Lore

Review by David Jenkins @daveyjenkins

Directed by

Cate Shortland

Starring

Kai Malina Nele Trebs Saskia Rosendahl

Anticipation.

Cate Shortland went a little off-the radar following her 2004 debut Somersault.

Enjoyment.

The melodramatic performances and plush settings make this a very easy watch.

In Retrospect.

Certainly sounds good on paper, but a little shallow and overstated in reality.

The bold concept behind Cate Shortland’s wrenching Nazi downfall drama is sold short by its overblown style.

How’s this for a provocative setup? Unrepentant middle-class Nazi children are – Lederhosen an’ all – ejected into the unforgiving German countryside as the regime topples around them. This time the central protagonist is a feisty young Aryan woman, and she remains fully in thrall to the glory of Germany and unshakeably repulsed by the Jewish race.

Lore is an emotive German language drama by Australian director Cate Shortland and though it is primarily an investigation into how suffering, poverty and humiliation can work towards altering our ingrained political ideals, it’s also a film which takes a topsy-turvy look how we identify with ‘strong women’ in cinema.

Lore, ably played by Saskia Rosendahl, is named guardian of her four younger siblings while her parents feverishly shred the evidence of their long-term Nazi complicity. The kids are then packed off on a daunting, 900km cross-country trek to the sanctuary of their grandmother in the North, and though their path is beset by a country’s suppurating war wounds, their only accomplice is an emaciated and mysterious Jewish drifter named Thomas (Kai Malina).

It’s a plush and strangely ornate film despite the hellish setting and there’s always the sense that Shortland is perhaps more interested in making a crimped, up-market costume drama in the mould of Jane Campion’s Bright Star than she is a bona fide survival movie with dirt under its fingernails. She incessantly beautifies the squalor and matters of tone are not helped by Max Richter’s swirling and hysterically inclined neo-classical score.

But for all its stylistic overstatement, Lore still resonates (albeit mildly) as a story about innocence lost and found. The young characters developed and practiced their vile ideology without ever being party to the atrocities of the Nazi meat grinder. When presented with the full horror of their beloved cause, Lore’s innocence is at first questioned, then corrupted, then brutally overturned.

Published 22 Feb 2013

Tags: Cate Shortland

Anticipation.

Cate Shortland went a little off-the radar following her 2004 debut Somersault.

Enjoyment.

The melodramatic performances and plush settings make this a very easy watch.

In Retrospect.

Certainly sounds good on paper, but a little shallow and overstated in reality.

Related Reviews

Berlin Syndrome

By Caitlin Quinlan

A holiday fling turns into a waking nightmare in Cate Shortland’s tense romantic thriller.

review

100 great movies by female directors – part 1

By Little White Lies

Read part one of our countdown celebrating the greatest female artists in the film industry.

Things to Come

By David Jenkins

Director Mia Hansen-Løve delivers something wonderful and somewhat unexpected – a film about cats.

review LWLies Recommends

What are you looking for?

Little White Lies Logo

About Little White Lies

Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.

Editorial

Design