Missing Twin Peaks? There’s never been a better… | Little White Lies

Not Movies

Miss­ing Twin Peaks? There’s nev­er been a bet­ter time to watch North­ern Exposure

06 Sep 2017

Words by Elena Lazic

Group of six people outdoors in a field, wearing casual 1980s-style clothing. Three men and three women are posing together.
Group of six people outdoors in a field, wearing casual 1980s-style clothing. Three men and three women are posing together.
This cult 90s TV show shares some unde­ni­able sim­i­lar­i­ties with David Lynch’s brainchild.

At a time when many of us are still recov­er­ing from the mind-blow­ing third sea­son of Twin Peaks, and adjust­ing to the void it has now left in our lives, anoth­er cult TV show from the 90s might just pro­vide some solace and exis­ten­tial healing.

North­ern Expo­sure fol­lows Joel Fleis­chman (Rob Mor­row), a young doc­tor fresh out of Colum­bia Uni­ver­si­ty and eager to set up his own prac­tice. A true New York­er at heart and some­thing of a city neb­bish, he is sent to work in the small fic­tion­al town of Cice­ly, Alas­ka, to repay his debt to the north­ern­most US state which paid for his edu­ca­tion. A bit­ter, ner­vous wreck of a man, Fleis­chman is forced to adapt to a qui­et lifestyle he does not understand.

Shot in the city of Roslyn, Wash­ing­ton, North­ern Expo­sure has a par­tic­u­lar­ly fog­gy, moun­tain­ous look that imme­di­ate­ly recalls David Lynch and Mark Frost’s brain­child. Twin Peaks is set in Wash­ing­ton state and much of its exte­ri­or footage was filmed in var­i­ous loca­tions about an hour’s dri­ve from Roslyn. This may sound a lit­tle sus­pi­cious, and jour­nal­ists at the time cer­tain­ly thought so, point­ing to all of the odd sim­i­lar­i­ties between the shows. Like Kyle MacLachlan’s agent Dale Coop­er in Twin Peaks, Joel Fleis­chman is an out­sider from the big city, with his own defined per­son­al­i­ty traits, tics and obses­sions. Mäd­chen Amick’s din­er wait­ress Shelly John­son finds a dou­ble and a name­sake in Cyn­thia Geary’s Shel­ley Tam­bo. Even the Log Lady seems ref­er­enced in the fig­ure of dot­ty shop­keep­er Ruth-Anne (Peg Phillips).

But while Twin Peaks unde­ni­ably had the greater cul­tur­al impact, it seems unlike­ly that the now all-but for­got­ten North­ern Expo­sure set out to imi­tate Lynch’s hit cre­ation. Orig­i­nal­ly air­ing just three months after Twin Peaks, North­ern Expo­sure put an end to spec­u­la­tion and accu­sa­tions very ear­ly on in its fifth episode with a won­der­ful meta­tex­tu­al sequence, the kind of self-reflex­ive and play­ful detour that became a sig­na­ture fea­ture of the show.

An unex­pect­ed paren­the­sis in the mid­dle of the episode’s lin­ear nar­ra­tive sees Joel, his girl­friend Elaine and local bar­tender Holling Vin­coeur (John Cul­lum, who recent­ly starred in Anto­nio Cam­pos’ Chris­tine) check­ing out the local water­falls: cue the Twin Peaks theme, men­tions of donuts and cher­ry pie, a dis­cus­sion on the pow­er of the unseen, and even a ref­er­ence to Susan Sontag.

Despite their sim­i­lar set­ting, with the same mys­te­ri­ous woods, frisky weath­er and crisp blue skies, the shows are dia­met­ric oppo­sites in terms of nar­ra­tive and tone. Where Lynch’s night­mar­ish vision trades in the malaise and fear that are often asso­ci­at­ed with life in a small Amer­i­can town, reveal­ing the mor­bid obses­sions that can arise in a place where every­body knows each oth­er, by con­trast North­ern Expo­sure cre­ators Joshua Brand and John Falsey see the inher­ent good­ness in local com­mu­ni­ty, where peo­ple tol­er­ate and love each oth­er despite their dif­fer­ences, big and small.

