­ing­ly good here, tak­ing on dual roles which adds to the film’s authen­tic­i­ty – dur­ing this par­tic­u­lar time peri­od, twins would in fact pro­mote them­selves in stage seg­ments sim­i­lar to the The Trans­port­ed Man’. But the truth of Angier’s dis­cov­ery, using Tesla’s fore­bod­ing machine, is the stuff of pure sci­ence-fic­tion. The final scene of Borden/​Fallon walk­ing past the taint­ed water tanks is gen­uine­ly unnerv­ing, with David Julyan’s musi­cal accom­pa­ni­ment ele­vat­ing the ten­sion. Still to this day, The Pres­tige picks at the brain, fun­nelling a route deep down into the human psy­che, per­sua­sive­ly employ­ing you to watch ever-so-closely.

You might like