Dune: Part Two – a rousing and stylish hard… | Little White Lies

Dune: Part Two – a rous­ing and styl­ish hard sci-fi sequel

21 Feb 2024 / Released: 01 Mar 2024

Two people, a man and a woman, with intense expressions, facing each other closely.
Two people, a man and a woman, with intense expressions, facing each other closely.
4

Anticipation.

We loved part one, so we're front of the queue for part two.

4

Enjoyment.

An epic undertaking that delivers a very fine adaptation of the novel and its themes.

4

In Retrospect.

The last act doesn't quite land, but the opening two hours make for some of Villeneuve's finest work.

Tim­o­th­ée Cha­la­met and Zen­daya shine as mys­ti­cal free­dom fight­ers in this grandiose and often-breath­tak­ing blockbuster.

We join Tim­o­th­ée Chalamet’s Paul Atrei­des at a moment of cau­tious accep­tance, with the prospec­tive mini-mes­si­ah hav­ing just best­ed a not­ed Fre­men war­rior in a mano-a-mano knife tussle. 

The first part of Denis Villeneuve’s impres­sive Dune saga cov­ered the open­ing sal­vo of Frank Herbert’s freaky 1965 opus, set­ting up the polit­i­cal con­text of war­ring noble fam­i­lies and a desert plan­et (Arrakis) rich in a mul­ti-pur­pose hal­lu­cino­gen referred to as the spice”. This con­tin­u­a­tion of the sto­ry charts Paul’s omi­nous rise and even­tu­al tran­scen­dence, but refus­es to ride the ragged coat­tails of his hero­ism and charis­ma, instead deal­ing in the moral mine­field that comes with being ordained a mys­tic god.

Vil­leneuve very light­ly tweaks the suc­cess­ful for­mu­la that was coined for Part One, with the sights, sounds and sen­su­al stig­ma of Arrakis car­ried over in his patent­ed, supreme­ly taste­ful less-is-more visu­al schema. Those who per­haps found that the first film sapped Herbert’s book of some of its more lurid and eccen­tric delights in favour of a stern, teu­ton­ic grandeur will be pleased to hear that the direc­tor – who is not known for work­ing in warm or com­ic hues – has scat­tered the first half of the film with some nice joc­u­lar horse­play and a few salty one-lin­ers. And not to men­tion a bur­geon­ing, beau­ti­ful­ly-realised romance between Paul and Fre­men foot­sol­dier Chani (Zen­daya).

There is focus, too, on the var­i­ous con­trap­tions and giz­mos that make life in the desert pos­si­ble, most notable of which is the icon­ic thumper” which, when plant­ed in the sand at the cor­rect point, issues a pound­ing beat to draw in the planet’s sand­worms – who are com­plete bas­tards, unless you know how to lure them in then surf on their heads. The unclut­tered design and dec­o­ra­tion of the film means that these details receive the atten­tion they deserve with­out draw­ing you out of the sto­ry which, for bet­ter and for worse, was not some­thing you could say about the David Lynch movie from 1984.

With the Atrei­des clan now dec­i­mat­ed due to a sur­prise attack from House Harkon­nen (over­seen by Stel­lan Skarsgård’s rotund floaty slime-bather, the Baron), secret­ly sanc­tioned by the Emper­or of the Known Uni­verse (Christo­pher Walken, obvs), the Fre­men now have the tac­ti­cal advan­tage of being able to mess with the planet’s spice-har­vest­ing pro­gramme. Indeed, if there’s an issue with the film at all it’s that the Harkon­nens don’t ever seem to pose that much of a threat to the Fre­men, what with their under­ground lairs and guer­ril­la war­fare tactics. 

As such, the story’s cli­max plays like the obvi­ous con­clu­sion to the a care­ful coun­ter­at­tack rather than a tense flash­point riv­en with the pos­si­bil­i­ty of fail­ure. Ret­ri­bu­tion is received in a man­ner that eschews tri­umphal­ism, to the point where it all feels a lit­tle bit rote. Yet Vil­leneuve some­how acknowl­edges this with a pair of haunt­ing, polit­i­cal­ly-loaded images which top and tail the film, both of which decry the inhu­man round­about of pow­er and the arro­gance of lead­er­ship which always seem to end up pun­ish­ing those whom it should, in the­o­ry, be elevating.

A more gen­er­al point of praise derives from the sim­ple, tac­tile qual­i­ties of the pro­duc­tion where dig­i­tal effects and green screen have been used extreme­ly spar­ing­ly. See­ing a lav­ish sci-fi epic which has actu­al visu­al tex­ture and arti­san craft is sud­den­ly spe­cial again due to the sad fact that such prac­tices have fall­en out of favour (or, more like­ly, are not deemed finan­cial­ly worth­while) with­in the Block­buster Indus­tri­al Complex. 

Film­mak­ers should take pride in the work they’ve done and want to dis­play the wares they’ve painstak­ing­ly pro­duced, and in this respect Vil­leneuve is very much fol­low­ing the charge led by Christo­pher Nolan in his belief that view­ers respect artistry that takes time and patience rather than process­es that are used as time and mon­ey savers. Sure, there is artistry in the process of dig­i­tal effects, but not when they’re being used – as they so often are – as a bandaid.

The first half of Dune: Part Two is among the best things that Vil­leneuve has ever done, though the sheer event­ful­ness of the plot and a bustling ret­inue of side-play­ers (Austin But­ler upgrad­ing Sting’s cod-pieced nin­ny from the 1984 film into a hair­less psy­chopath is wor­thy of men­tion) means that the final act does feel rushed. In terms of nar­ra­tive pac­ing, it’s easy to see how this could’ve been sliced into three films, but the ques­tion remains as to where part two would’ve end­ed and whether a lack of clo­sure may have alien­at­ed the more casu­al Dunehead.

Small nig­gles aside, this is an undoubt­ed suc­cess, and is pow­ered a clutch of lead per­for­mances – Cha­la­met, Zen­daya and Rebec­ca Fer­gu­son as a new­ly-ordained Bene Gesser­it rev­erend moth­er at the shin­ing core of the ensem­ble – help to fore­ground the rich polit­i­cal ambi­gu­i­ties inher­ent to the text.

Lit­tle White Lies is com­mit­ted to cham­pi­oning great movies and the tal­ent­ed peo­ple who make them.

By becom­ing a mem­ber you can sup­port our inde­pen­dent jour­nal­ism and receive exclu­sive essays, prints, week­ly film rec­om­men­da­tions and more.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.