A person looking up at a large moose with antlers in a grassy setting.

This may sound just like any oth­er feel-good Amer­i­can TV show where peo­ple fight and make up over the course of episodes and sea­sons, but North­ern Expo­sure is in fact quite unique, oper­at­ing entire­ly on its own terms. Brought to life as a mid­sea­son slot-filler for CBS, the show did not come under much pres­sure from either the net­work or the pro­duc­ers, leav­ing Brand and Falsey free to cre­ate a show where a doc­tor is sent to a remote, cold place but rarely saves lives; where many peo­ple die yet there is no mur­der mys­tery; where sim­ple small-town life and lit­er­a­ture nat­u­ral­ly coex­ist; and where not every­thing is explained but every­thing is well.

Indeed, North­ern Expo­sure is not a show that cap­ti­vates its audi­ence with a goal-ori­ent­ed nar­ra­tive or a mys­tery wait­ing to be solved. It has no par­tic­u­lar visu­al style to speak of and doesn’t feel like the real­i­sa­tion of a director’s grand vision the way Twin Peaks does. Nor does it attempt to cheap­ly hook view­ers with the type of mind­less melo­dra­ma that is designed sole­ly to sat­is­fy an insa­tiable curios­i­ty to know what hap­pens next. Instead, North­ern Expo­sure engages its audi­ence like a good friend would, address­ing view­ers as equals, direct­ly and with real compassion.

North­ern Expo­sure is full of ref­er­ences to films, lit­er­a­ture and crit­i­cal the­o­ry, most­ly intro­duced via mono­logues from Chris Stevens, the local radio DJ. Payed with unfor­get­table charm by John Cor­bett (per­haps more famous for play­ing Aidan in Sex and the City, but here younger and sex­i­er) Chris in the Morn­ing’ reg­u­lar­ly reflects on issues relat­ed to the human con­di­tion, cit­ing con­flict­ing argu­ments from var­i­ous clas­sic authors and thinkers, and almost always find­ing a vague yet sat­is­fy­ing­ly poet­ic solution.

The rev­er­en­tial atti­tude towards the arts with­in the world of the show is ful­fill­ing and nour­ish­ing to an over­whelm­ing degree, espe­cial­ly in the con­text of con­tem­po­rary film and tele­vi­sion, where emp­ty ref­er­ences and destruc­tive irony so often pass for intel­li­gence and wit. By con­trast, Chris humbly sits on the shoul­ders of those who came before him.

Far from mock­ing Chris’ pas­sion for the Arts or reduc­ing his ref­er­ences to hol­low name-drop­ping, the show also recog­nis­es the fun­da­men­tal impor­tance of the past; the need to remem­ber his­to­ry is a cen­tral theme across its six sea­sons. Sev­er­al episodes are ded­i­cat­ed to the fic­tion­al sto­ry of Cicely’s foun­da­tion as a cul­tur­al hub, and the per­pet­u­al ten­sion between one’s roots and the out­side world is at the core of Fleischman’s exis­ten­tial malaise.

Such earnest con­cerns make for many mov­ing and rev­e­la­to­ry moments, but these would not be as endear­ing and unex­pect­ed with­out the writ­ers’ impec­ca­ble per­cep­tive­ness in dif­fer­en­ti­at­ing between the char­ac­ters’ legit­i­mate con­cerns and their sil­ly, pure­ly triv­ial wor­ries. The nar­ra­tive dri­ve behind each episode, as is the case with many oth­er feel-good TV shows, is the sense of self-impor­tance felt by the char­ac­ters. Their self­ish actions and con­cerns cre­ate con­flicts which are even­tu­al­ly resolved when they calm down and recog­nise the error of their actions.

But what makes North­ern Expo­sure so spe­cial is that despite show­ing these char­ac­ters deal­ing with emo­tions they strug­gle to under­stand them­selves, it does not take their con­cerns seri­ous­ly. When Joel protests about how cold it is, or laments the loss of his New York City lifestyle, there is absolute­ly no one there to par­tic­i­pate in his self-pity – which only frus­trates him more, push­ing him even fur­ther into stub­born pet­ti­ness to great comedic effect. Unlike Joel, most of the locals are almost com­plete­ly at peace with the fact that the world does not revolve around them.

