In praise of High Plains Drifter – Clint… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

In praise of High Plains Drifter – Clint Eastwood’s shock­ing, spir­i­tu­al psy­cho western

07 Dec 2016

Words by Brogan Morris

A man wearing a black hat and grey shirt is drinking a glass of water in front of a window.
A man wearing a black hat and grey shirt is drinking a glass of water in front of a window.
This con­tro­ver­sial 1973 west­ern ranks among the director’s finest works.

A gun­slinger emerges from a desert’s shim­mer­ing hori­zon like an appari­tion. He looks like the tight-lipped, cig­ar-chew­ing sharp­shoot­er of Hang Em High or Ser­gio Leone’s Dol­lars Tril­o­gy, and on paper High Plains Drifter cer­tain­ly reads like your typ­i­cal Clint East­wood west­ern. It’s the sto­ry of a mys­te­ri­ous, crack-shot out-of-town­er paid hand­some­ly to pro­tect an idyl­lic Cal­i­for­nia min­ing com­mu­ni­ty from out­laws. Stan­dard fare for East­wood cir­ca 1973.

In real­i­ty, though, the film – only Eastwood’s sec­ond effort behind the lens – is a shock­ing­ly atyp­i­cal out­lier in the actor-turned-director’s estimable canon. Eastwood’s work as film­mak­er, espe­cial­ly in the lat­ter half of his career, has a rep­u­ta­tion for being state­ly and solemn, but High Plains Drifter is black­ly com­ic with Grand Guig­nol flour­ish­es. Made when East­wood was still con­sid­ered lit­tle more than a con­ser­v­a­tive prop with a gun, it’s a keen­ly spir­i­tu­al film with such high themes as the cor­ro­sive pow­er of vio­lence on its mind.

Dis­missed by some crit­ics at the time as deriv­a­tive of East­wood men­tors Ser­gio Leone and Don Siegel, today High Plains Drifter appears dar­ing­ly orig­i­nal, enter­ing genre ter­ri­to­ry nei­ther of those film­mak­ers ever dared to tread. Uneasy from the first notes of Dee Barton’s quiv­er­ing score, the film is pitched some­where between a hor­ror movie and a psy­che­del­ic acid west­ern. It even flirts with the super­nat­ur­al, and is more rem­i­nis­cent of a ghost sto­ry trans­posed to a tra­di­tion­al west­ern set­ting than any straight­for­ward oater of its day.

Though the towns­folk of Lago ini­tial­ly turn to Eastwood’s Stranger to pro­tect them against a pack of crim­i­nals led by the mur­der­ous Stacey Bridges (Geof­frey Lewis), it tran­spires that it is he who means them most harm. Though nev­er explic­it­ly stat­ed, there are reg­u­lar hints that Eastwood’s Stranger is in fact the ghost of a Mar­shal (played by long­time East­wood stunt dou­ble Bud­dy Van Horn), seen bru­tal­ly killed in flash­back as Lago’s cit­i­zens look on. He’s res­ur­rect­ed here to give ear­ly East­wood west­ern fans exact­ly what they want, before East­wood the direc­tor deliv­ers a film far more con­tem­pla­tive and a char­ac­ter far more dis­turb­ing than any­one could have expected.

A man wearing a cowboy hat and poncho standing in a doorway, carrying a bundle of items.

What you get in High Plains Drifter is one of Eastwood’s rare ven­tures beyond anti­hero­ism into out­right vil­lainy. The Stranger intro­duces him­self to the peo­ple of Lago by clean­ly dis­patch­ing some local rogues, but then, shock­ing­ly, this Man With No Name pro­ceeds to drag a woman into a barn to rape her. He then con­vinces the entire town to daub their homes and busi­ness­es in red paint and lay out a feast to wel­come the approach­ing Bridges gang, for no appar­ent rea­son. For the entire movie, this chill­ing­ly ambigu­ous fig­ure makes it his mis­sion to humil­i­ate and ter­rorise every man and woman who has seem­ing­ly wronged him. The title is decep­tive: the Stranger is not just some ran­dom drifter’, but a man of bloody, sin­gle-mind­ed pur­pose. We quick­ly come to realise that he’s not in the killing game for mon­ey or jus­tice; he’s in it pure­ly for pleasure.

In the wake of his com­ing out for Don­ald Trump, it’s almost impos­si­ble not to scan for traces of Clint’s pol­i­tics in his work. High Plains Drifter is, not unlike the Repub­li­can Pres­i­dent-elect, para­noid and dan­ger­ous­ly anti-estab­lish­ment, cen­tring as it does on a rur­al com­mu­ni­ty cor­rupt­ed by big busi­ness. It’s a vision of a Unit­ed States that’s for­got­ten its val­ues, with a lone sav­iour’ come to aggres­sive­ly restore order. The dif­fer­ence between Trump and the anti-war, pro-gun con­trol East­wood being that the direc­tor here is crit­i­cal of such behaviour.

Before he rides back into the fore­bod­ing desert haze, Eastwood’s Stranger turns a qui­et lake­side idyll into a liv­ing hell, the whole town splashed gial­lo red with bod­ies left to rot in its dusty streets. If this was one of Eastwood’s Spaghet­ti west­erns, we might be expect­ed to cheer. But here the Stranger’s vengeance is hor­ri­fy­ing. Exist­ing some­where between Eastwood’s ear­ly west­erns and the revi­sion­ism of The Out­law Josey Wales and Unfor­giv­en, High Plains Drifter is a bleak, ugly film that’s unlike any­thing the direc­tor has made since.

You might like