The Seasons in Quincy: The Four Portraits of John… | Little White Lies

The Sea­sons in Quin­cy: The Four Por­traits of John Berger

23 Jun 2017 / Released: 23 Jun 2017

Elderly man and woman in conversation, wearing casual clothing. Man has white hair and wrinkled face, woman has blonde hair and a soft expression.
Elderly man and woman in conversation, wearing casual clothing. Man has white hair and wrinkled face, woman has blonde hair and a soft expression.
3

Anticipation.

Tilda Swinton heads up this ode to the late intellectual heavyweight.

3

Enjoyment.

A few sweet, informative moments. Enough to carry it across the line.

3

In Retrospect.

Berger diehards are likely to glean the most pleasure from this.

The famed author of Ways of See­ing is the sub­ject of this chaot­ic but charm­ing doc.

How best to cov­er the life and times of one of Britain’s fore­most poet­ic thinkers, John Berg­er, on film? Give him the lin­ear This Is Your Life treat­ment, with fawn­ing endorse­ments from friends and fam­i­ly? Stick to a sin­gle, salient episode and go into minute detail? Or maybe opt for some­thing a lit­tle more kooky and con­cep­tu­al? The Sea­sons in Quin­cy: Four Por­traits of John Berg­er goes for a lit­tle bit of all three routes, offer­ing more reme­di­al mate­r­i­al for Berg­er new­bies and a some deep-dive stuff for the superfans.

Berg­er was cat­a­pult­ed to intel­lec­tu­al infamy with his now-clas­sic TV ser­i­al, Ways of See­ing, based on his own book, in which he offered a bull­shit-free analy­sis of how we could and should read images and glean infor­ma­tion from art. This film offers some thoughts on how Berger’s ways of see­ing have devel­oped in the inter­ven­ing years, how he applies his work to life and how his ideas inter­face with the polit­i­cal real­i­ties of the world.

This film is split into four sep­a­rate seg­ments, each deal­ing with Berger’s life and work from a slight­ly dif­fer­ent van­tage. The first sees old pal Til­da Swin­ton rock up to his lit­tle farm­house in the remote Alpine region of Giffre and the cam­era watch­es as the pair wax philo­soph­i­cal while slic­ing up fruit. It sets the pair up as close friends, but the impres­sion is that she is an acolyte and he is hap­py to engage. He seems unin­ter­est­ed in her day job. And yet, it’s per­haps Swinton’s hunger for knowl­edge, for poet­ry, for ways of express­ing her desires that leave the strongest impres­sion here.

Next the focus shifts to human/​animal rela­tions as a way of express­ing the essen­tial lone­li­ness of exis­tence, and then a pan­el dis­cus­sion on rep­re­sen­ta­tions of war. To close things out, there’s more fruit based antics, as Berg­er sends Swin­tons kids off to pick rasp­ber­ries and hang out with his own son. This final sec­tion, direct­ed by Swin­ton, is a high­light, focus­ing more on inter­per­son­al tri­fles and dialling back the hard philo­soph­i­cal con­tem­pla­tions. See­ing Berg­er con­verse with Swinton’s kids is a high­light, as he active­ly tries to con­nect his com­plex world­view to the soft banal­i­ties of every­day life. The pur­suit of free­dom at any price is encap­su­lat­ed in a sweet post-cred­it sting.

It’s a scruffy work which feels like its been hashed togeth­er by hook or by crook. Swinton’s cli­mac­tic sec­tion is the only bit that comes across as a real film in which a direc­tor reacts to the land­scapes and sub­jects with the cam­era. The open­ing seg­ment tries this, but ends up being ram­bling and inco­her­ent – prob­a­bly a state many a philoso­pher has had to pass through to even­tu­al­ly reach the good stuff.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.