Will The L Word revival embrace LGBTQ+ diversity? | Little White Lies

Not Movies

Will The L Word revival embrace LGBTQ+ diversity?

22 Sep 2017

Words by Roxanne Sancto

Group of women posing together, some wearing minimal clothing, on a dark background.
Group of women posing together, some wearing minimal clothing, on a dark background.
The show’s long-await­ed return is an oppor­tu­ni­ty to more accu­rate­ly rep­re­sent the les­bian community.

When Show­time announced the revival of its pop­u­lar, LGBTQ+ series The L Word ear­li­er this year, the press release was met with mixed reac­tions. The show orig­i­nal­ly aired in 2004, and was the first to focus entire­ly on the les­bian and LGBTQ+ com­mu­ni­ty in Los Angeles.

It set out to change the per­son­al nar­ra­tive of TV’s LGBTQ+ char­ac­ters and, from an ear­ly 2000s view­point, it may have suc­ceed­ed in paving the way towards diver­si­ty and the depic­tion of les­bian rela­tion­ships. Unfor­tu­nate­ly, it failed on many counts to rep­re­sent the audi­ence it was sup­pos­ed­ly relat­ing its sto­ries to. Rather than being cap­tured from a female gaze, The L Word still very much fetishised its char­ac­ters to attract a wider – in oth­er words, het­ero­sex­u­al male – audience.

In its pilot episode, we are intro­duced to Jen­ny Schecter (Mia Kir­sh­n­er), a bod­ing, Mid­west­ern writer who has obvi­ous­ly nev­er been exposed to Hollywood’s lav­ish scene and the LGBTQ+ com­mu­ni­ty with­in. She moves to LA to be with her fiancé Tim (Eric Mabius), but soon finds her­self fas­ci­nat­ed by their next-door neigh­bours, Bette (Jen­nifer Beals) and Tina (Lau­rel Hol­lo­man), a career-dri­ven, bira­cial cou­ple in the throes of start­ing their own family.

Tina and Bette’s social cir­cle main­ly con­sists of open­ly les­bian and bisex­u­al women includ­ing Alice (Leisha Hai­ley), Shane (Kather­ine Moen­nig) and Mari­na (Kari­na Lom­bard). On her first night in LA, Jen­ny plays peep­ing-tom when Shane and one of her lat­est con­quests use Bette and Tina’s pool for a steamy sex ses­sion. Excit­ed by the voyeuris­tic expe­ri­ence, she relays every­thing she has seen to Tim as a means of fore­play – Shane’s sex-life has essen­tial­ly become a visu­al for the straight cou­ple to get off on.

While The L Word does attempt to offer an authen­tic depic­tion of les­bian women and their Hol­ly­wood­i­an lifestyles, it does not dare to ven­ture out­side of the mainstream’s, het­ero­nor­ma­tive com­fort zone – the main­stream being pre­dom­i­nant­ly white and het­ero­sex­u­al. Where­as Jen­ji Kohan’s Orange Is the New Black embraces its butch char­ac­ter Boo (Lea DeLar­ia) in all her com­plex­i­ties, The L Word awk­ward­ly side-stepped the gen­der bina­ry by nev­er ful­ly allow­ing its les­bian char­ac­ters to own iden­ti­ties that veered from the cis-femme norm”.

In ear­ly episodes, it seemed Shane was intend­ed to ful­fil the butch role, but her iden­ti­ty rest­ed main­ly on her at times mas­cu­line cloth­ing and androg­y­nous appear­ance, not her actu­al char­ac­ter. When Moira (Daniela Sea) joined the show in its third sea­son, the top­ic was touched upon when she freely assumed Shane too iden­ti­fies as butch – an assump­tion Shane and her then-girl­friend Car­men (Sarah Shahi) ridiculed. But the writ­ers did not allow Moira to own her butch char­ac­ter either and, instead, we saw Moira tran­si­tion­ing into Max, and embrac­ing life as a FTM trans­gen­der man.