The char­ac­ter that best illus­trates this peace of mind is Mar­i­lyn (Elaine Miles), Joel’s Native Amer­i­can sec­re­tary, who always answers to his com­plaints with the same silence and blank expres­sion. Yet far from being a mere straight foil to Joel’s dis­pro­por­tion­ate ego­tism, she actu­al­ly embod­ies the holis­tic phi­los­o­phy of the Native Amer­i­can com­mu­ni­ty that con­sti­tutes a large part of Cicely’s pop­u­la­tion. While Joel is para­noid about peo­ple insult­ing him, tak­ing away his pri­va­cy, or gen­er­al­ly abus­ing his kind­ness, Mar­i­lyn and the oth­er Native Amer­i­cans who appear reg­u­lar­ly through­out the show have such con­fi­dence in them­selves and trust between one anoth­er, that they often do away with West­ern notions of polite­ness alto­geth­er. This way of life is of such sig­nif­i­cance in the show that, at the end of the last sea­son, a new low in Joel’s per­son­al life push­es him to move to a Native camp to try and find real peace, lead­ing a sim­ple life stripped of ambi­tion, self-doubt and fear.

With mov­ing grace, North­ern Expo­sure itself achieves the very humil­i­ty that Joel is striv­ing for. Despite its real­is­tic appear­ance, the show’s numer­ous meta-tex­tu­al ref­er­ences con­stant­ly high­light its arti­fi­cial nature, as if to remind us that this is, after all, just a show, and that real life is to be lived else­where. This is a pro­found­ly melan­choly and bit­ter­sweet con­fes­sion for the cre­ators of the show to make, but it also speaks of their incred­i­ble gen­eros­i­ty, pour­ing out such time and ener­gy into a work they admit is not vital.

Rather than high­light­ing the tragedy of it all, how­ev­er, the writ­ers find joy in the triv­i­al­i­ty of any human endeav­our and clear­ly see the beau­ty in their illog­i­cal, self­less gift. The self-reflex­iv­i­ty of North­ern Expo­sure – its unre­al nature – is pre­cise­ly what allows for so many moments of pure mag­ic, com­plete­ly divorced from the rules of log­ic or sci­ence and only spo­rad­i­cal­ly explained by Native Amer­i­can leg­ends and reli­gious belief. In North­ern Expo­sure, beau­ti­ful women can steal your voice, peo­ple dream each other’s dreams, dead boyfriends come back as dogs. The Auro­ra Bore­alis, vis­i­ble from Alas­ka at a cer­tain time of year, is at the cen­tre of some of the show’s cra­zi­est episodes.

Yet one of North­ern Exposure’s stand­out moments is actu­al­ly rather low-key. It cen­tres on Ed Chigli­ak (Dar­ren E Bur­rows), a half-Native Amer­i­can teen and wannabe film­mak­er who was aban­doned by his par­ents as a baby and is now try­ing to uncov­er the iden­ti­ty of his bio­log­i­cal father. Ed’s adop­tive fam­i­ly knows noth­ing, and the boy is about to give up his search when he is sud­den­ly vis­it­ed by One-Who-Waits (Floyd Red Crow” West­er­man), a com­mu­ni­ty elder and shaman who only Ed can see. As the two of them walk across the Alaskan land­scape, One-Who-Waits paus­es in silence to lis­ten to the wind, lis­ten to the water, feel the ground for any answer as to who Ed’s father might be. There is no CGI or music, the old man’s eyes do not roll into their sock­ets and he does not start shiv­er­ing in a trance, yet the nature around him sud­den­ly seems alive.

Dur­ing the show’s homage to Twin Peaks, Holling is explic­it­ly refer­ring to David Lynch’s mon­u­men­tal cre­ation when he says often­times, it’s what you don’t see that opens up your mind to the imag­i­na­tion.” Yet per­haps no TV show demon­strat­ed this prin­ci­ple with as much enthu­si­asm and gen­eros­i­ty as North­ern Exposure.

You might like