The further dimensions of Desperately Seeking… | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

The fur­ther dimen­sions of Des­per­ate­ly Seek­ing Susan

03 Oct 2017

Words by Leigh Clark

A woman with curly blonde hair and sunglasses, wearing a patterned jacket and smiling.
A woman with curly blonde hair and sunglasses, wearing a patterned jacket and smiling.
Does Madonna’s icon­ic pyra­mid jack­et con­tain a hid­den message?

Direc­tor Susan Seidelman’s sec­ond fea­ture, Des­per­ate­ly Seek­ing Susan, had var­i­ous big names attached to it in pre­pro­duc­tion. At one point Diane Keaton and Goldie Hawn were in talks for the lead roles. Melanie Grif­fith, Jen­nifer Jason Leigh and singer Susanne Vega were also con­sid­ered for the role of Susan, before the part even­tu­al­ly went to the biggest female pop star on the plan­et, Madon­na, with Rosan­na Arquette chas­ing her coat tails as Roberta.

As with Seidelman’s debut fea­ture, Smithereens, Des­per­ate­ly Seek­ing Susan focus­es on a female pro­tag­o­nist liv­ing in New York City. Apply­ing spit and pol­ish to her grit­ty aes­thet­ic and adding some star qual­i­ty to the mix, the direc­tor was able to con­fi­dent­ly shift from a work that sat com­fort­ably along­side Jim Jarmusch’s ear­ly films to cre­ate some­thing more main­stream and digestible while suc­cess­ful­ly cap­tur­ing the zeit­geist of the ear­ly 80s. This is the sto­ry of two women whose worlds col­lide amid mar­riage trou­ble, mem­o­ry loss and a pair of valu­able miss­ing ear­rings. At the time many crit­ics labelled the film a screw­ball com­e­dy’, but beneath its sur­face there are fur­ther dimen­sions to explore.

As the title sug­gests, Susan is both need­ed and want­ed, where­as Rober­ta is locked into a stag­nant mar­riage. Her per­son­al des­per­a­tion is evi­dent in the open­ing sequence, where she sits in a salon sur­round­ed by a gag­gle of house­wives. Roberta’s eager redis­cov­ery of Susan in the clas­si­fieds gives her a glimpse of a life beyond the con­straints of tra­di­tion­al wed­lock. Lat­er, when cel­e­brat­ing her husband’s career suc­cess­es at a house par­ty, Rober­ta catch­es her pathet­ic reflec­tion and is met by the image of a mun­dane, trapped Fort Lee house­wife. But then, as New York City glis­tens in the dis­tance, she expe­ri­ences a pre­mo­ni­tion of a new life, and her reflec­tion becomes an alter­nate iden­ti­ty, one void of the restric­tions of mar­riage. After the par­ty she sits alone in the kitchen watch­ing Alfred Hitchcock’s Rebec­ca, and recog­nis­es her­self in the fatal tale of a wife unable to live up to her husband’s expectations.

Two individuals, a woman wearing a pink top and floral headband, and a man in a black shirt, seated on a park bench.

Madon­na was a huge star in 1985, and the role she plays in Des­per­ate­ly Seek­ing Susan is not too far removed from the per­sona she adopt­ed through­out the decade. It is like­ly that a large por­tion of the audi­ence were Madon­na fans and Rober­ta, like them, is kept at arms length, first glimps­ing Susan through a coin oper­at­ed tele­scope before can­did­ly stalk­ing her across the city. This is where Roberta’s char­ac­ter becomes relat­able as her posi­tion mir­rors that of a mild­ly obses­sive fan. Rober­ta then pro­ceeds to mim­ic her idol, until her amne­sia enables her to become Susan completely.

Susan is a strong, sex­u­al and self-con­fi­dent woman. We are intro­duced to her as she rolls around on a hotel bed tak­ing pic­tures of her­self with a polaroid cam­era. She tucks a self­ie into her jack­et pock­et, before pinch­ing some valu­able ear­rings and tak­ing off in her hat and sun­glass­es, as though the paparazzi wait­ing for her out­side. She steps off the bus as if she expects to be mobbed by a scream­ing crowd, and while treat­ing the pub­lic toi­lets as her per­son­al dress­ing room, manoeu­vres her­self with the self assur­ance of a woman who wants for nothing.

How­ev­er, we soon find out that Susan doesn’t even have a bed to sleep in. Lat­er, upon dis­cov­er­ing that the van­i­ty case con­tain­ing her only belong­ings has been stolen, she shows no sign of being a bro­ken woman; the same can be said when she finds out that her for­mer lover has been mur­dered. Her for­mi­da­ble brava­do adds to her appeal and fuels Roberta’s obses­sion. Such a char­ac­ter could sim­ply not exist in the age of social media. Susan is inde­pen­dent and self-suf­fi­cient to the extent that although she has a boyfriend, she shows no real com­mit­ment to him. She is ful­ly in con­trol of her life, going where she wants, when she wants, tak­ing what she wants (ear­rings, news­pa­pers, cig­a­rettes, clothes and cab rides) and answer­ing to no one.

A woman with curly hair, wearing a pink top and several pieces of jewellery, posing with her hands in the air against a tiled wall background.

Sei­del­man has spo­ken about the influ­ence of Jaques Rivette’s Celine and Julie Go Boat­ing on Des­per­ate­ly Seek­ing Susan, which she also noticed in Leo­ra Barish’s screen­play. The pair pay homage to Riv­ette through­out the film, most notably with the iden­ti­ty switch, the Mag­ic Club and in the sequence where Rober­ta ini­tial­ly fol­lows Susan in the same qua­si far­ci­cal way that Julie (Dominique Labouri­er) trails Celine (Juli­et Berto).

In the orig­i­nal end­ing (which can be found on cer­tain DVD ver­sions of the film), Rober­ta and Susan are seen rid­ing a pair of camels across a bar­ren desert, which only real­ly makes sense with Celine and Julie in mind. Out of con­text this final shot makes lit­tle sense, yet in light of Rivette’s influ­ence it is some­what jus­ti­fied when you con­sid­er the sig­nif­i­cance of the pyra­mid embroi­dered on Susan’s jack­et – cru­cial­ly worn in the scene not by Susan but Rober­ta. The pyra­mid is Des­per­ate­ly Seek­ing Susan’s fig­u­ra­tive White Rab­bit and with Susan now fol­low­ing, it appears the pair have switched roles and are delv­ing deep­er into their own rabbit-hole.

Fol­low­ing poor audi­ence test screen­ings, the camels were left on the cut­ting room floor. The final ver­sion of the final ends in a cin­e­ma where Susan and Jim (Robert Joy) watch Ib Melichor’s The Time Trav­ellers, in which the char­ac­ters trav­el through time and inci­den­tal­ly cre­ate mul­ti­ple selves. The rab­bit-hole the­o­ry is again sub­tly allud­ed to as the film on the cin­e­ma screen burns out, cre­at­ing its very own visu­al por­tal, per­haps invit­ing us to look fur­ther into the film, or, as Susan final­ly demon­strates, to just sit back, put your feet up and enjoy it.

You might like

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.