The search for truth in Christopher Nolan’s… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

The search for truth in Christo­pher Nolan’s Memento

05 Sep 2020

Words by Daniel Broadley

A shirtless man with tattoos on his arms sits at a desk, writing or reading intently.
A shirtless man with tattoos on his arms sits at a desk, writing or reading intently.
Guy Pearce’s amne­sia-suf­fer­ing, tat­too-cov­ered pro­tag­o­nist is cinema’s ulti­mate unre­li­able narrator.

When we sit down to watch a film, we do so with a degree of trust that what we’re about to see will be true with­in the world of the film. So when a film­mak­er decides to tell their sto­ry from the per­spec­tive of an unre­li­able nar­ra­tor, as Christo­pher Nolan does in 2000’s Memen­to, we are forced to reassess and search for new meaning.

The search for truth and mean­ing is at the very heart of Memen­to. Leonard’s (Guy Pearce) search comes in the form of aveng­ing his wife, and while the mur­der-mys­tery sto­ry­line – along with the femme fatale fig­ure, nar­ra­tive voiceover and black-and-white cin­e­matog­ra­phy – are all hall­marks of clas­sic noir, Memento’s struc­ture and the way it depicts the mal­leable nature of mem­o­ry makes Leonard’s search for truth and mean­ing end­less­ly futile.

This is best evi­denced in Leonard’s tat­toos, as well as the Polaroids and notes he keeps. These tools are the means with which he records his short-term mem­o­ry and man­ages his day-to-day life. He appears to func­tion well enough at first, but when it becomes appar­ent that what Leonard believes to be true is objec­tive­ly false, we realise that these tools are mere­ly val­i­dat­ing his dis­tort­ed real­i­ty. Or, what philoso­pher and cul­tur­al the­o­rist Jean Bau­drillard might call his hyper­re­al­i­ty’: a sim­u­la­tion which has become more real to Leonard than real­i­ty itself.

Accord­ing to Bau­drillard, a total under­stand­ing of human exis­tence is impos­si­ble and beyond our com­pre­hen­sion because we have become over­ly reliant on signs and sym­bols. Exces­sive efforts to gain a com­plete under­stand­ing of our real­i­ty results in us being enticed by a state of hyper­re­al­i­ty. This is ulti­mate­ly what hap­pens to Leonard: he depends entire­ly on his tat­toos, Polaroids and notes, and the more he tries to cre­ate a coher­ent pic­ture and edge clos­er to the truth, the more he is seduced by his hyperreality.

For instance, Leonard even goes so far as to hire a pros­ti­tute to play his dead wife. In the moment where she wakes him up by slam­ming the door, he is able to sus­pend him­self in the belief that his wife is still alive. Addi­tion­al­ly, each time Leonard is chal­lenged he falls back on his notes and Polaroids and fur­ther into his hyper­re­al­i­ty, such as when he choos­es to ignore Teddy’s (Joe Pan­to­liano) warn­ing against the manip­u­la­tive Natal­ie (Car­rie-Anne Moss). Tip-toe­ing around the truth, Leonard reacts like a stub­born child, recit­ing his back­sto­ry like a script: I don’t have amne­sia. I remem­ber every­thing right up until the inci­dent. My name is Leonard Shel­by. I am from San Francisco.”

At the film’s cli­max, where the back­wards-flow­ing coloured scenes and chrono­log­i­cal black-and-white scenes meet, Ted­dy reveals to Leonard (or rather, reminds him of) the actu­al truth. That he is respon­si­ble for his wife’s death and that he invent­ed the sto­ry of Sam­my Jankis to cope with his guilt. So you lie to your­self to be hap­py,” he tells him. We all do it.” Through this, Ted­dy expos­es the mean­ing­less­ness of Leonard’s end­less, cycli­cal search for the truth. He is, in Teddy’s words, play­ing detec­tive.” Ted­dy pays the ulti­mate price for this, but because Leonard will soon for­get, he is able to set him­self off on anoth­er aim­less path of redemption.

Leonard’s expe­ri­ence with­in Memen­to reflects our expe­ri­ence of watch­ing it. We try to make sense of what is in front of us and put the pieces togeth­er, but because we are total­ly sub­ject­ed to Leonard’s view of the world, we expe­ri­ence the non-lin­ear sto­ry as Leonard does. Nolan has even said that he’s seen the film hun­dreds of times, but can walk into a screen­ing and not know which scene comes next, and that peo­ple who worked on the film with him still argue about the var­i­ous inter­pre­ta­tions of it today.

I have to believe in a world out­side my own mind. I have to believe that my actions still have mean­ing, even if I can’t remem­ber them.” Leonard’s ulti­mate goal is for his life, even if he can­not remem­ber most of it, to have mean­ing. Deep down, he knows that it can’t, but by con­struct­ing his own fake puz­zles to solve and hyper­re­al­i­ty to live in, Leonard nev­er needs to face the truth. He has the lux­u­ry of for­get­ting, after all. But he can­not go on like this for­ev­er. Real­i­ty will, one day, catch up with him.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.