In praise of Philippe Garrel, unsung hero of the… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

In praise of Philippe Gar­rel, unsung hero of the French New Wave

06 Apr 2017

Words by Matt Thrift

Two people photographing each other, one using a camera on a tripod.
Two people photographing each other, one using a camera on a tripod.
The direc­tor has been pro­duc­ing casu­al mas­ter­pieces since 1964.

It’s only in the last decade, since the release of his most wide­ly-seen film, Reg­u­lar Lovers that Philippe Gar­rel has re-entered the col­lec­tive cinephile con­scious­ness. It’s not that he’s ever been away – he’s been churn­ing out entries in his pro­found­ly auteurist canon of casu­al mas­ter­pieces every year or two since 1964 – more that he remains a main­stay of the fes­ti­val cir­cuit, even as the pres­ence of his son, Louis, in his last five films has brought a more recog­nis­able pub­lic face to such a sin­gu­lar oeu­vre of cin­e­mat­ic introspection.

Although so few of his films are avail­able on home video, en masse is the ide­al means of work­ing through Garrel’s back cat­a­logue, espe­cial­ly giv­en how intrin­si­cal­ly inter-con­nect­ed and how naked­ly auto­bi­o­graph­i­cal his work proves.

Jean-Luc Godard once described Gar­rel as being as close as teeth are to lips to the idea of nat­ur­al beau­ty,” in ref­er­ence to his emer­gence as a wun­derkind of the French New Wave with 1964’s Les enfants desac­cordés, a for­mal­ly play­ful short about a pair of young run­aways on the lam that shared a kin­ship with his more cel­e­brat­ed con­tem­po­raries. The events of May 68 were pre­fig­ured in his 1968 debut fea­ture Marie for Mem­o­ry and addressed direct­ly in both 1969’s The Virgin’s Bed and the new­ly redis­cov­ered 1968 short Actua I, but the dis­il­lu­sion­ment at their ulti­mate fail­ure echoes all the way through to the lit­er­al recon­struc­tions of Reg­u­lar Lovers near­ly four decades later.

That Gar­rel has nev­er received the inter­na­tion­al atten­tion afford­ed the likes of Godard and François Truf­faut is unsur­pris­ing giv­en the drug-addled strides into the avant-garde he made almost straight out of the gate. Ear­ly works such as Le Révéla­teur – a silent head-trip shot with the entire cast and crew trip­ping on acid – are a far cry from the reflex­ive vari­a­tions of his lat­er nar­ra­tive fea­tures, those indebt­ed to the influ­ence of his friend and men­tor, Jean Eustache.

The divi­sion of Garrel’s work into two camps is unequiv­o­cal­ly defined by his rela­tion­ship through the first half of the 1970s with the Ger­man singer, Nico. As famous for her string of sex­u­al con­quests on the 60s scene – from Iggy Pop to Bob Dylan – as her pres­ence on the banana-cov­ered Vel­vet Under­ground record and at Warhol’s Fac­to­ry, theirs was a nee­dle-fuelled romance of untold tem­pes­tu­ous­ness, the shad­ow of which hangs heavy over all of Garrel’s work through the 80s and 90s.

The cou­ple made four films togeth­er, two of which have proved the great­est rev­e­la­tions of the ret­ro­spec­tive, the key to unlock­ing the end­less­ly ref­er­en­tial rever­ber­a­tions which would follow.

Woman in white dress riding white horse, man walking beside, flames on ground in desert landscape.

The mutu­al tor­ment between the pair is already explic­it in 1972’s The Inner Scar, a work of stark visu­al beau­ty and sym­bol­ic impen­e­tra­bil­i­ty. It’s a peri­od piece – of sorts – a fan­ta­sy, even. Gar­rel and Nico play them­selves, or ver­sions there­of: wan­der­ing, fight­ing and col­laps­ing through an arid emo­tion­al waste­land. He’s cold­ly silent, she a foun­tain of raw accu­sa­tions; bib­li­cal and pagan imagery seared in vibrant colour as Nico wails on the sound­track as though she’s swal­lowed a bassoon.

Yet you can feel a col­lab­o­ra­tion at work in The Inner Scar, ideas being worked through and pre­sent­ed, how­ev­er eso­teric they may appear at first glance. Jump for­ward three years and any such ques­tions evap­o­rate in an opi­ate haze. A night­mar­ish vision that rat­tles from the depths of hero­in addic­tion, Le Berceau de Cristal is the pair’s most trou­bling work, and Garrel’s most ecsta­t­i­cal­ly impres­sion­is­tic film. It may also be his best – we’ll let you know as soon as the trem­bling stops.

Shot in their apart­ment in the dead of night, the film is undoubt­ed­ly Garrel’s love let­ter to Nico, her key-lit face and emer­ald eyes impos­si­bly lumi­nous. There’s lit­tle nar­ra­tive to speak of, more an attempt to doc­u­ment the artis­tic process, as Nico sits or paces alone, writes and reads music and poet­ry, pass­es it to Gar­rel, gets high. Under­scored by a star­tling­ly intense psy­che­del­ic phan­tas­mago­ria, the use of colour astounds almost as much as the rip­pling tex­tures of dark­ness unset­tle. A sin­gle shot of Gar­rel, his face emerg­ing from the black­ness to stare direct­ly into cam­era, eyes hol­low and mouth agape is the most night­mar­ish­ly potent image in the director’s work – Eraser­head by way of Per­sona – a haunt­ing reti­nal imprint like no other.

Gar­rel began his process of exor­cis­ing the doomed rela­tion­ship as ear­ly as 1979 with the mon­u­men­tal L’enfant secret. While 1991’s J’entends plus la gui­tare explic­it­ly address­es the affair in the most straight­for­ward nar­ra­tive terms, the ghost of Nico haunts the anx­i­ety dreams of 1996’s The Phan­tom Heart as much as trou­bled lover Car­ole, coax­ing Louis Gar­rel to his death in 2008’s Fron­tier of the Dawn or the meta-recon­struc­tions of the won­drous­ly titled She Spent So Many Hours Under the Sun Lamps, from 1985.

Film crit­ic Kent Jones once wrote of Garrel’s films that the action seems to be end­less­ly replay­ing as a crys­tallised eter­nal present with­in the cham­ber of mem­o­ry,” and it’s nev­er more true than when bulk-watch­ing his work. His is a cin­e­ma of the inci­den­tal, few direc­tors find such lucid beau­ty and grace in the spaces between action, dia­logue and ges­ture, the beats seem­ing­ly out­side of the scene’. And yet there are count­less episodes of tran­scen­dent pow­er, as Jean Pierre Léaud says in 1993’s The Birth of Love, all great art is based on noth­ing,” and Gar­rel pulls count­less tiny mir­a­cles seem­ing­ly out of thin air.

The lack of judge­ment towards the char­ac­ters in Garrel’s work is quick­ly tak­en for grant­ed, but his fear­less intro­spec­tion knows no bounds. A con­ver­sa­tion between wife, Brigitte Sy and him­self in 1989’s great Les bais­ers de sec­ours says it all:

How can we dis­cuss us or our lives as if they’re some­thing interesting?”

Because I’m not afraid to look at us.”

You might like