Truth and Movies

Moffie

Review by Hannah Woodhead @goodjobliz

Directed by

Oliver Hermanus

Starring

Kai Luke Brummer Ryan de Villiers

Anticipation.

Interesting premise with an atmospheric trailer.

Enjoyment.

A punishing watch, but arresting all the same.

In Retrospect.

Sticks in your mind; tenderness without sentimentality.

A pair of conscripts find love amid the chaos of Apartheid in Oliver Hermanus’ queer war drama.

There’s no shortage of films which focus on a young man’s sexual awakening, and even before Call Me by Your Name made a heartthrob of Timothée Chalamet, queer narratives were among the most heartfelt and vital of these, from James Ivory’s Maurice to Hettie MacDonald’s Beautiful Thing.

Oliver Hermanus’ Moffie is indeed a coming-of-age story centred on a gay protagonist, but set against the backdrop of 1980s South Africa it becomes a punishing, heartbreaking tale of clandestine longing and aggressive masculine performance.

The film’s title refers to the Afrikaans slang word for a gay man – in particular, it implies weakness, effeminacy and abnormality. Nicholas van der Swart (Kai Luke Brummer) is aware of this as he enters compulsory military service, defending the Apartheid regime against the so-called “wart gevaar”, or “black danger”. Quiet and brooding, Nick does his best to fit in alongside his fellow recruits, which largely means taking orders and engaging in a suitable amount of brotherly hijinks.

“It could be paradise, but the greed and rampant hatred that rule in the Apartheid regime infect everything.”

Structured in a similar way to Stanley Kubrick’s Full Metal Jacket, the first half of Moffie sees Nick engaged in basic training, while the latter sees him deployed with his South African Defence Force unit. The young men are detached from the war, with little interest in who they’re fighting or why – fatigued and brutalised by training, their main focus is maintaining a pack mentality and not doing anything to draw the ire of their commanding officer.

But fellow soldier Dylan Stassen (Ryan de Villiers) draws Nick’s attention, disinterested in roughhousing or the pursuit of warfare as glory. Nick knows that his desire is considered a perversion – to be outed would be a death sentence – yet Dylan offers much-needed tenderness that can’t be found anywhere else in a warzone. And Hermanus never pretends it’s anything else; the film is often loud and bloody, gruelling and violent. It’s a difficult watch, but not half as difficult as surviving it must have been for André Carl van der Merwe, who wrote the memoir of the same name.

Although Nick remains quietly hopeful that he can emerge from his military service unscathed, and that love can indeed be found in a hopeless place, Moffie isn’t a romance. There’s stark realism in the beauty of the country, with its stunning blue skies and crystal clear oceans. It could be paradise, but the greed and rampant hatred that rule in the Apartheid regime infect everything. Moffie is a bleak but necessary reminder that we still have so far to go before everyone is allowed to love who they love without living in fear.

Published 23 Apr 2020

Tags: Moffie Oliver Hermanus Queer Cinema

Anticipation.

Interesting premise with an atmospheric trailer.

Enjoyment.

A punishing watch, but arresting all the same.

In Retrospect.

Sticks in your mind; tenderness without sentimentality.

Suggested For You

Why Maurice remains one of the great queer romances

By Annie Jo Baker

James Ivory and Ismail Merchant’s stunning 1987 love story prizes sensuality over intellectualism.

Call Me by Your Name again: André Aciman on his new novel ‘Find Me’

By Emily Maskell

The American author reveals what the future has in store for Elio and Oliver in his long-awaited sequel.

How the queering of Georgian folk dance sparked a cultural revolution

By Daniel Theophanous

Levan Akin’s And Then We Danced has put LGBT+ rights centre-stage in the conservative, Orthodox country.

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design