Truth and Movies

Papicha

Review by Lillian Crawford @lillcrawf

Directed by

Mounia Meddour

Starring

Amira Hilda Douaouda Lyna Khoudri Shirine Boutella

Anticipation.

Always excited about new female voices, especially from countries where they aren’t often heard.

Enjoyment.

You’ll fall in love with Nedjma and her friends and feel their heartbreak with them.

In Retrospect.

Can’t wait to see more from Meddour, this is seriously powerful filmmaking.

A group of young women come of age against the backdrop of civil war in Mounia Meddour’s vibrant, nuanced debut.

When we meet fashion student Nedjma, played by Lyna Khoudri, on a night out on the town with her mates, she seems like most free-spirited young women. Dressed to the nines, her eyelids blue, and smoking a cigarette out the cab window (it is the 1990s), it looks like another clique movie celebrating female friendship and independence.

But as with other recent films, such as Céline Sciamma’s Girlhood and Sarah Gavron’s Rocks, things in Mounia Meddour’s debut feature, Papicha, aren’t as joyous as they first seem. No matter how many times the rug is pulled from beneath Nedjma’s feet, the misogynistic violence never ceases to shock.

While Sciamma faced criticism for attempting to relate to the experience of young Black womanhood in Paris, Meddour’s direction feels unmistakably authentic. After being born and raised in Algeria, her family moved to France after her filmmaker father received death threats during the Civil War. The oppression of women shown in Papicha to be superficially founded in religion, especially through the insistence they replace their crop tops and miniskirts for hijabs, mirror the criticism she faced as a student.

In the film this takes on a broader symbolic purpose – it’s about celebrating women’s bodies rather than covering them up, but at the same time presenting the frighteningly realistic acts of terror that simple protest inspired. The university campus Nedjma and her friends live on is a microcosm not only of Algeria, but of women facing radical repression across the globe.

What Papicha so brilliantly captures is the instability of women’s experiences. Rather than being relentlessly brutal, the film’s structure better captures the ups and downs of the characters’ lives. There are periods of fun that intercut the more challenging moments, although the situation becomes more challenging as the film progresses.

Posters insisting women wear hijabs first appear outside the campus, then inside, then a patrol of veiled women breaks into Nedjma’s room, before the final bloody attack on her fashion show. She has to escape – of course she wants to enjoy herself, but she’s incredibly resilient, having worked hard to get to university and then to design and organise the catwalk. She needs to find a place where her work is celebrated, not destroyed.

What’s important here is that we never habituate to the gunshots, to the deaths and violence. It’s prevented by those breathing spaces of music, laughter, and creativity that bring us close to the characters on screen. While the film ends with Nedjma finding peace at her sister’s grave through her tears, we can’t let go once the credits roll. It’s not ultimately about religion after all – Meddour shows us that violence is ulterior to faith, since Nedjma and her friends have the same fundamental beliefs.

It’s the greatest asset of Papicha that it condemns without being dogmatic, showing its central conflict to be more complicated than Western audiences might otherwise believe.

Published 6 Aug 2020

Tags: Mounia Meddour Papicha

Anticipation.

Always excited about new female voices, especially from countries where they aren’t often heard.

Enjoyment.

You’ll fall in love with Nedjma and her friends and feel their heartbreak with them.

In Retrospect.

Can’t wait to see more from Meddour, this is seriously powerful filmmaking.

Suggested For You

It Must Be Heaven – first look review

By Charles Bramesco

Palestinian filmmaker Elia Suleiman hits the road, but home follows close behind.

Girlhood

By Anton Bitel

This quietly radical and poetic teen drama depicts the black experience in the suburbs of Paris.

review LWLies Recommends

Les Misérables – first look review

By Elena Lazic

Ladj Ly’s gritty portrait of suburban Paris tips its hat to La Haine and Do the Right Thing.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design