Sonic the Hedgehog 2

Review by David Jenkins @daveyjenkins

Directed by

Jeff Fowler

Starring

Ben Schwartz Colleen O'Shaughnessey Idris Elba Jim Carrey

Anticipation.

The first Sonic was a travesty, unlikely this is going to be much better.

Enjoyment.

A cold money-making machine and nothing more.

In Retrospect.

Spoil this Sonic! [makes obscene hand gesture]

Dashed-off sequel to the 2020 hit which makes the Chipmunks films look like Tarkovsky by comparison.

Ahead of the Sonic the Hedgehog 2 screening we saw for review purposes, a bespoke, high-end disclaimer played asking that audiences seeing the film refrain from rushing to social media to spoil its secrets. When you encounter something like that, not only does it alert you to the the perils of new media, the sanctity if the cinematic experience and our collective yearning to reveal key plot points to our pals, but it makes you think that the film you’re about to watch contains delicate and intricately-conceived plot machinations that need to be blurted out post haste.

Wouldn’t it be amazing if audiences had the right of reply to such irritating, bad-faith demands? How, indeed, is it possible to “spoil” a film like Sonic the Hedgehog 2? Not that expectations were sky high for this quick turnaround family sequel to the surprise (and similarly awful) 2020 smash, but is it right for an audience – who are made to endure a stern talking to before being entertained – to expect basic competence on any creative level? There is no way a film as aggressively poor as Sonic the Hedgehog 2 could be spoiled more than its makers have already done so themselves.

There’s a joke where people say, “This film’s plot could’ve been written on the back of a napkin!” Yet for Sonic 2, a napkin seems like the equivalent of multi-volumed antiquarian tome, as there is so little of substance to this depressingly rote endeavour. It sees the punchline-spouting blue spiny mammal (who is basically the satirical Poochie from the Simpsons taken at face value) up to his old monkeyshines in rural Seattle where he has taken to independent crime fighting.

Meanwhile, a testy echidna called Knuckles (voiced by Idris Elba) unwittingly saves Dr Robotnik (Jim Carrey) from his exile on a mushroom planet, and the pair join forces to locate a chaos emerald with untold powers. Filling out the non-sentient cast is a shy little fox called Tails (Colleen O’Shaughnessey) who has the ability to fly and has a backpack full of gadgets that are used for the sole purpose of narrative expedience.

The rest is fill-in-the-blanks filmmaking where all elements clearly could’ve done with a few more months (if not years) in the oven. The script feels like it was a poor first draft. The performances are phoned in. Even Carrey is just schtick-ing hard for his paycheque, desperately attempting to find some subtle variation on his standard arsenal of gurns, gurgles and wacky enunciations, but he rarely if ever hits the comic bullseye.

Worst of all is the quality of the computer graphics, which in many cases look incomplete, or at least not ready for audience consumption. As the animated characters dash, or engage in complex interactions with a real environment, their figures appear blocky and indistinct, as if not properly rendered. The shoddy visuals exemplify much of the film’s low-bar quality control, but it’s bizarre to see a Hollywood product looking this ugly: one sequence, in which Sonic and Knuckles are conversing on a beach after throwing sand over each other, it looks like the effects artists have literally forgotten key parts of the animation. The grim reality is that the makers know this is Sonic 2, and that no-one is really going to care.

In a film where literally the only good bit is when Sonic falls over and says, “Oww, my pelvis!”, a pre-game spoiler warning is bad form to say the least. The best way to make sure arrogant audiences don’t spoil your movie is to not treat them with borderline contempt.

Support our independent journalism and receive monthly film recommendations, exclusive essays and more

Become a member

Published 28 Mar 2022

Tags: Ben Schwartz Idris Elba Jeff Fowler Jim Carrey Sonic The Hedgehog

Anticipation.

The first Sonic was a travesty, unlikely this is going to be much better.

Enjoyment.

A cold money-making machine and nothing more.

In Retrospect.

Spoil this Sonic! [makes obscene hand gesture]

Suggested For You

Sonic the Hedgehog

By Anton Bitel

A scene-stealing Jim Carrey just about sustains this fast, fun and forgettable video game crossover.

review

Space Jam: A New Legacy

By Rogan Graham

This bloated reboot of the hit ’90s cartoon crossover is little more than a cynical exercise in brand synergy.

review

Pokémon Detective Pikachu

By Hannah Strong

Ryan Reynolds voices everyone’s favourite electric yellow rodent in this fun, fast-paced murder mystery.

review

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design