Why I love Dirk Bogarde’s performance in The… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

Why I love Dirk Bogarde’s per­for­mance in The Servant

28 Mar 2021

Words by Emilia Rolewicz

Man gazing intensely at camera while a person is visible in the background.
Man gazing intensely at camera while a person is visible in the background.
His manip­u­la­tive house­keep­er at the cen­tre of Joseph Losey’s 1963 film is a sly sub­ver­sion of his star persona.

Dirk Bogarde’s career was a con­tra­dic­tion. In the 1950s he reg­u­lar­ly topped the movie charts as one of Britain’s most pop­u­lar stars, but pri­vate­ly he admit­ted that beneath the glam­our of it all he was deeply unsat­is­fied. At first, he wore his star­dom with a cool non­cha­lance, as best summed up in one of his auto­bi­ogra­phies Snakes and Lad­ders’: “[John Davis] would make me into one of the biggest Stars, or biggest Box Office Attrac­tions, Rank had ever had. How did I feel about that? I felt fine.”

Born in West Hamp­stead on 28 March, 1921, to for­mer actress Mar­garet Niv­en and Ulric van den Bogaerde, Art Edi­tor of The Times, Bogarde’s act­ing career seemed almost pre-des­tined. But, in stark con­trast to his even­tu­al movie star­dom, he first served as a lieu­tenant in World War Two – the bru­tal­i­ty of which changed him irrevocably.

After mak­ing around 30 com­mer­cial pic­tures with The Rank Organ­i­sa­tion, Bog­a­rde found greater free­dom by select­ing more per­son­al ful­fill­ing projects. In 1961 he played a gay lawyer in Basil Dearden’s Vic­tim, express­ing how at last he felt he was in a film which both edu­cat­ed and illu­mi­nat­ed”, and fol­lowed this by reunit­ing with direc­tor Joseph Losey, with whom he had made The Sleep­ing Tiger almost a decade earlier.

At that time, Losey had men­tioned his inter­est in turn­ing Robin Maugham’s nov­el The Ser­vant’ into a film with Bog­a­rde as Tony, the afflu­ent young Lon­don­er seek­ing a manser­vant. But by now the actor was, in Losey’s words, too old to play the boy.” Or, as Dirk lat­er put it: “[I] had to play the ser­vant because there was no mon­ey for a star like Ralph Richardson.”

Bogarde’s per­for­mance as the sly Hugo Bar­rett is one of his great­est, and it earned him his first BAF­TA win. He dom­i­nates the screen with sear­ing charis­ma in a film that explores, to a dis­turb­ing degree, the ser­vant-mas­ter rela­tion­ship. Gone is the per­fect­ly coiffed hair and shoul­der padding of his ear­li­er com­e­dy crime noir roles. Instead, Bog­a­rde looks suit­ably unglam­orous with slicked greasy hair and heavy bags under his eyes.

The bril­liance of Bogarde’s per­for­mance is that we nev­er quite know what Bar­rett is think­ing. We have only glimpses which are empha­sised by Dou­glas Slocombe’s mas­ter­ful cam­er­a­work. The open­ing track­ing shot sur­veys the bare win­try trees and rooftops of Chelsea before focus­ing on Bog­a­rde. From there the cam­era starts to pan as he keeps walk­ing, remain­ing in sight but get­ting fur­ther and fur­ther away. With a suit­ably pal­pa­ble air of mys­tery, Bar­rett is just out of reach. How­ev­er, what we do see is a glim­mer of his unflap­pable com­po­sure as he cross­es the busy street, casu­al­ly swing­ing a brol­ly back and forth while mak­ing no attempt to hurry.

A man in a hat stands beside a sleeping or unconscious person lying on a couch. The image is in black and white.

His umbrel­la makes notable appear­ances through­out the film, not least in the scene where Tony (James Fox) is inter­view­ing Bar­rett for the epony­mous posi­tion. As Tony quizzes him on his cook­ing prowess, Bar­rett leans the umbrel­la han­dle pre­car­i­ous­ly between his legs, bare­ly mask­ing it with a bowler hat. His eye­brows dance sug­ges­tive­ly as he boasts of his souf­flé mak­ing abil­i­ty. Of course, the key to a good souf­flé is a per­fect rise. There’s a delight in his sly innu­en­dos which only add to the film’s tension.

Where­as Vic­tim was more explic­it, the first Eng­lish-lan­guage film to say the word homo­sex­u­al’, The Ser­vant only alludes to it. One rea­son being that Bogarde’s agent who he was secret­ly in a rela­tion­ship with, Antho­ny For­ward, was con­cerned by the pos­si­bil­i­ty of him acquir­ing a homo­sex­u­al image.” Gay ren­dezvous between men were not yet decrim­i­nalised, and in The Ser­vant Bog­a­rde expert­ly demon­strates a more embed­ded approach.

Bogarde’s main weapon were his eyes: boy­ish­ly wide yet just as intense and pur­pose­ful, as though they’re undress­ing you and mock­ing you simul­ta­ne­ous­ly. Bar­rett seems aware of the pen­e­trat­ing pow­er they pos­sess, and like a sin­is­ter fox­trot – quick, slow, quick – he occa­sion­al­ly slows right down in between whisk­ing around the house, zon­ing in on his sub­ject with that steely gaze. I’m afraid it’s not very encour­ag­ing, miss,” Bar­rett starts as he sees Tony’s girl­friend Susan (Wendy Craig) out. He lingers on her, a lit­tle too close for com­fort, before con­tin­u­ing: “…the weath­er fore­cast.” She leaves bemused, lat­er telling Tony that she doesn’t feel total­ly at ease around Barrett.

As the film goes on, Barrett’s errat­ic behav­iour esca­lates from over­step­ping his bounds to betray­ing the cou­ple com­plete­ly: I’m nobody’s ser­vant, I run the whole bloody place!” he roars in stark con­trast to his soft­ly spo­ken yes sirs’ at the start of the film. In the final scene he push­es Tony about like a rag doll, treat­ing his zomb­i­fied, intox­i­cat­ed state as just anoth­er sin­is­ter game – not unlike the men­ac­ing ver­sion of hide-and-seek they play ear­li­er. Bar­rett goes from phys­i­cal­ly dom­i­nat­ing the space to emo­tion­al­ly dom­i­nat­ing his mas­ter, and Bogarde’s elec­tri­fy­ing turn makes the entire descent into chaos seem entire­ly plausible.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.