First Cow – first look review | Little White Lies

Festivals

First Cow – first look review

22 Feb 2020

A man in a black bowler hat and coat stands in a forest, silhouetted against the warm autumn light.
A man in a black bowler hat and coat stands in a forest, silhouetted against the warm autumn light.
Kel­ly Reichardt trains her metic­u­lous eye on 1820s Ore­gon in this sub­lime com­pan­ion piece to 2006’s Old Joy.

With First Cow, Kel­ly Reichardt, America’s fore­most chron­i­cler of small sto­ries root­ed in metic­u­lous­ly-craft­ed geo­graph­i­cal expans­es, has deliv­ered anoth­er slow­burn heart­break­er. The set­ting is 1820s Ore­gon in a set­tle­ment of beaver-trap­pers. Jonathan Raymond’s source nov­el, The Half Life’, has anoth­er time­line set in the present-day, which is pared back here to a brief yet omi­nous pro­logue fea­tur­ing Alia Shawkat and a dog dis­cov­er­ing some­thing in the ground.

Mean­while, back in the 1820s, the qui­et­ly spo­ken Cook­ie Figowitz (John Mag­a­ro) finds King Lu (Ori­on Lee) naked in the woods and helps him to escape from blood­thirsty Russ­ian pur­suers. The pair run into each oth­er again, at a lat­er inter­val, at which point the film’s true theme of friend­ship begins to bloom. A sequence of them nest­ing – Cook­ie beat­ing the dust out of a rug while Lu chops wood – dri­ves home that this is nar­ra­tive cen­tred on sen­si­tive, prac­ti­cal men in har­mo­ny with one another.

Lu is in thrall to the Amer­i­can Dream, prone to talk­ing aloud about how he can ascend to a more monied sta­tion in life. Cook­ie is usu­al­ly found in a state of watch­ful silence, but has his own dream: to open a bak­ery. This is the skill that Lu ends up har­ness­ing as a busi­ness oppor­tu­ni­ty. It tran­spires that deli­cious oily cakes” are exact­ly what peo­ple want at a beaver-trap­ping set­tle­ment in 1820s Ore­gon. Some are will­ing to give a gen­er­ous num­ber of ingots to sate this hunger for sweetness.

In the press con­fer­ence fol­low­ing the film’s Berlin Film Fes­ti­val screen­ing, Reichardt spoke about bor­row­ing a canoe from a muse­um; Lee said that he learned to make rope from grass, as well as frag­ments of First Nations lan­guage. His char­ac­ter is a Chi­nese immi­grant who has taught him­self to com­mu­ni­cate with the Native Amer­i­cans who are shown liv­ing with and around the white settlers.

The look of the film is con­stant­ly trans­fix­ing. Vivid world-build­ing leads to a pic­ture that thrums with tac­tile ener­gy. Whether its dirt under the fin­ger­nails of a large, beard­ed man car­ry­ing a baby in a bas­ket, or a Native Amer­i­can girl heav­ing a buck­et of milk that splash­es onto her mauve dress, or René Auber­jonois (who sad­ly passed away at the end of 2019) stand­ing still with a raven on his shoul­der, First Cow puls­es with painter­ly and poet­ic details.

Autumn trees, people on a wooden dock, cow walking across the dock in a lakeside setting.

There is also a sur­pris­ing­ly hearty sense of humour here. When the tit­u­lar cow rolls into town, it does so via raft. Reichardt lets the scene play out in almost real-time, as every­one watch­es, mouths agape. The cow attempts a regal still­ness that only ampli­fies how absurd it looks to see a cow on a raft.

Said cow belongs to Chief Fac­tor (Toby Jones), the rich, white over­seer who has a Native Amer­i­can wife (a cameo from Lily Glad­stone) and believes that killing one slave in front of a group can be moti­va­tion­al to work ethics. Even he is afford­ed a hilar­i­ous intro­duc­tion as he los­es his mind over how deli­cious the oily cakes are, and prof­fers Cook­ie the com­pli­ment, I com­mend you, sir, for this deli­cious baked comestible,” a line deliv­ered with fer­vour by Jones.

While there is no short­age of scenes which serve as sources of unex­pect­ed lev­i­ty, dra­mat­ic ten­sion builds slow­ly as Cookie’s cake-mak­ing process puts him and his bud­dy into night­ly dan­ger. Yet, as fans of Reichardt’s work will know, she nev­er con­trives ten­sion. She draws the world then lets the con­flict­ing ele­ments of it play out with under­stat­ed nat­u­ral­ism. The real ten­sion here is between the haves and the have-nots. As twas ever thus, the world is risky for have-nots attempt­ing to move up. It threat­ens the haves, even though they have noth­ing to fear by contrast.

Although in the social por­trai­ture is bleak in First Cow, there is a lush­ness in the green land­scapes, the white light and the warm and respect­ful way that Cook­ie and Lu inter­act with their world and each oth­er. There are visu­al and the­mat­ic par­al­lels with Debra Granik’s Leave No Trace, as well as Reichardt’s own Old Joy from 2006. The meek may not inher­it the earth, but dur­ing the fleet­ing moments that they are allowed to com­mune with it, there are flick­ers of the peace that could be.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.