The Fallen Idol is one of the great films about… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

The Fall­en Idol is one of the great films about the loss of child­hood innocence

30 Sep 2018

Words by Adam Scovell

Three well-dressed people, two men and one woman, sitting at a table in a café or restaurant. The image is in black and white.
Three well-dressed people, two men and one woman, sitting at a table in a café or restaurant. The image is in black and white.
Car­ol Reed’s 1948 clas­sic cap­tures the tran­si­tion to adult­hood in all its con­tra­dic­tions and hypocrisies.

Childhood’s end is nev­er a straight­for­ward precipice. Instead, a long, mean­der­ing gap appears between youth and adult­hood that varies depend­ing upon an infi­nite array of per­son­al, social and even eco­nom­ic fac­tors. Yet the begin­ning of this process can be marked indi­vid­u­al­ly and, in cin­e­ma, this has rarely been bet­ter por­trayed than in Car­ol Reed’s 1948 film The Fall­en Idol.

Based on a short sto­ry by Gra­ham Greene, the film fol­lows one of these very par­tic­u­lar moments when the wor­ry-free world of a child becomes marked by the oncom­ing real­i­ty of adult­hood with all of its con­tra­dic­tions and hypocrisies. Allow­ing such a nar­ra­tive to unfold through naïve eyes pro­duces a stark but empa­thet­ic sto­ry that reflects and reminds us of some per­son­al equiv­a­lent, even if it is like­ly far from the clear wealth and priv­i­lege of the lives on show.

The Fall­en Idol fol­lows a few days in the pleas­ant life of Philippe (Bob­by Hen­rey), the son of a diplo­mat liv­ing in the high-ceilinged wealth of an embassy in Bel­gravia (Grosvenor Cres­cent, to be exact, where Reed lat­er filmed 1968’s Oliv­er!). Philippe is left alone for large peri­ods of time in the care of the embassy but­ler, Baines (Ralph Richard­son), and his wife, Mrs Baines (Sonia Dres­del). Baines has con­coct­ed a fan­tas­ti­cal, colo­nial his­to­ry for him­self in order to keep Philippe enter­tained but also as a dis­trac­tion from his dis­in­te­grat­ing mar­riage. He is hav­ing an affair with a younger work­er at embassy, Julie (Michèle Mor­gan), whom Philippe meets by chance.

How­ev­er, Mrs Baines is sus­pi­cious and, when the boy acci­den­tal­ly gives away the affair, she hides in wait in the house for the pair to be caught. Find­ing the affair in full swing, Mrs Baines flies into a rage, hurt­ing Philippe and try­ing to gain access to the room in which she believes Julie to be. She climbs onto a bal­cony but is pushed off by an open­ing win­dow, falling to her death at the bot­tom of the stairs. Philippe runs away believ­ing, false­ly, that he has seen Baines kill his wife. The police become ever more sus­pi­cious as the boy’s desire to pro­tect his hero lends cre­dence to the false sus­pi­cion of mur­der at Baines’ hands.

One of Reed’s sig­na­ture cin­e­mat­ic tech­niques is to play with the camera’s per­spec­tive. In The Third Man, we are left in the dark for as long as its con­fused main char­ac­ter (Joseph Cot­ton), blun­der­ing with him through Vienna’s bat­tered streets, while in Odd Man Out, the cam­era stut­ters and stag­gers as the injured Irish Nation­al­ist (James Mason) tries to evade the police. The Fall­en Idol is more dis­arm­ing than both of those bril­liant films as its per­spec­tive is so inno­cent, so helpless.

When the tragedies of adult­hood become slow­ly appar­ent, the pathos is almost unbear­able as Reed frames every­thing through Philippe’s eyes. His wit­ness­ing of a mur­der which isn’t real­ly a mur­der and his blind­ness to the affair are all sim­ply part of his per­cep­tion as a child. It’s the nat­ur­al view of some­one with tof­fees stuck togeth­er in their pock­ets and a pet snake hid­den behind a loose brick in the wall. Through high­light­ing this view­point, the main crux of the film – the loss of faith in author­i­ty fig­ures and, over­all, the truth – becomes all the more affect­ing. Richardson’s per­for­mance is per­fect in build­ing this up with his match­es lit with sin­gle, per­fect strikes and a pen­chant for sneak­ing iced buns in between meals.

He’s the part­ner-in-crime every child­hood cries out for, espe­cial­ly one with clear­ly dis­tanced, busy par­ents. We feel the hurt of his betray­al and fall from grace because Philippe feels it. At the end, author­i­ty was built on a jum­ble of enter­tain­ing lies which hid things beyond the com­pre­hen­sion of the young boy. The final tragedy being how the last instance of truth telling no longer mat­ters, shrugged off by the police in a slight mix-up; where fal­si­ty led to the truth of Baines’ inno­cence with thank­ful serendip­i­ty. Philippe is only real­ly saved from his shak­en faith by the arrival of his par­ents and even then, the film ends before any­thing else is confirmed.

The Fall­en Idol is essen­tial­ly about that first, tear­ing loss of child­hood inno­cence – the first moment when the fal­lac­i­es and imper­fec­tions of those we look up to and idolise become appar­ent. In spite of its play­ful atmos­phere and the nat­ur­al draw­ing-room warmth that British cin­e­ma of this peri­od was drenched in, Reed’s film presents this moment laced with sad­ness. High­light­ing the child­ish­ness of com­plete trust in our elders cre­ates an alarm­ing and melan­cholic effect over­all. We’ve got to think of lies and tell them all the time,” sug­gests Philippe, and then they won’t find out the truth.” The first step out of child­hood nev­er felt more acute­ly painful. Though it was ulti­mate­ly inevitable and the great­est tragedy is that it always will be.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.