Memory – first-look review | Little White Lies

Festivals

Mem­o­ry – first-look review

08 Sep 2023

Words by Yasmine Kandil

A woman with long red hair wearing a green jacket, standing in a forested area.
A woman with long red hair wearing a green jacket, standing in a forested area.
Michel Fran­co’s dra­ma about the choke­hold of the past boasts star pow­er in Jes­si­ca Chas­tain and Peter Sars­gaard, but nev­er quite deliv­ers on its emo­tion­al premise.

The dual­i­ty of mem­o­ry is a con­cept that human beings have been forced to grap­ple with ever since our brains first func­tioned with even the slight­est indi­ca­tion of cohe­sion. Our mem­o­ries serve as a bank in which we accu­mu­late the unique life expe­ri­ences that craft us into dis­tinc­tive indi­vid­u­als, for bet­ter or for worse. On his third vis­it to the Venice Film Fes­ti­val with­in the past four years, direc­tor Michel Fran­co attempts to explore the lat­ter, more vul­ner­a­ble aspects of the cere­bral cache root­ed deep with­in our skulls.

We first encounter Sylvia (Jes­si­ca Chas­tain), an alco­holic in recov­ery, at an uncon­ven­tion­al­ly cel­e­bra­tive Alco­holics Anony­mous meet­ing on the thir­teenth anniver­sary of her sobri­ety. On an aver­age day, Sylvia’s mun­dane life con­sists of drop­ping her teen daugh­ter Anna (Brooke Tim­ber) at school, work­ing as a car­er at an adult day­care cen­tre and hang­ing out with her younger sis­ter Olivia (Mer­ritt Wev­er) and her fam­i­ly. When the sis­ters attend a high school reunion, Sylvia is fol­lowed home by Saul (Peter Saars­gard). Although the two don’t speak, he remains out­side of her apart­ment until the next morn­ing, sleep­ing on a pile of tires.

After find­ing emer­gency con­tact infor­ma­tion in his wal­let, Sylvia dis­cov­ers from his broth­er Isaac (Josh Charles) and niece Sara (Elsie Fish­er), that Saul has ear­ly-onset demen­tia. Evi­dent­ly caught up in copi­ous amounts of trau­ma from the past, Sylvia ini­tial­ly rejects a pro­pos­al made by Sara in which she would be paid to care for and pro­vide com­pa­ny for Saul, but after dis­cov­er­ing Saul wasn’t part of her trau­mat­ic high school expe­ri­ence, she has a change of heart, and the pair begin to ten­ta­tive­ly bond.

The beau­ty of Mem­o­ry derives from the sub­text embed­ded in its sto­ry. Sylvia and Saul are dras­ti­cal­ly dif­fer­ent, yet simul­ta­ne­ous­ly alike. Where Sylvia is inca­pac­i­tat­ed by the mem­o­ries which haunt her, Saul is free from the bur­den and is alle­vi­at­ed from remem­ber­ing the dis­tress­ing sit­u­a­tions that he is unwill­ing­ly prone to. Nev­er­the­less, they are both lone­ly and deprived of the lux­u­ry of hap­py mem­o­ries. As a result, when their respec­tive fam­i­ly lives begin to suf­fer, they find them­selves lean­ing on each other.

Alas, the major­i­ty of this intrigu­ing explo­ration is kept well beneath the film’s epi­der­mis and is hard­ly vis­i­ble to the naked eye. Con­sid­er­ing that this par­tic­u­lar plot heav­i­ly depends on the expe­ri­ences that have led these core char­ac­ters to con­verge, Fran­co is unable to com­mit to explor­ing these indi­vid­u­als on a gen­uine lev­el. Con­se­quent­ly, this ques­tion­able sac­ri­fice gives Chas­tain and Saars­gard lit­tle sub­stance to tack­le in what has the poten­tial to be a fas­ci­nat­ing set of char­ac­ter studies.

In lieu of nar­ra­tive depth, we are pro­vid­ed with stag­nant tech­ni­cal deci­sions that are equal­ly as under­de­vel­oped. By no means should films have to tire­less­ly take visu­al risks, but at the bare min­i­mum, this stripped-back approach should feel engag­ing and delib­er­ate. Yet Memory’s rel­a­tive­ly restrained hun­dred-minute run­time is bloat­ed with repet­i­tive sequences focused on the char­ac­ters nav­i­gat­ing the world phys­i­cal­ly rather than emo­tion­al­ly, sug­gest­ing that even Fran­co fails to grasp the vast poten­tial of the para­ble at hand.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.