In defence of Hook – Steven Spielberg’s grown-up ode to childhood

Does the director’s take on JM Barrie’s classic tale deserve its reputation?


James Clarke


Sometimes a movie can throw you simply by turning out nothing like what you were expecting. Take Steven Spielberg’s much-maligned 1991 film, Hook. If you watched it expecting an Indiana Jones-ed version of Peter Pan, chances are it didn’t work for you. Taken on its own terms, however, Hook now looks like the end point of the first phase of Spielberg’s stellar career.

Occasionally it’s the less appreciated films that reveal the most about a director’s body of work. At the time of Hook’s original release it was subject to largely dismissive reviews, yet one critic saw something that most others did not. In his two-part essay for Film Comment entitled ‘The Panning of Steven Spielberg’, Henry Sheehan made the case for the film as one of Spielberg’s most significant achievements up to that point.

In the mid 1980s, Spielberg considered directing a live-action musical version of Peter Pan, even getting John Williams to sketch out several musical numbers. Although that initial vision didn’t materialise, the musical DNA still found its way into Hook. If you’ve never seen Hook before, it’s worth approaching it as a musical only with less singing and fewer dance numbers.

Key to Hook’s musical and theatrical vibe are the contributions of production designer John Napier, who served as visual consultant on the film. Napier specialised in theatre and worked on the Coppola/Lucas/Jackson short film, Captain EO, from 1986. Hook was rendered almost entirely on soundstages. This was in part due to the fact that Sony had just acquired Columbia Pictures and were understandably keen to show the industry the large scale resources they could now muster.

The artifice foregrounded by the film is essential – the story being about a man’s journey away from reality. Once we arrive in Neverland, the shallower focus images contrast neatly with the deeper focus of the non-fantasy scenes.

At the film’s midpoint, amid all the frantic Lost Boys shenanigans, sits one of the most elegantly rendered sequences that Spielberg has ever directed: the scene where adult Peter remembers his past. The screenplay by Jim V Hart expertly channels the thematic core of Peter Pan, but not its entire plot. The sequence in question is a great example of this, drawing from the chapter ‘The Home Under the Ground’ in which Wendy Darling’s memory of home is referred to.

The narrator observes that, “she was absolutely confident that [her parents] would always keep the window open for her to fly back by…” This detail becomes a key line of dialogue in Hook and it also gets due treatment in the above sequence. Hart and Spielberg do further justice to the novel’s open window image, which works especially well when the focus shifts to Tinkerbell and not Peter; in close-up we see her looking forlornly through a closed window, Peter and Wendy together reflected across Tink’s face.

Light as a soufflé at first glance, Hook actually deals with some heavy themes. It’s the first Spielberg film to use memory as a key motif. The director presents a protagonist struggling to recover his past in order to move on with his future. Maybe it’s this that makes Hook more a film adults than young kids. After all, when we talk about looking at a film more deeply, aren’t we really talking about looking deeply at ourselves?

Refracting reality through the lens of fantasy has long been a rich seam for movies to explore. When Hook’s teaser trailer was shown in cinemas in late 1991 it brought that dynamic to life – a magnifying glass sweeps across an old map revealing the Known and Unknown worlds side by side. As a reminder of how one story can lead to another, this brilliantly effective teaser brings to mind a line from Herman Melville’s novel ‘Moby Dick’: “It is not down on any map; true places never are.”

Published 15 May 2016

Tags: Herman Melville Robin Williams Steven Spielberg

Suggested For You

The films of Steven Spielberg ranked – part one

By Little White Lies

We take stock of the (almost) complete oeuvre of one of modern cinema’s true masters.

The BFG – first look review

By Sophie Monks Kaufman

There’s a dash of old-school movie magic in Steven Spielberg’s whizzpopping family fantasy.

Why The Iron Giant is one of the most powerful superhero movies ever made

By Tom Bond

Brad Bird’s soaring 1999 animated feature taught us that true heroism is much more than quips and spandex.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.