Little Palestine (Diary of a Siege) – first-look… | Little White Lies

Festivals

Lit­tle Pales­tine (Diary of a Siege) – first-look review

15 Jul 2021

Elderly, weathered hand gripping a green rope against a grunge background.
Elderly, weathered hand gripping a green rope against a grunge background.
Abdal­lah Al-Khatib’s extra­or­di­nary doc­u­men­tary cap­tures dai­ly life in the largest Pales­tin­ian refugee camp.

Yarmouk is the biggest Pales­tin­ian refugee camp in Syr­ia, formed after Pales­tini­ans were oust­ed from their home­land in 1948. Abdal­lah Al-Khat­ib was born there. In 2014, with the Bashar al-Assad-led régime lay­ing siege to Yarmouk, he picked up a cam­era – one that belonged to his mur­dered friend Has­san – and doc­u­ment­ed, diary-style, the impact of the siege on the peo­ple liv­ing there.

The first per­son we meet is his moth­er Umm Mah­moud, a nurse to the elder­ly, doing the rounds with her patients. Her brisk ten­der­ness with these del­i­cate humans estab­lish­es a sense of com­mu­nal spir­it that becomes a vital source of lev­i­ty as the scenes doc­u­ment­ed become increas­ing­ly har­row­ing. There are adorable chil­dren galore in Yarmouk.

Small girls reveal, in between shy gig­gles, that they are draw­ing on the walls so that the world will see and help them. Peo­ple gath­er fre­quent­ly for ral­lies in the dusty streets, chant­i­ng and wav­ing Pales­tin­ian flags. It’s a way to fos­ter sol­i­dar­i­ty as indi­vid­ual sur­vival becomes a con­stant pressure.

Death by star­va­tion sneaks into the pic­ture, slow­ly but sure­ly, each lost soul marked by a march and the col­lec­tive cry that forms both a eulo­gy and an accu­sa­tion, I’m Case 80, I died of hunger in the siege of Yarmouk” rings out a voice as a body wrapped in a white sheet is car­ried through the streets. Al-Khat­ib films to cap­ture stark real­i­ty, but he is not sor­did or pun­ish­ing in what he shows, afford­ing pri­va­cy to his neigh­bours by nev­er show­ing the moment of death.

His voiceover knits togeth­er the scenes. His words are ele­gant, absorb­ing and damn­ing, with a per­spec­tive that folds in both psy­cho­log­i­cal and phys­i­cal sur­vival. He talks about the des­per­ate things peo­ple do, like sell­ing children’s milk, but also the way they keep com­ing togeth­er to mourn as one. Under siege, col­lec­tive pain is a qual­i­ty and a path to sur­vival,” he says. His inti­ma­cy with his sub­jects leads to inter­views with peo­ple in dire straits that do not feel exploitative.

An old man, face hol­lowed to the bone, shows the cam­era his sur­vival kit: a small pan, oil and spices. He heats water in the oil and adds spices in order to eat. Else­where pieces of cac­tus are carved up to boil into soup and a plucky lit­tle girl picks grass for her fam­i­ly. Her name is Tas­nim and she is san­guine about the sit­u­a­tion, not flinch­ing at the sounds of mor­tar explod­ing nearby.

The rea­son that peo­ple are dying of hunger is because food is being blocked at the check­point. A plan to charge at the check­point forms as days merge into each oth­er. There is lit­tle to do – apart from sur­vive – in what increas­ing­ly looks like a post-apoc­a­lyp­tic waste­land as a result of shelling. Peo­ple exchange infor­ma­tion, share rumours of food and col­lec­tive­ly mourn mar­tyrs”. The impor­tance of faith as a means of find­ing dig­ni­ty with­in great suf­fer­ing is appar­ent as in the col­lec­tive chant goes, God is greater than they are.”

It is des­per­ate­ly mov­ing to behold not just the bod­ies but the souls of these besieged Pales­tini­a­ni­ans, dri­ven from one home, only to be bombed out of exis­tence in what was sup­posed to be a place of refuge. Indeed one of the hopes that Al-Khat­ib has in releas­ing the film is that the siege of Yarmoulk will be clas­si­fied as a war crime. The mir­a­cle of what would seem to be irrefutable evi­dence of war crimes is that it is not a monot­o­nous litany of mis­ery. Indeed, it has more tonal vari­ance than many movies with lighter set-ups.

There is some­thing about Al-Khat­ib and the peo­ple of Yarmouk that trans­mutes the very best as well as the very worst aspects of human­i­ty. In one scene, deep into the siege, he asks a gag­gle of young chil­dren what they dream about. One says, the road open­ing up”. One says a chick­en sand­wich”. One says, hear­ing my grand­moth­er eat bread’. It is among the most stir­ring things I’ve ever seen: a nur­tur­ing desire in one so young and so under duress.

You might like