Shall I Compare You to a Summer’s Day –… | Little White Lies

Festivals

Shall I Com­pare You to a Summer’s Day – first-look review

14 Feb 2022

Words by Alicia Haddick

A person wearing a fishnet top and hat stands in a dimly lit room, surrounded by shadowy figures.
A person wearing a fishnet top and hat stands in a dimly lit room, surrounded by shadowy figures.
Poet­ry and per­for­mance take cen­tre stage in Moham­mad Shawky Has­san’s inven­tive chal­lenge to soci­ety’s heteronormativity.

An often-for­got­ten part of William Shakespeare’s life is the ques­tion that he may be bisex­u­al. We may nev­er know for sure with­out ask­ing the man him­self (and besides, lan­guage has evolved that such descrip­tors would need reclas­si­fy­ing in a 16th-cen­tu­ry con­text), but he cer­tain­ly liked to write about it a lot even if he didn’t feel this way. Many of the playwright’s son­nets refer to a man known as the Fair Youth’, includ­ing many of his most famous and oft-quot­ed poems and writings.

Son­net 18 is one of many writ­ings addressed to this unknown indi­vid­ual, and starts with one of the most famous lines in all his writ­ing: Shall I com­pare thee to a summer’s day?’

The unde­fin­able space that is Club Scheherazade is used for the per­for­mance of love and long­ing and its inter­sec­tion with race and queer iden­ti­ty, pre­serv­ing its desire and find­ing a space to bring it into the open with­in a world that forces such feel­ings to remain hid­den from pub­lic view.

To steal anoth­er famous Shake­speare quote, All the world’s a stage, and all the men and women mere­ly play­ers.” In this space beyond real­i­ty and with­in the meta­phys­i­cal realm, the het­ero­nor­ma­tive soci­ety that keeps the pas­sion­ate embrace of these same-sex romances hid­den in the bed­room and the clos­ets of a queer person’s heart is unleashed onto the stage in rap­tur­ous excess.

Actors are placed against green screen back­grounds and trans­port­ed into fan­tas­ti­cal realms. The inter­sect­ing accounts from one-night Grindr hook-ups and the long­ing for romance is turned into the­atre and spec­ta­cle through a queer lens. Sex­u­al plea­sure is trans­port­ed from the inti­mate space of the bed­room to a white void of posed recre­ations of sex posi­tions and pas­sion­ate three­somes, and the writ­ten flir­ta­tions of a pri­vate mes­sage is read against a sex­u­al­ly-charged pure love between men that drops the pre­tence of restraint.

In this lim­i­nal space, emo­tions replace the vis­i­tors as the pri­ma­ry dri­vers of the events. Indeed, Hassan’s fas­ci­nat­ing video piece lacks a pri­ma­ry pro­tag­o­nist, flick­ing instead between the lives and images of these men as they both address and ignore the audi­ence while reflect­ing on their love.

The clos­est thing to a cen­tral char­ac­ter comes not through a per­son but through the omnipo­tent words spo­ken above their realm of exis­tence: beyond the Shake­speare quotes accom­pa­ny­ing the start of each chap­ter are var­i­ous songs and the poet­ry of Lebanese-Aus­tralian poet Wadih Sa’adeh.

These words speak of dis­en­fran­chise­ment and alien­ation and con­trast the cathar­tic release of details and recre­ations of the past and present. Yet they speak to the film’s core mes­sage: while love can feel intense, and while drag and safe spaces like Club Scheherazade can be a loca­tion through which true iden­ti­ty comes to life, it is mere­ly an escape from a world they feel they must escape.

It’s a world they can’t escape for­ev­er. A rush to real­i­ty near the film’s cli­max reminds us of the ter­ror that can come from liv­ing true, one that’s only ampli­fied in the Arab-speak­ing world. It’s some­thing that only empha­sis­es reality’s absence from the film until that point, and the joy that could exist were Club Scheherazade even close to a rep­re­sen­ta­tion of our reality.

While per­haps lack­ing some­thing more to say beyond an account of rela­tion­ships in a space beyond our own, per­haps that’s enough. Based on the filmmaker’s expe­ri­ences and fan­tasies, these inter­twined nar­ra­tives give off a folk-like qual­i­ty that leaves you exit­ing the the­atre con­tem­plat­ing what was and what could be. It speaks to a non-exis­tent eter­nal sum­mer. But thy eter­nal sum­mer shall not fade.

You might like