Tsai Ming-liang’s The Hole is one of the great… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

Tsai Ming-liang’s The Hole is one of the great films about liv­ing in isolation

22 Mar 2020

Words by Ruairi McCann

Image shows a young woman sitting on the floor wearing a white vest top and looking directly at the camera.
Image shows a young woman sitting on the floor wearing a white vest top and looking directly at the camera.
The director’s slow cin­e­ma musi­cal from 1998 sees a mys­te­ri­ous epi­dem­ic send Taipei into lockdown.

Tai­wanese film­mak­er Tsai Ming-liang’s con­cep­tion of urban life is a lone­ly one, starved of direct phys­i­cal and emo­tion­al con­nec­tion. He express­es this through cin­e­mat­ic sting oper­a­tions; patient­ly observed, and often fun­ny, obser­va­tions of lives lived in iso­la­tion. Where time is killed by fix­at­ing on the often-uncom­fort­able real­i­ties of being crea­tures of mis­be­hav­ing flesh with an ingrained depen­dence on rou­tine. Tsai’s is a cin­e­ma that already seems to be under quarantine.

Released in 1998, Tsai’s fourth the­atri­cal fea­ture, The Hole, makes this metaphor lit­er­al. Begin­ning with a rare burst of explic­it nar­ra­tive con­text. Over a black screen the direc­tor lays down the chat­ter of news­read­ers and vox pops, explain­ing that on the eve of the year 2000 Taipei has been immo­bilised by a mys­te­ri­ous epi­dem­ic. As a result the city is in a lock­down, with every­one either long gone or stuck. The film then avoids the grand scale of a city-wide dis­as­ter in lieu of sub­mer­gence in a sin­gle locale; a tow­er block and then specif­i­cal­ly, two flats.

One is occu­pied by Hsiao-kang, the peren­ni­al moniker of Tsai’s muse Lee Kang-sheng, who brings again his strange­ly mechan­i­cal yet nat­u­ral­is­tic pres­ence. A Buster Keaton-esque daw­dle and a fer­tile blank­ness as he either inscrutable mopes around his quar­ters or main­tains a bode­ga where he spends more time dot­ing on local cats than ply­ing his wares. Mean­while, in the apart­ment direct­ly below Hsiao-kang’s, lives an unnamed woman (played by anoth­er Tsai reg­u­lar, Yang Kuei-mei). Her char­ac­ter and Yang’s per­for­mance con­veys lone­li­ness with rel­a­tive­ly more ver­biage and neu­roses, as she copes with the iso­la­tion and her apartment’s decay by home­spun care reg­i­men of egg yolk face wash, mas­tur­ba­tion and the hoard­ing of water and paper towels.

Their exis­tences would have remained only dis­crete, infringed only super­fi­cial­ly, if it were not for a breach. A hole that a plumber care­less­ly makes in Hsiao-kang’s apart­ment floor and there­fore the woman’s ceil­ing. It is this incon­ve­nience that brings them togeth­er, ini­tial­ly under the dynam­ic of a slap­stick duo with him, the addled nui­sance and her, the exas­per­at­ed straight man. Slow­ly though con­flict gives way to attrac­tion, with the hole act­ing as match­mak­er for these two lone­ly hearts. Pro­vok­ing, for the woman espe­cial­ly, a sex­u­al­i­ty that was pre­vi­ous­ly latent but now gains form in an inter­ject­ing series of fan­ta­sy sequences. Song and dance num­bers where she lip-syncs tunes of lust and love – crooned by Can­to pop icon Grace Chang – at her object of desire, Hsiao-kang.

These sequences shed light on an often-over­looked aspect of Tsai’s cin­e­ma. It is easy to sim­ply box him in as a min­i­mal­ist; not­ing how his pref­er­ence for long takes and a lack of clear nar­ra­tive cause and effect posi­tions him as one of the prog­en­i­tors of slow cin­e­ma’. Yet The Hole indulges a con­trary qual­i­ty. A covert max­i­mal­ist ten­den­cy that, apart from dis­play­ing a deep affec­tion for the the­atrics and direct­ness of both pop and musi­cals, exem­pli­fies how his films artic­u­late the dif­fi­cul­ty in find­ing out­er expres­sion for inner quan­daries through what Tsai dubs the coun­ter­point” between real­ist depic­tion and non-real­ist elements.

Ini­tial­ly this can be seen in action with­in the same frame, with the first num­ber where the woman mimes Chang’s Calyp­so’. After being seen sub­sist­ing in casu­al wear she is now sud­den­ly dolled up in an evening dress and shim­my­ing in an open ele­va­tor which is equal­ly bedaz­zled. This yearn­ing for a bit of glam­our, as an escape from a squalid envi­ron­ment, is both rein­forced, as fan­ta­sy, and under­mined by the real­ism of the rest of the scene’s décor, a fair­ly mun­dane look­ing atri­um, remains untransformed.

Lat­er num­bers are cut more like clas­sic Hol­ly­wood and Cathay musi­cals and up the fan­ta­sy with more cos­tume changes and cho­rus girls and danc­ing suit­ors prowl­ing through impro­vised but increas­ing­ly elab­o­rate set design. The dis­junc­ture then is in how these scenes are marked­ly removed from the look and, espe­cial­ly, the sounds of the rest of the film. For to con­jure, with accu­ra­cy, the mélange of dead air and gran­u­lar detail of being alone, Tsai opts for direct nat­ur­al sound, pay­ing par­tic­u­lar atten­tion to the chaf­ing of fab­ric against skin, the slurp­ing of food and the flux of flu­ids both bod­i­ly and soon to be.

While in the musi­cal sequences the arti­fi­cial, or the imag­ined, com­plete­ly can­cels this all out, with only Grace Chang and her accom­pa­ni­ment present in the mix. That the woman’s emo­tions are trans­par­ent when chan­nel­ing Chang and that she is artic­u­late when she is not, speaks to how the inner knot of desires is not solved but suc­coured by fan­ta­sy. Feed­ing off and con­tra­ven­ing a real­i­ty, regard­less of whether it is crum­bling or not, can offer lim­it­ed satisfaction.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.