In defence of the superhero movies of 1997 | Little White Lies

In Praise Of

In defence of the super­hero movies of 1997

02 Apr 2017

Words by Greg Evans

Frosty figures in a blue-tinted, winter-themed scene; a woman in an elaborate fur-trimmed costume and a man in a metallic, armoured costume.
Frosty figures in a blue-tinted, winter-themed scene; a woman in an elaborate fur-trimmed costume and a man in a metallic, armoured costume.
Between them Bat­man & Robin, Spawn and Steel point­ed the way for­ward for the genre.

A lot can change in 20 years, espe­cial­ly in cin­e­ma. Take the super­hero genre for exam­ple. Today it is a colos­sal enter­prise, with con­nect­ed uni­vers­es expand­ing at an eye-water­ing rate. Giv­en the rich­ness of avail­able source mate­r­i­al it is remark­able that these mono­lith­ic block­busters often feel so unin­spired and lack­ing in diver­si­ty. Back in 1997, a trio of super­hero movies were released which, despite their many flaws, were arguably much more pro­gres­sive than their 21st cen­tu­ry counterparts.

The most noto­ri­ous of these is Joel Schumacher’s Bat­man & Robin. The director’s sec­ond Bat­man film, quick­ly com­mis­sioned fol­low­ing the box office suc­cess of 1995’s Bat­man For­ev­er, has more in com­mon with Mar­di Gras than the goth­ic grit of Tim Burton’s ear­li­er instal­ments. A com­bi­na­tion of cringe­wor­thy jokes, gar­ish sets, rub­ber nip­ples and cod­pieces turned Schumacher’s film into a mul­ti-mil­lion dol­lar laugh stock. Indeed, George Clooney and Chris O’Donnell have since admit­ted their regret at being involved in the project. The finan­cial returns were so poor that Warn­er Bros can­celled sev­er­al pro­posed sequels and the Caped Cru­sad­er did not return to the big screen until 2005 care of Christo­pher Nolan’s acclaimed reboot.

Yet Bat­man & Robin should be cel­e­brat­ed on some lev­el. Apart from a most­ly for­got­ten Super­girl movie from 1984, a big-bud­get super­hero movie had nev­er fea­tured a promi­nent hero­ine. Bat­girl, played by Ali­cia Sil­ver­stone in the 1997 film, is far from a exem­plary female char­ac­ter but hers is pos­si­bly the strongest arc in Bat­man & Robin. The film also paints her as a much more intel­li­gent indi­vid­ual than her Gotham com­rades. The X‑Men and Avengers movies would lat­er improve upon these hum­ble foun­da­tions – and it remains to see what Won­der Woman and Cap­tain Mar­vel will bring to the table – but Batgirl’s con­tri­bu­tion, although small, should not be disregarded.

With one of the most laud­ed and depend­able super­heroes falling spec­tac­u­lar­ly at the first (okay, third) hur­dle, the next big com­ic book movie of 1997 faired lit­tle bet­ter. In the 1990s Spawn was eas­i­ly the most pop­u­lar non Mar­vel or DC char­ac­ter. Cre­at­ed by Todd McFar­lane, Spawn is a CIA assas­sin who is wrong­ful­ly mur­dered and sent to hell only to forge a Faus­t­ian pact where he agrees to serve the under­world just so he can see his wife again. Admit­ted­ly the Spawn sto­ry is a lit­tle con­fus­ing, and its block­buster adap­ta­tion cer­tain­ly did lit­tle to make up for that, opt­ing to over­dose the audi­ence on the most shod­dy spe­cial effects to ever grace a $40m movie.

It’s hard to find much to praise in this quag­mire of inco­her­ence, but Spawn does hold at least one com­mend­able acco­lade: it was the first major stu­dio super­hero film to cast a black actor in a lead­ing role. Michael Jai White, who plays Spawn, clear­ly has a lot of respect for the source mate­r­i­al and tries to bring as much grav­i­tas to the role as the script allowed. White’s per­for­mance marked a wel­come depar­ture from the norm and in part set a prece­dent for 1997’s next super­hero movie.

Metallic android figure in armoured suit, holding weapon, standing in urban night setting.

When it seemed as though things couldn’t get any worse for super­hero fans, Steel hap­pened. Star­ring NBA super­star Shaquille O’Neal, the film was based on a DC char­ac­ter who wears a tech­no­log­i­cal­ly-enhanced suit of armour and wields a huge ham­mer. That’s about as inter­est­ing as our hero gets in this drab, unam­bi­tious and overblown TV movie, which is not remote­ly enjoy­able. Steel was a colos­sal flop, earn­ing just over $1m at the box office and effec­tive­ly bring­ing a pre­ma­ture end to Shaq’s act­ing career.

Still, Steel does have its sav­ing grace in the form of Anna­beth Gish, who plays Susan Sparks, a wheel­chair-bound woman who assists Steel in his fight for jus­tice. Even though the film is rid­den with clichés it does not dwell on her dis­abil­i­ty. She is sim­ply shown as an intel­li­gent and tal­ent­ed per­son who helps a friend in need, and in return is treat­ed as an equal. It’s this pos­i­tive rep­re­sen­ta­tion of dis­abil­i­ty that sets this oth­er­wise abysmal film apart.

Over­all 1997 was a dis­as­ter for super­hero movies, it took near­ly five years for the genre to com­plete­ly recov­er. In that peri­od both Blade and the first X‑Men movie were released, launch­ing two suc­cess­ful fran­chis­es fea­tur­ing black actors, both male and female, as promi­nent heroes. Fast for­ward to 2017 and we have Cyborg in the Jus­tice League, plus Fal­con and Black Pan­ther in the Avengers, albeit in sup­port­ing roles. Dis­abled parts are still lim­it­ed but Patrick Stewart’s sev­en-film run as Pro­fes­sor X proved that there is more than enough longevi­ty for a dis­abled char­ac­ter if por­trayed in the right way.

Twen­ty years ago, super­hero movies were tru­ly awful – but in their own way, they took the fledg­ling genre in a bold new direc­tion. Things have undoubt­ed­ly improved, but it’s impor­tant not to for­get that these three films pushed more bound­aries than they were giv­en cred­it for.

You might like