How When We Were Kings enshrined Muhammad Ali’s… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

How When We Were Kings enshrined Muham­mad Ali’s legacy

17 Jan 2018

Words by Justine Smith

Crowd of people gathered at an outdoor event, with a man in a white shirt raising his fist in the air.
Crowd of people gathered at an outdoor event, with a man in a white shirt raising his fist in the air.
Leon Gast’s award-win­ning 1996 film por­trays the heavy­weight champ as an artist, philoso­pher and poet.

An unearth­ly ten­sion runs through When We Were Kings. Paid five mil­lion dol­lars each, Muham­mad Ali and George Fore­man are flown to Zaïre (now The Demo­c­ra­t­ic Repub­lic of the Con­go) to fight for the heavy­weight title of the world. Only the bru­tal dic­ta­tor Mobu­tu Sese Seko was will­ing to put up the mon­ey for the fight and Don King, the infa­mous fight pro­mot­er, was hap­py to do busi­ness. State vio­lence hangs around the edges of the frame and the impend­ing monsoon’s fill the air with heavy elec­tric­i­ty. More than just a fight movie, this is a work of phi­los­o­phy and poet­ry and a doc­u­ment of Muham­mad Ali as an artist.

The aes­thet­ic tightrope that the doc­u­men­tary bal­ances on, invokes the romance of the ring and the dan­ger­ous obses­sion that goes with it. Ali and Fore­man are por­trayed as two men dri­ven to bat­tle and long before they enter the ring, they exchange words on the open stage. Cor­rup­tion bleeds into the lead-up, as the con­di­tions of a fight with­in is rife with para­noia and uncer­tain­ty. I’ve nev­er seen Don King look so young but he is unmis­tak­able with his up-brushed hair and open smile. He shakes hands and intro­duces him­self to every­one, treat­ing each man like roy­al­ty. He quotes Shake­speare to the press, who ask him to slow down and repeat every word so they can put it into print. Nor­man Mail­er, one of the film’s talk­ing heads, explains that Don King rarely had the best inter­est of fight­ers at heart but even know­ing that, he nev­er failed to charm you.

The phys­i­cal toll of the fight sim­i­lar­ly weighs on the film. Billed as a fight that pit wis­dom against youth, Muham­mad Ali’s face was already begin­ning to reflect the bru­tal­i­ty of his lifestyle. He had already been in the busi­ness for about 10 years and had been knocked down more than a few times. What hap­pens to a life after box­ing seems to be a cen­tral tenet of the film, as the phys­i­cal and psy­cho­log­i­cal toll of the game keeps draw­ing you back in. Ten years after this fight, just three years into his retire­ment, Ali was diag­nosed with Parkinson’s that doc­tors believed was caused by his fight­ing. He was 42 years old.

From the ear­li­est days of cin­e­ma, going all the way back to 1894 and Edison’s first box­ing record­ing, the Leonard-Cush­ing fight (a snip­pet of which exists on YouTube), the medi­um seemed per­fect­ly suit­ed for cin­e­ma. Over a hun­dred years lat­er, that small piece of film flick­ers at a speed slight­ly slow­er than real­i­ty, a haunt­ing expres­sion of bod­ies in motion. Extend­ing that ear­ly kinet­ic obses­sion to fic­tion in movies like The Champ and The Set-Up, cin­e­ma could not be bet­ter suit­ed to fight­ing which was beau­ti­ful to watch and served as a cru­cial metaphor for man’s strug­gles for respect, love, and peace. Even the best of these films though (I’d argue from the first fifty years of cin­e­ma, it would be Robert Rossen’s Body and Soul from 1947) could not have pre­dict­ed the com­pli­cat­ed poet­ry of Muham­mad Ali.

The strength of When We Were Kings is the strength of Ali’s screen pres­ence. While George Fore­man is noth­ing to laugh at, this movie belongs to The Great­est.” In Zaïre, Ali was con­sid­ered some­thing of an icon and the peo­ple of the coun­try all want­ed him to win. They admired the way he stood up to the Amer­i­can mil­i­tary when he refused to be draft­ed in Viet­nam, which cost him years of his fight­ing when it led him to be stripped of his title.

Decades lat­er his words still burn. My con­science won’t let me go shoot my broth­er, or some dark­er peo­ple, or some poor hun­gry peo­ple in the mud for big pow­er­ful Amer­i­ca,” he said. And shoot them for what? They nev­er called me nig­ger, they nev­er lynched me, they didn’t put no dogs on me, they didn’t rob me of my nation­al­i­ty, rape and kill my moth­er and father. … Shoot them for what? How can I shoot them poor peo­ple? Just take me to jail.”

The talk­ing heads in When We Were Kings are wit­ness­es rather than par­tic­i­pants; artists, and jour­nal­ists like Nor­man Mail­er, George Plimp­ton, and Spike Lee. They dis­cuss the events with colour and imag­i­na­tion, imbu­ing mean­ing into Ali’s silent ram­blings to him­self between rounds and the fren­zy of his pre-fight Dance. They admire Ali not just as a fight­er but as a poet, a man who could ele­vate a pre-fight taunt to leg­end (“I mur­dered a rock, injured a stone, hos­pi­talised a brick”). The com­pli­cat­ed rich­ness of the film’s con­text, from the witch-doc­tor fetishist warn­ing of the shak­ing hands to the blood-soaked sta­di­um, is brought to life through their testimonies.

Words and myth though, become sub­servient to the crack­ling sat­u­rat­ed image. The colour of Zaïre and the move­ments of Ali are mas­ter­ful. He shad­ow box­es on an open road, the thick humid­i­ty of the air obscur­ing a pink, dis­tant sun, as he chants with chil­dren, Ali Bomaye!” (Ali, Kim Him!). The film’s edit­ing style, evokes a kind of new age Sovi­et Mon­tage, as mean­ing and ideas are shaped by an irre­versible com­pound­ing of images and ideas. At the same time as the fight an equal­ly trou­bled con­cert, Zaïre 74, was being staged and the music of James Brown, BB King and Miri­am Make­ba serves as the film’s rhyth­mic backdrop.

Were Ali still alive today, he would be turn­ing 76. More than just one of the great­est ath­letes of all time, he was one of the great philoso­phers of the mod­ern world. When We Were Kings encap­su­lates the poet­ry and the tragedy of Ali’s body and ide­ol­o­gy. Paint­ing him as a flawed man with­in a sport rife with vio­lence and cor­rup­tion, he rep­re­sents human­i­ty at large, chas­ing fire until it burns out. Few doc­u­men­taries cap­ture the sense of the moment as beau­ti­ful­ly as When We Were Kings, that remains vital over twen­ty years after its release.

You might like