Max’s sto­ry­line isn’t the only one to – per­haps inad­ver­tent­ly – sug­gest that gen­der can­not be flu­id. Ivan (Kel­ly Lynch), a gen­derqueer drag king intro­duced in sea­son one, is equal­ly prob­lem­at­ic. The char­ac­ter is only regard­ed as butch when dressed in full drag – off­stage, series devel­op­ers did their best to high­light Ivan’s fem­i­nin­i­ty by ways of long blonde hair and oth­er femme features.

Through­out the series, many a con­ver­sa­tion points to its main char­ac­ters view­ing the butch iden­ti­ty as a form of role play rather than an actu­al iden­ti­ty, and as Max’s sto­ry pro­gress­es, it is point­ed out just how trans­pho­bic and close-mind­ed the LGBTQ+ com­mu­ni­ty can be towards the non-bina­ry. While this may be a real­i­ty in many LGBTQ+ com­mu­ni­ties, The L World rein­forced these atti­tudes rather than explore them, leav­ing view­ers – and the show’s non-bina­ry char­ac­ters – to feel as though no world exists out­side of the either/​or.

Although the show was way ahead of its time in its open depic­tion of LGBTQ+ char­ac­ters, rela­tion­ships and issues, its inabil­i­ty to cel­e­brate char­ac­ters on all sides of the gen­der spec­trum proved its lack of diver­si­ty. The same is very much true for its black and Lat­inx char­ac­ters. Kit (Pam Gri­er) Tasha (Rose Rollins), Car­men and Papi’s (Jan­i­na Gavankar) sto­ry­lines were main­ly based on stereo­types. Where­as Bette’s ambigu­ous racial fea­tures allow her to move through a white world rel­a­tive­ly eas­i­ly, Kit and Tasha are often por­trayed as angry, irra­tional and emo­tion­al­ly unsta­ble, and usu­al­ly rely on their Cau­casian coun­ter­parts to res­cue” them.

Sim­i­lar­ly, Car­men and Papi were con­fined to their cul­tur­al stereo­types, with Papi prid­ing her­self in the role of the smooth-talk­ing play­er and Carmen’s dou­ble-life as a clos­et­ed-les­bian in front of her strict­ly catholic fam­i­ly. These nar­ra­tives sug­gest that, while the series pushed the bound­aries of its time in one way, it still con­formed to the main­stream mass­es – Show­time clear­ly did not trust its audi­ence to relate to char­ac­ters oth­er than those who fit the white, attrac­tive, femme les­bian norm. There­fore, it often feels as though the show focus­es more on reach­ing the main­stream mass­es rather than the crim­i­nal­ly under­rep­re­sent­ed minor­i­ty groups it is sup­pos­ed­ly representing.

As is the case with most TV shows, The L Word buys into main­stream beau­ty stan­dards and only ever presents char­ac­ters who fit the cri­te­ria. Bar a few excep­tions – name­ly Kit, Phyl­lis (Cybill Shep­herd) and Joyce (Jane Lynch) – every char­ac­ter is young, beau­ti­ful, and thin, and their sex­u­al encoun­ters enjoy plen­ty of screen-time that may even be con­sid­ered explic­it. The excep­tions do not.

Kit and Phyl­lis, who are mid­dle-aged and volup­tuous, both have inter­est­ing, impor­tant sto­ry­lines, but their sex­u­al­i­ties are not per­mit­ted to be viewed in the same light as their younger, skin­nier coun­ter­parts. Had the show indeed been told from the female, or even the queer gaze, the def­i­n­i­tion of beau­ty would not have relied on appear­ance, age or gen­der, but diver­si­ty – body, gen­der, eth­nic and otherwise.

The L Word remains a ground-break­ing series – no oth­er show has come close to explor­ing the les­bian expe­ri­ence on this pro­found a lev­el. But with a revival in the works, the show’s writ­ing room should be as diverse as the new series.

You might like