Harriet – first look review | Little White Lies

Festivals

Har­ri­et – first look review

12 Sep 2019

Words by Katie Goh

Two Black women, one holding a firearm, in a tense scene with serious expressions.
Two Black women, one holding a firearm, in a tense scene with serious expressions.
Cyn­thia Eri­vo is superb in this oth­er­wise sketchy and under­pow­ered biopic of rebel slave, Har­ri­et Tubman.

It’s close to aston­ish­ing that no fea­ture film had ever been made about Har­ri­et Tub­man until now. Not just because Tub­man is one of the most impor­tant his­tor­i­cal fig­ures in Amer­i­can his­to­ry, but also because her extra­or­di­nary life makes for one hell of a rip­ping yarn. Born into slav­ery in the 19th cen­tu­ry, Tub­man escaped and trav­elled north, becom­ing a key mem­ber of the abo­li­tion­ist Under­ground Rail­road movement.

She was respon­si­ble for res­cu­ing hun­dreds of slaves in her life­time. Final­ly, direc­tor Kesi Lem­mons, best known for 1997’s Eve’s Bay­ou, has trans­formed the events of Tubman’s ear­ly life into a heart­felt biopic star­ring Cyn­thia Eri­vo – so sub­lime in 2018’s Wid­ows and Bad Times at the El Royale. In Har­ri­et, Eri­vo deliv­ers a remark­able, sen­si­tive per­for­mance. She is by far the strongest ele­ment of this sin­cere but unin­spired film.

The sto­ry begins in 1849 as Minty,” a Mary­land slave whose hus­band is a free man, asks her mas­ter to allow their child to be born into free­dom. After being cru­el­ly denied, life con­tin­ues for Minty and her fam­i­ly who work the land until the mas­ter of the house dies.

Fear­ful under the watch­ful gaze of the master’s son, Gideon (Joe Alwyn), who has an unnerv­ing obses­sion with her, Minty runs away, trav­el­ling 100 miles and near­ly drown­ing to make it across the bor­der to Philadel­phia. Start­ing a new life, Minty is reborn as Har­ri­et Tub­man. Work­ing with Under­ground Rail­road abo­li­tion­ist William Still (Leslie Odom Jr), Har­ri­et decides to return to Mary­land to save her fam­i­ly and free them from slavery.

With this ini­tial set up, Har­ri­et turns into an adven­ture sto­ry. Har­ri­et dons an array of arrest­ing coats and hats and becomes known as Moses” in order to lead dan­ger­ous expe­di­tions bring­ing slaves north. While Eri­vo looks every bit a hero – there are some glo­ri­ous shots of Har­ri­et on boats look­ing every bit a swash­buck­ling adven­tur­er – the film nev­er ful­ly com­mits to this shift in tone from Harriet’s ori­gin sto­ry to a west­ern-like quest.

The details of Harriet’s jour­neys north are skimmed over, and much poten­tial for tense action is often squan­dered. Har­ri­et becomes bogged down by uno­rig­i­nal chase scenes and a bland, over-the-top score from the usu­al­ly reli­able Ter­ence Blan­chard. The lack of styl­ish flair from Lem­mons is startling.

Rely­ing on hazy, blue-tint­ed flash­backs that looks clos­er to the aes­thet­ic of a Foren­sic Files reen­act­ment, the direc­tor gives us lit­tle insight into Harriet’s past or into the extent of her reli­gious faith. It’s a tes­ta­ment to Erivo’s per­for­mance that Har­ri­et is giv­en any char­ac­ter­i­sa­tion beyond a super human who is led by visions from God.

Harriet’s biggest issue is that it tries to do too many things, want­i­ng to give the audi­ence the stir­ring ori­gin sto­ry of an Amer­i­can hero, the ten­sion of an action film and the emo­tion­al grav­i­tas of a melo­dra­ma. Yet it’s a dis­ap­point­ing and for­mu­la­ic por­trait. Eri­vo – and Har­ri­et Tub­man – deserve a bet­ter vehicle.

You might like