How Mulholland Drive perfected the art of the… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

How Mul­hol­land Dri­ve per­fect­ed the art of the jump scare

08 Apr 2017

Words by Greg Evans

Weathered wall with barred window, concrete, metal bars.
Weathered wall with barred window, concrete, metal bars.
If you recog­nise this scene, you’ll already know what’s coming…

Man­ag­ing expec­ta­tions for a film can be dif­fi­cult, espe­cial­ly where genre cin­e­ma is con­cerned. Even before you sit down to watch a hor­ror movie, for instance, it’s typ­i­cal to antic­i­pate being fright­ened or at least pro­voked into some kind of vis­cer­al reac­tion. Rarely do you see hor­ror effec­tive­ly util­is­ing new tech­niques in order to scare viewers.

Con­sid­er the jump scare, an all-too famil­iar trick that sel­dom fails to deliv­er. Its pow­er to manip­u­late and hold the atten­tion of the audi­ence is an art in itself, which when per­fect­ed can be auda­cious and deeply dis­turb­ing. In Mul­hol­land Dri­ve, direc­tor David Lynch inverts this method to craft a scene that is so con­fi­dent in its abil­i­ty to ter­ri­fy us that it actu­al­ly lays out pre­cise­ly how it will do so.

Eleven min­utes into the film, we enter the fic­tion­al Winkie’s Din­er on Sun­set Boule­vard. Two men are sat oppo­site each oth­er at a table. There is noth­ing par­tic­u­lar­ly notable about the inside of the din­er. It is almost com­plete­ly unre­mark­able. Why are we here? These men have not fea­tured in ear­li­er scenes. All we have seen so far is a jit­ter­bug com­pe­ti­tion and a car crash that trau­ma­tised one vic­tim so bad­ly that she had to seek refuge in a near­by house. Is this scene part of that sto­ry? As view­ers, we are left con­fused and on edge – but the mys­tery at hand is already work­ing its magic.

Dan and Herb (played by Patrick Fis­chler and Michael Cooke), are notice­ably dif­fer­ent in their body lan­guage. Dan is anx­ious, uptight and pos­si­bly sleep deprived. By con­trast Herb is relaxed and con­fi­dent. Dan tells Herb why they are here. He has had the same dream about this place, this very din­er, on two sep­a­rate occa­sions. Both men are present in this seem­ing­ly mun­dane vision and both are scared beyond belief.

The cause of their fear is the pres­ence of a man behind the build­ing, who Dan can see through the wall. He says he nev­er wants to see that man’s face out­side of a dream but stops short of describ­ing his tormentor’s fea­tures. Herb ini­tial­ly cracks a joke but becomes more intrigued as the sto­ry pro­gress­es. Upon its con­clu­sion, he decides that they should both go out­side and see if the man is actu­al­ly there.

It is made clear that all this is not tak­ing pace inside a dream, so there is lit­tle chance that the man is behind the din­er. And yet every­thing about this scene sug­gests that it is indeed a dream. The cam­era is shaky, bare­ly stay­ing still and care­less­ly roam­ing up and down and behind the two char­ac­ters. Despite the fact that we are in a busy din­er in the mid­dle of the day, the only dis­cernible sound is of the men’s voic­es. There is no noise com­ing from the kitchen, the oth­er cus­tomers or the street out­side. The ten­sion is pal­pa­ble and increas­es fur­ther when they exit to inves­ti­gate whether or not some­thing wicked lies in wait. Per­haps this is the dream.

This is a jump scare par excel­lence – unlike any oth­er in the his­to­ry of cin­e­ma. It takes place in broad day­light in an urban envi­ron­ment. Lynch turns this seem­ing­ly safe space into a night­mare sce­nario where noth­ing is cer­tain and dan­ger lurks just around the cor­ner. For his part, Fis­chler con­veys more ter­ror in five min­utes than most actors man­age over the entire course of their careers. He is sweat­ing and short of breath through­out. When he final­ly approach­es the rear of the din­er, he moves ten­ta­tive­ly, rigidly.

His fear of what is about to come com­bined with the atmos­phere of the scene cre­ate a tru­ly mes­meris­ing piece of cin­e­ma that works despite the cli­max hav­ing already been spoiled just moments before. It almost doesn’t mat­ter if the man is actu­al­ly behind Winkie’s or not. The sense of dread that this scene engen­ders is so intox­i­cat­ing that it per­se­veres for the pro­ceed­ing two-and-a-half hours.

In Mul­hol­land Dri­ve, we are told to expect one thing but choose instead to believe some­thing else. This thread runs right through the film, from the audi­tion scene to Club Silen­cio, where every­thing has already been described in detail yet in the moment we are ful­ly engrossed nonethe­less. The way that Lynch con­structs each scene in the film is extra­or­di­nary, but it is Winkie’s Din­er which shows the direc­tor at his most bla­tant and manip­u­la­tive best. As view­ers we are con­di­tioned to antic­i­pate what comes next, but just when we think we’ve got the answers, Lynch changes the ques­tions and stills gets results.

You might like