Bogancloch review – film and landscape are as one | Little White Lies

Bogan­cloch review – film and land­scape are as one

29 May 2025 / Released: 30 May 2025

Words by David Jenkins

Directed by Ben Rivers

Starring Jake Williams

Black and white image of a person lying in a bed, surrounded by snow-covered furniture and decor.
Black and white image of a person lying in a bed, surrounded by snow-covered furniture and decor.
4

Anticipation.

One of Britain’s most consistently exciting and inquisitive directors returns.

4

Enjoyment.

A pleasurable hang-out movie that offers hopeful, humanistic musings on repair and rebirth.

4

In Retrospect.

See you in a decade ( hopefully!) for the continuing adventures of Jake Williams.

The lure of the Scot­tish wilder­ness was too much to resist as Ben Rivers returns there for his lat­est feature.

In his 2011 film Two Years at Sea, artist/​filmmaker Ben Rivers decamped to Scot­tish wilds with his hand-cranked 16mm cam­era and hung out with a beard­ed lon­er named Jake Williams. The film did lit­tle more than cap­ture the every­day minu­ti­ae of a man who had cho­sen to par­ti­tion him­self from urban soci­ety and the com­pa­ny of oth­ers, yet the result­ing film played more like a pas­toral post-apoc­a­lyp­tic riff on some­thing like The Omega Man. It’s over a decade lat­er and we’re back in the woods with Jake, still eking out a hap­py exis­tence in his tum­ble­down shack and drink­ing in the plea­sures of the rugged and serene landscape.

The key dif­fer­ence with this new film, Bogan­cloch, is that there is more inter­ac­tion with oth­er peo­ple, with Jake now pre­sent­ed as some­one slow­ly rein­te­grat­ing with a prim­i­tive form of soci­ety – but strict­ly on his own terms. There’s a sequence where he’s shown with a group of intrigued high­school­ers as he demon­strates the work­ing of the cos­mos with use of a wilt­ing pub para­sol and some old bits of string. Lat­er on, he’s seen lead­ing a night­time sing-along of the­mat­i­cal­ly fecund Scot­tish folk music. There’s some­thing enliven­ing and hope­ful in Jake’s world this time, where he sees poten­tial and com­pan­ion­ship in oth­er peo­ple, even if for very short and sweet bursts. 

The mate­r­i­al is ele­vat­ed by Rivers’ typ­i­cal­ly-fas­tid­i­ous for­mal approach, where high con­trast black-and-white film is processed in a way to leave glitch­es and blem­ish­es in the frame, like the film itself is a rel­ic that’s been dug up from under­neath a trees tump. Indeed, all of Rivers’ films con­tain some ele­ment of this found” qual­i­ty to them, and in this instance you’re made to feel as if Jake him­self would have con­coct­ed this thing from old ends of film reels dis­cov­ered in a ditch. The film and land­scape are as one, with the visu­al degra­da­tion echoed in the moss, rust and grime we see on the screen.

With so lit­tle con­text giv­en about Jake’s sit­u­a­tion and how he came to be out there alone, the film allows you instead to impose your own back­sto­ries and psy­cho­log­i­cal jus­ti­fi­ca­tions. There’s one sequence in which he starts rifling through a box of old music tapes and giv­ing a cou­ple of them a lis­ten; the crack­ling music sounds like it’s from Asia some­where, maybe India. You begin to won­der if Jake had been there and kept these tapes. Or maybe he was once mar­ried to an Indi­an woman way back when and we’re sud­den­ly par­ty to his own lit­tle trip down mem­o­ry lane. It’s refresh­ing that Rivers and Williams have an under­stand­ing that, just because the cam­era is point­ing at you, it doesn’t mean you need to nar­rate your actions and speak to the audi­ence down the lens.

And yet, there are ele­ments of per­for­mance in the film, where scenes have been pre-agreed and set up for show. In the cli­mac­tic shot of Two Years at Sea, Jake is seen float­ing slow­ly across a lake. In this film, he warms up the water in an old tin bath and just mar­i­nates there, this time the cam­era itself float­ing away like a bub­ble caught on the breeze, leav­ing us with anoth­er vision of bliss­ful contentment.

To keep cel­e­brat­ing the craft of film, we have to rely on the sup­port of our mem­bers. Join Club LWLies today and receive access to a host of ben­e­fits.

You might like