Why Netflix’s live-action remake of Cowboy Bebop… | Little White Lies

Not Movies

Why Netflix’s live-action remake of Cow­boy Bebop is des­tined to fail

30 Nov 2018

Words by Kambole Campbell

Animated character on a motorbike, chasing an animated rabbit-like creature through a desert landscape with dramatic sky.
Animated character on a motorbike, chasing an animated rabbit-like creature through a desert landscape with dramatic sky.
Shinichi­ro Watanabe’s sin­gu­lar 90s show is yet anoth­er clas­sic ani­mé that should be left well alone.

In a sly move wor­thy of Vicious him­self, Net­flix has announced a live-action remake of Shinichi­ro Watanabe’s sin­gu­lar 90s ani­mé, Cow­boy Bebop, while all of Twit­ter was still cel­e­brat­ing the news that the equal­ly beloved Neon Gen­e­sis Evan­ge­lion would be mak­ing its stream­ing debut on the ser­vice. While live-action adap­ta­tions of ani­mé are noth­ing new – the Japan­ese have done it plen­ty – it is yet to yield any­thing tru­ly worthwhile.

Net­flix – in the UK at least – is a ver­i­ta­ble grave­yard of mid­dling to bad ani­mé adap­ta­tions, includ­ing Adam Wingard’s Death Note, and live-action ver­sions of Full­met­al Alchemist and Bleach. Cow­boy Bebop is the lat­est in a long line of ani­mé series to get this treat­ment – and it might just be the choice that feels the most wrong.

Gen­er­al­ly speak­ing the show is about a colour­ful, rag­tag group of boun­ty hunters referred to as cow­boys’, who strug­gle to get by and get along with each oth­er as they work through their respec­tive trau­mat­ic pasts. Most episodes unfold as stand­alone vignettes, focus­ing on a self-con­tained sto­ry while slow­ly drip-feed­ing us the back­sto­ry of pro­tag­o­nist and laid­back boun­ty hunter Spike Spiegel, and the world he inhabits.

Like the main char­ac­ter, the show is a very par­tic­u­lar mix of tragedy, bru­tal­i­ty laid­back charm, and a zen atti­tude – though Spike him­self is also a trag­ic, bit­ter man who ulti­mate­ly finds him­self unable to learn from his mis­takes. Spike says on more than one occa­sion, what­ev­er hap­pens, hap­pens”, which could be tak­en either as a sign of inner peace, or sim­ply defeat.

Born out of some­what unlike­ly cir­cum­stances (it gained fund­ing as an excuse to make toys, they spent the mon­ey on the music), Watan­abe and co pulled in influ­ences from all over the world to make some­thing tru­ly idio­syn­crat­ic and fresh. Cow­boy Bebop is often con­sid­ered gate­way ani­mé’, blend­ing ani­mé with var­i­ous aspects of West­ern pop cul­ture for a unique but uni­ver­sal­ly enjoy­able expe­ri­ence. In a cou­ple of excel­lent Twit­ter threads, film­mak­er and Mandy co-writer Aaron Stew­art-Ahn (who ear­li­er this week wrote an equal­ly good thread about Evan­ge­lion) point­ed out just how much the show is tied to spe­cif­ic influ­ences and creators.

Watan­abe is known for sam­pling of vari­ety of styles and gen­res: Samu­rai Cham­ploo mix­es Edo-peri­od samu­rai action with hip-hop cul­ture; Space Dandy bounces between gen­res so often it’s almost impos­si­ble to pin down. Out­side of Watan­abe and his writ­ing team, per­haps Cow­boy Bebop’s most impor­tant con­trib­u­tor is com­pos­er Yoko Kan­no, who along with her band The Seat­belts, con­jured up one of television’s most excit­ing sound­tracks, and the coolest open­ing theme ever made.

Kan­no and The Seatbelt’s score isn’t all fre­net­ic jazz, either. Much like how Watan­abe looked glob­al­ly for inspi­ra­tion, the show’s music com­pris­es a wide range of gen­res, from blues to reg­gae to heavy met­al and every­thing in between. It’s inte­gral to the show; an irre­place­able part of its char­ac­ter. For the most part, each episode takes its name from a style of music show­cased along­side the jazz com­po­si­tions that we’ve come to expect from it.

Despite it being a multi­na­tion­al rep­re­sen­ta­tion of human­i­ty and the West­ern influ­ences on the show, Watan­abe has reject­ed the idea that Amer­i­ca is treat­ed as the cen­tre of the world. One can only imag­ine that the show is being remade for a new US audi­ence, and accord­ing­ly to do so flies in the face of that very point. Even ignor­ing this, the very nature of the work seems resis­tant to being remade. Remakes aren’t nec­es­sar­i­ly a bad thing, but cross­ing the bound­ary between ani­ma­tion and live-action is a tricky thing to get right. In most cas­es these endeav­ours are des­tined to fail – the Wachowskis and Takashi Miike might be the only film­mak­ers to have done so successfully.

There is such a strong feel­ing of final­i­ty to Cow­boy Bebop’s last episodes that it’s clear why only one sea­son was made (the excel­lent Cow­boy Bebop: The Movie, from 2001, takes place between two of the lat­er episodes). There’s also the small mat­ter of the show’s hand-drawn action scenes, which are some of the most detailed, flu­id ani­mat­ed sequences ever cre­at­ed. Recre­at­ing this with flesh-and-blood actors and all the lim­i­ta­tions that live-action brings with it will be a chal­lenge to say the least.

On top of this, there’s the exag­ger­at­ed char­ac­ter body types, pur­pose­ful­ly designed to look noth­ing alike, and flu­id, hyper-real move­ment that Bebop became known for. While the series was fair­ly ground­ed, with a cast of real peo­ple it’s very pos­si­ble that these dis­tinct designs and move­ments will be brought all the way down to Earth, and not for the bet­ter. The show’s style, its essence, would like­ly be lost in a tran­si­tion to live action.

But then, even in the case that this is done right, there’s sim­ply not a huge desire or neces­si­ty for a cov­er ver­sion of Cow­boy Bebop. It works best as a con­tained and sin­gu­lar work, to the point where rein­ter­pret­ing it feels like rob­bing a grave, as it’s a work that feels so con­nect­ed to its cre­ators. In oth­er hands, it’ll just feel like an homage. The orig­i­nal was a bit­ter­sweet, trag­ic sto­ry about peo­ple strug­gling to improve them­selves that exists bet­ter alone.

In the defence of the new cre­ators there’s some sol­id writ­ing tal­ent involved in Chris Yost, and Bebop’s struc­ture may make it more adapt­able than most ani­mé. Hav­ing Watan­abe him­self onboard as a con­sul­tant can’t hurt either, but the task of step­ping out of the orig­i­nal show (and movie)’s shad­ow will be noth­ing short of an enor­mous bur­den. In oth­er words, they’re gonna car­ry that weight.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.