Unbroken | Little White Lies

Unbro­ken

11 Dec 2014 / Released: 26 Dec 2014

Man running in a race, wearing a black vest with the word "Torrance" on it.
Man running in a race, wearing a black vest with the word "Torrance" on it.
3

Anticipation.

A bigger, better chance to see if Angelina Jolie can be as interesting behind the camera as she is in front of it.

2

Enjoyment.

If this story is so incredible, why does it feel like we’ve seen it before?

2

In Retrospect.

Jolie might be a good director, but she still hasn’t directed anything good.

Angeli­na Jolie takes to the director’s chair and is over­whelmed by her deity-like sub­ject in this glossy, unex­cep­tion­al awards-baiter.

By the time Unbro­ken limps towards the fin­ish line, direc­tor Angeli­na Jolie has con­vinc­ing­ly made the case that a dozen great movies could be made about the extra­or­di­nary life of Louis Louie” Zam­peri­ni. The fol­ly of this bland and broad­ly for­get­table ver­sion is that it tries to be all of them.

Based on Lau­ra Hillenbrand’s Unbro­ken: A World War II Sto­ry of Sur­vival, Resilience, and Redemp­tion’ (Kate Upton’s favourite book, FYI), Jolie’s third fea­ture is a biopic that’s paral­ysed by the awe it bears for its sub­ject, and it’s not hard to under­stand why. A scrap­py upstate New York­er born to Ital­ian immi­grants in Jan­u­ary of 1917, Zam­peri­ni was a bul­lied teenag­er who, in order to make it through his ado­les­cence in one piece, remade him­self as a light­weight box­er. But that wasn’t meant to be — Zam­peri­ni soon learned that not fight­ing is bet­ter than los­ing, and remade him­self once more as a run­ner. Short­ly after grad­u­at­ing high school, he became the youngest Amer­i­can to ever qual­i­fy for the 5,000-meter race at the Olympics.

In 1941, Zam­peri­ni enlist­ed in the Air Force, and in 1943, the plane on which he was serv­ing as a sec­ond lieu­tenant crashed into the Pacif­ic Ocean 850 miles south of Oahu. Zam­peri­ni was one of three men to sur­vive the event, and one of two to make it through the 47 days of being strand­ed at sea that fol­lowed. Res­cued” by a Japan­ese naval unit, the two Amer­i­cans were then detained in a vari­ety of POW camps, where they did not have fun. Zam­peri­ni wouldn’t only sur­vive the war, he would live long enough to be reward­ed with a sec­ond inter­view slot on The Tonight Show with Jay Leno (so don’t accuse Amer­i­ca of not prop­er­ly hon­our­ing its heroes).

Zamperini’s sto­ry is too incred­i­ble to be fic­tion, but its telling smacks of arti­fice. The kind of film in which the events described by the clos­ing title cards are far more inter­est­ing than any­thing in the film itself, Unbro­ken begins by under­lin­ing the pro­fun­di­ty of Zamperini’s jour­ney, only to slow­ly reduce the man to the val­ues he embod­ies over the course of an increas­ing­ly dull would-be epic. The script (bur­nished by the Coen broth­ers) doesn’t give him much to work with, but ris­ing star Jack O’Connell (Starred Up, 71) is well cast as the under­sized hero, imbu­ing Zam­peri­ni with a mix of fiery deter­mi­na­tion and blue-col­lar vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty that works in all of the character’s var­i­ous states of duress. Both the actor and the film are at their best dur­ing the ear­ly going, in which Zam­peri­ni and his band of broth­ers try to stay aloft in the fly­ing scrapheaps they’re forced to fly. It’s these sequences, which main­tain a nat­u­ral­is­tic tone despite dab­bles of glar­ing­ly fake CG, in which Jolie makes her most com­pelling case as a film­mak­er — if lit­tle else, she pos­sess­es a For­dian flair for emo­tion­al­ly moti­vat­ed action.

Unfor­tu­nate­ly, Jolie’s strengths (which make her seem a bet­ter fit for a mid-bud­get sus­pense thriller than they do a bleed­ing hunk of Oscar chum) were under­mined by her weak­ness­es by the time she first arrived on set. It’s not her com­pe­ten­cy that’s the prob­lem, it’s her instincts. Jolie sub­mits to con­ven­tion by paus­ing Zamperini’s mil­i­tary adven­tures in order to flash­back to his for­ma­tive years as a bur­geon­ing track star, but fails to accom­plish any­thing with these scenes beyond under­lin­ing the runner’s fame. Obvi­ous­ly the same under­dog resilience that made Zam­peri­ni an unlike­ly Olympic con­tender resur­faces dur­ing his wartime ordeal, but the film reveres his can-do excep­tion­al­ism like it’s a birthright, like he’s sim­ply bet­ter than his less for­tu­nate comrades.

The sadis­tic Japan­ese tor­tur­er who toys with Zam­peri­ni cer­tain­ly feels the same way. Mut­suhi­ro The Bird” Watan­abe (played by pop star Miyavi) ruth­less­ly antag­o­nis­es his prized Amer­i­can charge, but the char­ac­ter is more defined by his youth­ful­ness than his vio­lence. A shal­low char­ac­ter, quick­ly for­got­ten as soon as Jolie’s cam­era diverts its atten­tion from him, The Bird’s boy­ish­ness nev­er­the­less reflects just how young all of these men are, the struc­ture of the film around them mis­tak­en­ly insist­ing that their for­ma­tive years are behind them (what­ev­er issues Jolie might have with her instincts, she con­tin­ues to show a keen eye for her select­ing her cast and collaborators).

A missed oppor­tu­ni­ty for a more nuanced win­dow to the war, the char­ac­ters’ ages, along with their inabil­i­ty to make mean­ing­ful choic­es, makes Unbro­ken feel like a YA adap­ta­tion of a more adult sto­ry, the Hunger Games to Mer­ry Christ­mas Mr Lawrence’s Bat­tle Royale. Ulti­mate­ly, Miyavi’s per­for­mance can do lit­tle to save the scenes at the var­i­ous POW camps from blend­ing togeth­er into an expe­ri­ence as point­less and pro­tract­ed as war, itself. Every­thing about Unbro­ken (includ­ing Alexan­dre Desplat’s score, stir­ring but out of place) is tilt­ed towards mak­ing Zamperini’s life feel like the incred­i­ble jour­ney that it was, but in reduc­ing such an unfath­omable sto­ry into a basic nar­ra­tive of tri­umph, Jolie’s film ulti­mate­ly makes it feel… ordinary.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.