In praise of Holy Motors | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

In praise of Holy Motors

07 Dec 2017

Words by Ben Nicholson

Green-faced woman in black leather jacket, standing in a dimly lit warehouse-like setting with cars in the background.
Green-faced woman in black leather jacket, standing in a dimly lit warehouse-like setting with cars in the background.
One of the great screen visions of mod­ern Paris come to the ICA on 35mm in asso­ci­a­tion with MUBI

Is the film telling a sto­ry? No, it is nar­rat­ing a life. The sto­ry of a life? No, the expe­ri­ence of being alive” 
– Leos Carax

Mid­way upon the jour­ney of our life
I found myself with­in a for­est dark,
For the straight­for­ward path­way had been lost.”
– Dante Alighieri, The Divine Comedy

When Holy Motors debuted at the Cannes Film Fes­ti­val in 2012, it was billed as the return of French cinema’s enfant ter­ri­ble, Leos Carax. Now 51 years old, he hadn’t made a film since his exper­i­men­tal Her­man Melville adap­ta­tion, Pola X, in 1999. He’d orig­i­nal­ly burst onto the scene with 1984’s Boy Meets Girl and sub­se­quent­ly cul­ti­vat­ed a rep­u­ta­tion for fan­tas­tic, ambi­tious work.

Despite the break, and advanc­ing years, Holy Motors is his most bold and adven­tur­ous film to date; a free­wheel­ing voy­age of dis­cov­ery that is dense with ideas, but so fleet of foot that it pos­i­tive­ly brims with vital­i­ty. It’s a play­ful explo­ration of cin­e­mat­ic his­to­ry, of the nature of per­for­mance and iden­ti­ty, of rebirth and meta­mor­pho­sis – a love let­ter to life itself. A love let­ter co-writ­ten by the actor Denis Lavant and Dante Alighieri.

In the film’s open­ing moments, Carax him­self appears, wak­ing up in a hotel room dec­o­rat­ed in tree-pat­terned wall­pa­per. He dis­cov­ers a hid­den door and walks through it into a cin­e­ma where slack-jawed mass­es stare, unblink­ing­ly, at a flick­er­ing screen. It’s an hal­lu­ci­na­to­ry sequence that sets the tone for the irre­sistible dream log­ic of what is to fol­low. Carax has him­self con­firmed that the open­ing lines of Dante’s Infer­no (quot­ed above) inspired the scene – per­haps giv­ing an oblique glimpse into his moti­va­tion for return­ing to the medi­um. It also sig­nals that Holy Motors is itself a bravu­ra riff on Dante’s epic which, rather than depict­ing a descent into Hell, journey’s into the very essence of being.

A fer­ry across the Riv­er Acheron acts as the sym­bol­ic pas­sage for Dante the author to become Dante the char­ac­ter with­in the work. A ship’s horn blows as Carax looks up at the screen and the pic­ture cuts, with mas­ter­ful edit­ing eli­sion, to a house with dis­tinct­ly naval char­ac­ter­is­tics. From it emerges Carax the char­ac­ter, played by the director’s muse Denis Lavant. Carax’s real name is Alex Cristophe Dupont (his nom-de-ciné­ma is an ana­gram of his first name and Oscar’) and Lavant has thrice played char­ac­ters named Alex in Carax’s films.

On this occa­sion, he is the mer­cu­r­ial Mon­sieur Oscar. He enters a white lim­ou­sine chauf­feured by Édith Scob’s watch­ful Vir­gil, Céline, and spends a day criss­cross­ing Paris for nine appoint­ments’. This involves don­ning a series of cos­tumes, pros­thet­ics, and per­sonas to embark on vary­ing­ly bizarre pub­lic per­for­mances that appear to have no audience.

It’s a vir­tu­oso turn from Lavant, who is list­ed in the cred­its as Denis Lavant x 11.” He’s required to go from being a hunched old lady to a wiry thug and lat­er, to a dying man. There are some roles in which he can rev­el in the ener­getic phys­i­cal­i­ty for which he’s known – such as a brief acro­bat­ic sojourn in a motion cap­ture stu­dio – to oth­ers in which more emo­tion­al nuance is required.

Arguably the most wide­ly seen role is that of Merde’ a char­ac­ter that first appeared in Carax’s seg­ment of the port­man­teau film Tokyo, as a kind of pre­pos­ter­ous art­house inflec­tion on the destruc­tive Godzil­la arche­type. He repris­es the role in Holy Motors, ram­pag­ing across the Père Lachaise ceme­tery and into an Eva Mendes pho­to­shoot. Lavant imbues the unfor­get­table troglodyte crea­ture with unerr­ing empa­thy. Carax has spo­ken about being uncer­tain whether Lavant could man­age two of the more sub­tle scenes, but he was hap­py to be proved com­pre­hen­sive­ly wrong.

The film’s var­i­ous sequences are open to inter­pre­ta­tion, mal­leable to whichev­er nar­ra­tive pro­gres­sion a view­er is finds in the work. Some see allu­sions to cin­e­mat­ic his­to­ry and evo­lu­tion, like an open­ing shot of Eti­enne-Jules Marey’s pre-cin­e­ma exper­i­men­ta­tion. There are ref­er­ences to the work of Jean-Luc Godard, Georges Fran­ju, Carax him­self, and a final scene that can’t help but evoke the work of Disney’s Pixar. Refer­ring back to Dante, Oscar’s jour­ney through tan­gen­tial­ly relat­ed scenes, which could eas­i­ly be assigned labels like lust’ and fraud’, can rep­re­sent the decline through hell’s circles.

Strip­ping away arti­fice as he goes, Lavant trans­forms from the overt stag­ing of the unseen and unre­al (the ignored home­less woman or the mo-cap artiste) to sub­tle human­i­ty (a dying man, a home­mak­er’). He is con­tin­u­al­ly more inti­mate and expres­sive with each sep­a­rate per­for­mance, find­ing final truth in a Parisian sub­urb. Or, do the likes of Kylie Minogue’s Jean Seberg-esque cameo, or Edith Scob’s final scene, sug­gest that it’s still all just a per­for­mance? Per­haps that’s the final truth about the lived expe­ri­ence in Carax’s stun­ning, baroque masquerade.

Holy Motors plays as part of Light Show #1 – a sea­son of films on 35mm curat­ed by MUBI, the ICA and Lit­tle White Lies. The film screens on Sun­day 10 Decem­ber at 8pm. Book tick­ets here.

You might like